DOCTER MAFIA: STOP THOSE SNATCHER SCUM!
Posts
So, the way to analyze which role is our role is by protecting ourselves, but the only way to know that our powers work is if someone tries to lynch us, It maybe happen but I dont think that if you are naive cave will send you a PM saying, you suck you will never do your job right, I think just a protect succesfully even if nobody target you will be the PM he will send you. Although it has advantages, like TBG said, you can reduce the odds of people dying, if that's what he said. it is a really good form to protect everyone since mafia would have to guess who is the naive or the even doctor in order to have a succesful kill. Saying this we have to find another way to find out our roles, but by now for the sake of protecting town we should go for ivory's plan.
I will think for a plan. Also I won't put my NO LYNCH vote yet, I gotta feeling that the day will end to fast if we do so, I still wanna talk (since I finally can talk without so much meta or quicktopic) At the end, the day only last 5 days so let's make a good use of it even if it is only day one, day to imagine all the scenarios based in little little clues.
I will think for a plan. Also I won't put my NO LYNCH vote yet, I gotta feeling that the day will end to fast if we do so, I still wanna talk (since I finally can talk without so much meta or quicktopic) At the end, the day only last 5 days so let's make a good use of it even if it is only day one, day to imagine all the scenarios based in little little clues.
Jeroen_Sol
Nothing reveals Humanity so well as the games it plays. A game of betrayal, where the most suspicious person is brutally murdered? How savage.
3885
^I agree. Even if it is day 1, let's fully utilize it.
Oooh! I already read tbg post careful, that's what he didn't said. That CPR is a suicidal and dangerous to town o.o... so technically one doctor would die today if mafia doens't guess who is CPR.
Okay quick theory although I very sure it won't work but hypothesis can grow into better. CPR would kill himself most likely on first day. So the only way to save him is to protect him, we could do a chain of: doctor 1 protect> doc 2> doc 3. But this plan fails at this moment, doc1>scum>doc2, the scum will be sure of who he can kill. Although it would be a good form to get reactions. on the day.
Okay quick theory although I very sure it won't work but hypothesis can grow into better. CPR would kill himself most likely on first day. So the only way to save him is to protect him, we could do a chain of: doctor 1 protect> doc 2> doc 3. But this plan fails at this moment, doc1>scum>doc2, the scum will be sure of who he can kill. Although it would be a good form to get reactions. on the day.
Jeroen_Sol
Nothing reveals Humanity so well as the games it plays. A game of betrayal, where the most suspicious person is brutally murdered? How savage.
3885
^In that case CPR would kill his target, a potentially useful player. Selftargeting would be the better option.
Yes, because if CPR or the Insane kills off a proper doctor, there could be big repercussions down the road. If they kill themselves off, though - and it might sound heartless to say this, but it's true - they then take out another hazard to town win.
^I though he was a kind of a weak doctor, but yeah didn't knew that, in any case that theory would turn out worst, That's why I am sticking to ivory's one for now. Although I want to prevent CPR death, cause the only way he could be saved is that mafia kill him tonight. otherwise I am pretty sure he will die tonight.
that ^ was for jeroen, although, I have to agreed with liberty but I just hope I am not the CPR, cause it is a pretty sucky role, really suicidal.
Day 1 Votecount
Nolynch: thatbennyguy, Rabitz (2)
With ten alive, it takes six to lynch. Day 1 ends when a majority is reached or some arbitrary time on Wednesday. Four PM EST, let's say.
Also, I put this in the OP because someone asked about it: Although I will only advance to the next dayphase once I have collected all night actions, doctors can choose to not protect anyone if they want.
Nolynch: thatbennyguy, Rabitz (2)
With ten alive, it takes six to lynch. Day 1 ends when a majority is reached or some arbitrary time on Wednesday. Four PM EST, let's say.
Also, I put this in the OP because someone asked about it: Although I will only advance to the next dayphase once I have collected all night actions, doctors can choose to not protect anyone if they want.
To be honest, if every doctor saved themselves, we'd weed out the "bad" doctors like CPR. Do we want CPR anyway? No. We want reliable doctors, and we'll fire everyone else.
Coz I'm House M.D.
Coz I'm House M.D.
did lwg's internet connection broke again?
well... I don't have nothing better to add, ivory's plan is a good one and the best, what should we do now, I don't think that call for the inactive ones would do something.
Jeroen_Sol
Nothing reveals Humanity so well as the games it plays. A game of betrayal, where the most suspicious person is brutally murdered? How savage.
3885
Well, it appears nothing much has happened. Oh well, I guess Lib's right. Let's wait until everybody has posted.
I've got a MASSIVE migrane. Any doctors in the House?
I'll #nolynch for now. Not a fan of it, but I need to sleep.
I'll #nolynch for now. Not a fan of it, but I need to sleep.
author=ivoryjones
did lwg's internet connection broke again?
Hey! Nah my internet is fine, but sorry for the late reply I didn't have any time to reply earlier. Also, I've seen you try to vote me twice, you swine!
I'm pretty much looking forward to working out what doctor I am more than scum hunting at the moment to be honest, but there's a few minor innocent tells from my point of view, but nothing concrete yet, so I am paying attention.
I'm going to be no lynching for definite to day, but like Mr Chearlie said, there’s no point rushing to end a day.
Jeroen_Sol
Nothing reveals Humanity so well as the games it plays. A game of betrayal, where the most suspicious person is brutally murdered? How savage.
3885
Hiya, LWG, glad you could join. Everybody has posted now, right? I honestly don't have any scumtells at the moment. I'm going to check back on everybody's posts to see if I can deduce anything.
I like Little Wing Guy's term "towntelling". It works better than "scumhunting", because that way, instead of accusing each other madly, mafia has to act more "town" than town, which is difficult to pull off. So we should use that from now on.
Also, I'm calculating the odds of if we made a chain like MrChearlie suggested: doc1->doc2->doc3->...->doc1. It might work. I'll try and figure out the odds.
Also, I'm calculating the odds of if we made a chain like MrChearlie suggested: doc1->doc2->doc3->...->doc1. It might work. I'll try and figure out the odds.
Jeroen_Sol
Nothing reveals Humanity so well as the games it plays. A game of betrayal, where the most suspicious person is brutally murdered? How savage.
3885
Hmmm no good. I have no idea. It seems ivory is a little quick to be suspicious of Benny for posting 'those things again'
Apart from that, nothing. ivory voting for me could mean anything, and nothing much has happened apart from that.
Apart from that, nothing. ivory voting for me could mean anything, and nothing much has happened apart from that.
I don't mind ivory. Both times ivory pointed out her suspicion of me, she was completely innocent, as well as I. I've grown somewhat numb to her accusations.
Also, here are the chances of each role dying if they protect themselves:
binary even = 1/8
binary odd = 0
cpr = 7/8
insane = 9/16
naive = 1/8
paranoid = 0
sane = 0
bodyguard = 1/8
Also, here are the chances of each role dying if they protect themselves:
binary even = 1/8
binary odd = 0
cpr = 7/8
insane = 9/16
naive = 1/8
paranoid = 0
sane = 0
bodyguard = 1/8





















