PHOENIX WRIGHT: ACE MAFIA

How would you die if I was protecting you? That's what protecting someone means. That you don't die. Do you mean if I died in the night? Because....you know. bulletproof.

Also, I can confirm that, at the very least, Trihan is telling the truth about the power his role has. Viola matches up with the flavor I got.

There might be a roleblocker present that would disable CAVE's powers and then the mafia could kill him off. I don't know if disablement will disable bulletproof too though.

Roleblockers only prevent people from acting, typically, not their passive abilities.

Because now you’ve come out, won’t you just get killed at night? You’re a smart player, but I’m not sure if you revealing who you’re protecting next is a good idea either. If the mafia kill you tonight, you’ve just framed Trihan =(

Mafia has to target me during two individual nightphases to kill me. That's two cop investigations/tracker tracks that would just be unstoppable if mafia chose to focus on me. Subordinates gain nothing from targeting me, and I could be watched as well, so I'm pretty confident I won't die before I reveal a scumbo.

I still don't feel that lynching Idida is a good idea today since he is going to be modkilled if he keeps this up.

I'm not really sure why Gourd_Clae said that the town is overpowered. I know that my role is, in a sense, but I don't think he expected me to use it in this fashion. There's a lot of scum for how many townies we have.

Now that our roles are out in the open, CAVE, I propose we spend whatever time we have left working together to establish a bloc.

Basically, the way I see this working is that we agree on who we want to investigate, I use my power at night to give you someone's role in exchange for voting for a person we agree is suspicious, and hopefully we'll get at least one confirmed person before one of us snuffs it. What do you think?

We all have chearlie's role. He's dead. That's why I'm not bothering with Idida now.

If I understand this correctly now and if we take everything at face value (which I always tend to do anyway) Trihan and CAVE_DOG are who they say they are. Kyrsty is not a murderer (because CAVE_DOG did not die),

But yes. That is what we're going to do tonight. This will also confirm Trihan as town if I live which is good since he himself has said that he had the ability to choose between town and mafia. The last thing I want at LYLO is some mafia princess screwing things up.

Alright. I think I've got it straight now. This is why I don't like all those weird roles since it means I basically have no idea what does what and most of the game is spent wondering what people can or cannot do.

So who do we lynch?

Do I just pick one from the scumlist? Or do I attempt to lynch myself again. (is there a role that makes you unlynchable? Would be awesome to lynch oneself and then I wouldn't be lynched muahahahaha)

CAVE, can you give me your cases for the people on your scumdar? Why do you suspect them and who are you most suspicious of?

So we get an extra Innocent thanks to Trihan (with a decent role to boot). Still a bit confused as to his role though; so basically Trihan tells CAVE to vote for a certain person, and CAVE votes the next day, but when does the role get revealed to CAVE? The night after the day CAVE votes?

Also, I'd love to know why CAVE suddenly suspects me >:(...

Okay. Marrend purely for avoiding Idida for the rest of them. He is the least scummy in my book.

Zeuzio for sounding so sure of Despite's alignment and then backpedaling in a way that seemed dishonest as well as ignoring Idida.

Idida, also, but he's probably going to get modkilled.

Mirrormasq for avoiding Idida the whole first day and then trying to retcon his post history to make it seem like he suspected him even though he mentioned him not once. Also, he said Marrend was suspicious but didn't vote him. If Mirrormasq is scum, so is Marrend.

Yellow_Magic, I don't remember. I thought he had hinted that he had more information than town. nix that. I was confusing him with this next guy.

LWG, just kidding. I don't have a case on him either. I'm still under the effect of sleeping pills. Marrend, Idida, Mirrormasq, and Zeuzio is my call for scumteam.

MINOR SCUM CASES:

Shinan: not playing his usual game as far as I can tell. This could be because this is the first time I have not tried to immediately destroy him, though.

Chana: Lurking waaaay more than usual. If any of my other scumcases fall through, I would definitely be okay with substituting Chana.

author=CAVE_DOG_IS_BACK
Yellow_Magic, I don't remember. I thought he had hinted that he had more information than town. nix that. I was confusing him with this next guy.

Oh, that was probably when I called the Doctor a Cop. Had a feeling it would look slightly suspicious :<

I'd like to take a more in-depth look at everyone's posts to date, but like Shinan said, Euro 2012. In a bit..