DOCTER MAFIA: STOP THOSE SNATCHER SCUM!

Actually now that I think about it, yeah we're better off without him. Protecting liberty should be our top priority now. Good riddance if mafia kills him.

Chearlie, if you read correctly: If Benny doesn't protect me, that means I end up protecting him - this means he dies. THEN if mafia attack me, I have no protection, so I DIE. Then there's the Insane who might kill someone - that's three dead.
So there's a possibility that 0-3 will die - the same as last night.
0 if mafia attacks me while Benny protects me and Insane gets another good roll.

Paranoid is a good thing, though. It can create a chain of complete protection. All it takes is one random person to protect him (not letting mafia know who so they have to guess who isn't protected), and him protecting someone who needs to be kept alive. Also, if he's paranoid, he's a townie. We don't want to kill off our own.

If we really want to do this correctly we should put the plan like this: Pair off all characters. That will leave me and Benny protecting each other. Then, someone can choose to protect benny - in secret - so that he doesn't get killed off. Mafia won't know who is protecting him so they won't know which pair to target. Of course, this means there could be more than one person who changed their proper target to Benny, but again, mafia won't know WHO to target because it'd be secret.
This leaves mafia with these choices:
- Target a random pair in the hope of hitting one of the unprotected.
- Target me, in case benny decided not to protect me.
- Target Benny, in case no-one protected him.

i am truly livid

well... as I said, if TBG is town, and he doesn't protect you he is a real idiot, there is no reason of doing that, so, Target you in case he doesn't protect you is far possible scenario. Also, that they killed tbg is indeed a danger. So yeah, let's say we agree in do it in secret, the rules say, no outside chatting or private, that is bad kids (I am talking also about hacking, that is bad thing kids). So the one that would protect TBG would be based on guts, "I don't think anyone would protect him so I will), but the problem is that there would no be one, there is more possibilities that many protect TBG if it is in secret. So that would leave many of the pairs in danger and the odds of mafia killing some are almost the same.

What we can do is, TBG > Liberty, Liberty > TBG, and everyone protects himself again in order to find the Insane one, And if somebody wants to follow Liberty, you have free will, so you can vote for TBG instead of yourself.

Right, fine with me. So who are we waiting to hear from? Has everyone posted yet? I don't want to drag it on like the last day, but I don't want someone eliminated for not posting, either.

author=Liberty
We're not protecting ourselves again, Chearlie. We're protecting our partners.

With this being say I can tell you that we aren't doing this in secret, why, because yours it's a sugestion just like I said protect ourselves again and you said mine is invalid just because it is repetitive. So from now on we will shut off and follow whatever Ivory's says, except for sexual harasment.

then my bad in suggesting that again, I didn't knew it was against the rules do the same thing twice. But as I said, we can do it secretly but that depends on the ones who want to break the pairs, the problem is that they can left in danger their pairs cause we don't know for sure if just one will take the risk of breaking the formation and protect TBG. Because I don't find another way to do it secretly than one working on his own. Or maybe I haven't understand that, Also I am not trusting Ivory, is just that she has good ideas, we can do the pairs with a random genarator if you don't trust ivory but from my point of view is the same result, unless mafia has a way to know which doctor is which.

I'm not dictating anything (ok maybe i am LOL). I've simply taken the liberty to do what I can from the list. I think it's fair enough since we can juggle between the players. TBG should definitely protect liberty though.

Hmm still not satisfied with this day's posting. Can someone kick some players in the groin that would help a lot with 'posts deduction' rather than the results again thanks

Also my plan is the best.

...

ok, that blank was supposed to be---> (chearlie/liberty's post)