Full Games List
Featured Games
New Games
Reviews
Media
Images
Blogs
Game Updates
Images Feedback Summary
Game Design Highlights
Tutorials
Articles
Scripts
Utilities / Plugins
Resources
Engines
Engine Bulletins
What is Makerscore?
Past Events
Achievements
Misaos
Forums
Post History
Chat
New to RMN?
Full Store List
RMN Music Pack (free)
DOCTER MAFIA: STOP THOSE SNATCHER SCUM!
Posts
ivoryjones
75
ivoryjones
View playlists
CloseThe insane would always end up killing people even if you've paired him to other people. There would probably be 2 deaths at most since TBG is protecting liberty. If everyone protects their partner the night would go smoothly.
...Unless you think I'm scum (and I've shown, hopefully, a strong case for being CPR) then I could generate them. Of course, if you have reservations about my role, then don't worry about it.
Also, I didn't mean I'd be going against the current plan, Ivory, just that I won't automatically jump on board of every plan until I've thought it through for myself and I don't recommend anyone else does so either - for any plan by any person.
Also, I didn't mean I'd be going against the current plan, Ivory, just that I won't automatically jump on board of every plan until I've thought it through for myself and I don't recommend anyone else does so either - for any plan by any person.
ivoryjones
75
Iunno, ABAB or ABBA or whatever seems a lot better and less cluttered than randomizing.
yeah but no one has laid out any plan yet (and by lay out, i mean a plan that isn't inferior to mine) so yeah.
Time for the usual protect-your-partner-say-"aye" time.
yeah but no one has laid out any plan yet (and by lay out, i mean a plan that isn't inferior to mine) so yeah.
Time for the usual protect-your-partner-say-"aye" time.
Jeroen_Sol
Nothing reveals Humanity so well as the games it plays. A game of betrayal, where the most suspicious person is brutally murdered? How savage.
3885
So, I'll be protecting MM. Sure, why not.
author=Jeroen_Sol
@Chearlie We can't randomly generate the Pairs as there's always the possibility of the person doing it being scum.
Well, I think that's what Ivory did, just pair up people, that is random, just the same action than a ramdomly generate, Ivory could be mafia, but the point is that there is no difference if mafia, or not mafia do the list, at this mafia doesn't know who is who so they would be doing lucky guess, like saying,
Scum: "I will protect doc 3 cause I think he is the sane one" But there is no proof that he is the sane doctor cause not even doc 3 knows that
Random generator: "I will accomdate scum with doc 3" a machine doesn't know that scum is scum and that doc 3 could be the sane one, he just pair.
But also, this is going to sound scummy but it is a fact that we would have discover more if there was intention of NOT doing No Lynch, we already discovered that Liberty is most probably town, It is hard to believe otherwise. We are trying to solve this withouth killing anyone, yes, there are odds that the sane doctor gets killed, but in almost every mafia game I have played there is a sane doctor and odds of him dying. I will go for no lynch today, since pairs can only be done with 10, but tomorrow I will have no intention of doing NO LYNCH cause it is slowing us very much, the odds of 3 townies dying is not only because of mafia, town is also the cause of deaths in the night. So saying this, we need to find the insane doctor no matter what (or if that person discover his roles and decides not to use his power is also valid) and the only way I can came up in order to discover that is death, so we should stop being afraid of deaths so much.
:/ I hope my point is clear.
Fine, then we can do it like this:
ABCDDCBA or ACABDCBD or ABCDABCD or CDABDABC
That is a bit more random than ABABCDCD:
So, doing the most random one (CDAB DABC):
Rabitz:Jeroen, LWG:Gourd, Chearlie:Dudes, Ivory:Mirror and TBG:Liberty
ABCDDCBA or ACABDCBD or ABCDABCD or CDABDABC
That is a bit more random than ABABCDCD:
So, doing the most random one (CDAB DABC):
Rabitz:Jeroen, LWG:Gourd, Chearlie:Dudes, Ivory:Mirror and TBG:Liberty
Actually, allowing Mafia to pick the pairs is a bad idea because they could easily pick each other and use each other for protection: "Oh, yeah, I was protected really well/I got a PM saying that I was attacked/stopped an attack" and use that to verify their innocence.
They could also have an inkling about who is what and deliberately avoid pairing with who they might think is Insane, and buy themselves a ticket out. We don't know what mafia knows or think they know, so better safe than sorry. Hence why I proposed a more random pick than 12121212 - which is an easy pattern to figure into one's calculations. We can't know that choosing that formation is by chance or deliberate.
They could also have an inkling about who is what and deliberately avoid pairing with who they might think is Insane, and buy themselves a ticket out. We don't know what mafia knows or think they know, so better safe than sorry. Hence why I proposed a more random pick than 12121212 - which is an easy pattern to figure into one's calculations. We can't know that choosing that formation is by chance or deliberate.
Jeroen_Sol
Nothing reveals Humanity so well as the games it plays. A game of betrayal, where the most suspicious person is brutally murdered? How savage.
3885
I have no objections to Liberty's plan. It will be hardest for mafia to influence.
well, she's got a point in that of pair them together, I didn't though of that, in that way they can fake and they won't be in Insance Doctor hands.... What is #YOLOSWAG MODE!?
author=Dudesoft
I don't wNt to be paired with Gourd.
He looks too innocent in the avatar.
It's funny cause you drew it. Haha.
Also, while I would be against any one person actively telling town what to do, conisdering you are randomizing the partners, I have no problem with this plan.
