Full Games List
Featured Games
New Games
Reviews
Media
Images
Blogs
Game Updates
Images Feedback Summary
Game Design Highlights
Tutorials
Articles
Scripts
Utilities / Plugins
Resources
Engines
Engine Bulletins
What is Makerscore?
Past Events
Achievements
Misaos
Forums
Post History
Chat
New to RMN?
Full Store List
RMN Music Pack (free)
MILLER'S HOLLOW MAFIA - GAME THREAD
Posts
CAVE_DOG_IS_BACK
View playlists
Closeyou son of a bitch. give me actual answer.
so here's another thing to examine: night kills are rarely wifom'd. Mirrormasq seems like an odd choice.
can someone put forth actual arguments as to why platinum should be lynched. if there's enough curse words i might believe you. but besides that, i'm assuming that someone on the scumteam didn't like these last day 1 posts of mirrormasq. wildwes doesn't make sense, because everyone was on him. it's not me because i'm town. someone case this platinum dude. otherwise i am going to assume that trihan is scum. it fits in with my recently formed worldview that says trihan is scum.
so here's another thing to examine: night kills are rarely wifom'd. Mirrormasq seems like an odd choice.
author=MirrorMasq
Platinum because of his early decisions, wildwes and Trihan because of nolynch vote (it's common to use nolynch at the first day for Liberty, so it isn't enough for me to kill her), also wildwes is just... supsicious. Don't know why. You? For the same reason I've wanted to lynch you like every game before. You're hard to read because you're playing exactly the same every single game, you always are "obviously town" and it can be dangerously deceiving, so I'm always up to lynch you before I'm completely sure you're town. And this "look at me, I'm so cute I can't be villain" won't work with me.
can someone put forth actual arguments as to why platinum should be lynched. if there's enough curse words i might believe you. but besides that, i'm assuming that someone on the scumteam didn't like these last day 1 posts of mirrormasq. wildwes doesn't make sense, because everyone was on him. it's not me because i'm town. someone case this platinum dude. otherwise i am going to assume that trihan is scum. it fits in with my recently formed worldview that says trihan is scum.
I say Dudesoft is town because he did a legitimate disappearing act (comic) and if you're scum you have responsibilities. With the fact scum out number the town, and there's a strong possibility that we have only 3 scum with how small the game is, ditching like that isn't something scum can afford.
However, given that a) that is his job, and b) he may have already discussed it and c) he's made it to the second day, he may also be scum.
I'm curious as to why MirrorMasq was targeted last night, if Adon's roleclaim is legitimate. Mirrormasq has been pointing quite a few fingers, so it might be a ploy to get those people lynched, or a legitimate attack to get rid of someone who made lead to a successful scumkill.
However, given that a) that is his job, and b) he may have already discussed it and c) he's made it to the second day, he may also be scum.
I'm curious as to why MirrorMasq was targeted last night, if Adon's roleclaim is legitimate. Mirrormasq has been pointing quite a few fingers, so it might be a ploy to get those people lynched, or a legitimate attack to get rid of someone who made lead to a successful scumkill.
PlatinumAshes is playing scum. Enough loose arguments and small comments while lurking quite heavily. It's the same kind of scum I played my first time- including the hammervote at the end of the day, which got me killed, if you recall. I know his wasn't a hammer, but he didn't rationalise it, and he was trying to get the Sheriff to be a random choice by voting Zeuzio as well.
I was trying to lynch Platinum today, but haven't raised enough support. Also Cave still needs to be lynched anyway.
author=SorceressKyrsty
PlatinumAshes is playing scum. Enough loose arguments and small comments while lurking quite heavily. It's the same kind of scum I am playing.
Also,
There has been shit ton of text and I'm struggling to find the time to consume the most of it. I've been re-reading some of the stuff from the end of the day 1 again while trying to choose between Cavedog and Dudesoft.
I am not going to start quoting posts because I'm at work and I won't have time for long sessions, or entirely dedicated to myself until next Monday. (Unless I get a chance to access pc when we're visiting my relatives on weekend.) However, I think there has to be at least one werewolf in Zeuzio bandwagon and first I was thinking of jumping the bandwagon on the beginning of day 2 to get some werewolves join, and considering it grew as fast as it did I find it unlikely Cavedog himself is one of them.
I started questioning Cave's authority at some point as he was contradicting himself and making some shallow points. Some of these being logical thought patterns presented, but you can make almost anything seem logical or illogical, regardless from the perspective. You just need to be able to convince people with good arguments.
