MAFIA: HIGURASHI NO NAKU KORO NI (GAME)

author=Liberty
I dunno, I think he's covering himself in that post, actually. Which makes me lean more towards him being independent instead of mafia.

#unlynch

My my, what does this even mean? I'm covering myself? What would the "Town" thing to do have been in your eyes? To continue the claim of "lie detector" even though it's only value was to get a very quick reaction from someone? It loses power the longer scum have to react to it. I've confirmed one townie (Despite) to everyone who has the ability to think critically and am in the process of lynching a third-party role, so what would your basis for me being either third-party or mafia be?

author=Liberty
reasoning: Because if he did have that power, he'd have put himself out there and is now trying to cover it. I think he really IS independent with a lie-detector power. He's just trying not to get aimed for by the mafia. Smart move, I guess.

Eeueuum, would it not be simpler, in the case you describe, to simply..not claim? What kind of purpose could a third-party lie detector have, anyway?

You have offered a flurry of flimsy defenses that do not stand to reason. I'm in favor of waiting for everyone to post first, but there is no reason to not lynch Liberty at the end of this day.

That's what Mad Vigilante is. Someone who kills but at less percentage the more you do it.

I guess I'll be killed off tonight now, if not beforehand by lynch-happy cave and his little friend ivory.

Nyaaa, so you're what I was in PW mafia.

Incidentally, I was not aligned with the town either.

I have zero inclination to believe that you will not stab us in the back and chainlynch townies if you are in a position to do so.

Uh... read my post. I am the second townie. You know, the one with the awesome power that Despite decided to open his big mouth about?

le sigh

Calling all cars, calling all cars. We've got some major redirection attempts going on in page 7 of the mafia thread.

If you are townie, what in the world would be your motivation for claiming independent and leading town on a wild goose chase?

Uh, protection? Since someone decided to oust my ability in such a way as to make me a hazard to mafia? Which I already said.

...that kinda ended up in a lame way. No offense.

If you've put it that way, it kinda makes sense why you're so defensive. But why do you assume you will be nightkilled after revealing your role? If you were honest earlier, then people might be more inclined to protect you. (assuming there's a doc)

author=Liberty
Wait, what? I never claimed to kill several townies at night. I said :
"I'm townie with the ability to kill one person of my choosing at night. First night, 100% hit. Second night, 50% hit, with a chance to kill someone by accident instead."

Sounds like someone's desperately trying to drum up the lynch mob.

Please, what does kill someone by accident even mean? Your night action in the first place is to kill people. It doesn't make a lick of sense.

Uh, protection? Since someone decided to oust my ability in such a way as to make me a hazard to mafia? Which I already said.

How on earth does saying you are independent if you are town protect you? First of all, in the hypothetical situation where you are town, it obfuscates discussion. Secondly, it makes town paint a target on you. Third, you claimed independent who wins WITH THE TOWN. This, while not making sense, would make you the equivalent of a townie and the mafia would have no reason to not kill you, making your 'protection' worthless.

author=Liberty
If I'd claimed townie - since there's only two and Despite already claimed the first spot - people would have known I had that power and mafia would have been gunning for me. Safer to claim Independant in that case.

Besides, I wanted to see reactions and look at who - if anyone - could be considered mafia.

...There are far more than two townies. People would have known you had what power? Why would anyone know what powers you had based on the claim of "not mafia"? What are you talking about?