There are more than few players here who're lynching without proper documentation. However, the fact is that they're playing bad, but their alignemnt can still be anything regardless of that. You can only perceive the alignment by comparing the actions presented each day and if people are contradicting themselves.
There's also some silly arguments that "person X wouldn't do this because it'd make him seem scum", but werewolves could always abuse these easily by actually doing whatever they want despite of it making them seem guilty, because hey, "that would be very un-werewolflike thing to do."
(For this reason most of Liberty's arguments seem entirely useless to me.)
Also, Cavedog said to Adon that if Adon was suspected, as a town player Adon should lay all his cards on the table. Now, was Cavedog doing this earlier? Perhaps not, but I'm glad to see some actual effort from him now.
I'm still holding my lynch vote on Dudesoft. I will post my arguments as soon as I find more time, which hopefully is soon. I meant to originally do so in this post, but this becaume suprisingly general very fast.
author=SorceressKyrsty
I say Dudesoft is town because he did a legitimate disappearing act (comic) and if you're scum you have responsibilities. With the fact scum out number the town, and there's a strong possibility that we have only 3 scum with how small the game is, ditching like that isn't something scum can afford.
However, given that a) that is his job, and b) he may have already discussed it and c) he's made it to the second day, he may also be scum.
I'm curious as to why MirrorMasq was targeted last night, if Adon's roleclaim is legitimate. Mirrormasq has been pointing quite a few fingers, so it might be a ploy to get those people lynched, or a legitimate attack to get rid of someone who made lead to a successful scumkill.
I doubt that the attempt on Mirrormasq was a ploy to frame anyone. For two reasons: Firstly, scum almost always just directly target whoever is gunning for them because people rarely analyze nightkills. Secondly: I am the first person to bring this up. if this was a ploy by scum to attempt to pin the nk on someone, they would have made arguments for it by now. Since the nk attempt has been ignored up until now, I think it is safe to assume that either a. they thought MM is a power role or B. didn't like his list of suspects.
I will reread PA today.
Why. Show your work!!
you lurked entirety of first day??! as in. no posts. How can you use this as an argument against PA.
Also, so which is it. Is he scum or town. all players have a responsibility to the game to..play. also this game has more lurkers than dudesoft. are you also prepared to say that trihan is town?
Also, You just said that PA has been scummily lurking according to you. But you are also saying that Dudesoft's absence makes him town (although maybe still scum!!!)
would lynch kyrsty today too
PlatinumAshes is playing scum. Enough loose arguments and small comments while lurking quite heavily. It's the same kind of scum I played my first time-
you lurked entirety of first day??! as in. no posts. How can you use this as an argument against PA.
I say Dudesoft is town because he did a legitimate disappearing act (comic) and if you're scum you have responsibilities. With the fact scum out number the town, and there's a strong possibility that we have only 3 scum with how small the game is, ditching like that isn't something scum can afford.
However, given that a) that is his job, and b) he may have already discussed it and c) he's made it to the second day, he may also be scum.
Also, so which is it. Is he scum or town. all players have a responsibility to the game to..play. also this game has more lurkers than dudesoft. are you also prepared to say that trihan is town?
Also, You just said that PA has been scummily lurking according to you. But you are also saying that Dudesoft's absence makes him town (although maybe still scum!!!)
would lynch kyrsty today too
Your looooong wall of text, CAVE, makes me suspicious of Dudesoft, but... I dunno. Hmmm... I must think on these matters (think= watch Doctor Who and play video games).
Also, where are some of the other players (Trihan, Liberty, etc.)? Lurking around or genuinely not here?
Liberty is an australian or something and too ultra-angry all the time to be scum. Trihan, however, is probably lurker scum and lurking for that reason. He is also probably Dracula.
author=CAVE_DOG_IS_BACK
What video game are you going to play, wildwes.
Probably either LoZ: Majora's Mask or LoZ: Wind Waker. Maybe PokeMMO. Why?
author=CAVE_DOG_IS_BACK
wildwes confirmed scum. adon poison this guy tonight
I'm sorry PokeMMO offends you so, CAVE. If it's that bad I won't play it, jeez.
author=CAVE_DOG_IS_BACK
Why. Show your work!!
You're asking me why I think he's town? Because none of the arguments are solid enough to consider him as anything other than town.
Jeroen_Sol
Nothing reveals Humanity so well as the games it plays. A game of betrayal, where the most suspicious person is brutally murdered? How savage.
3885
Day 2 votecount as of July 11th 20:15 GMT Summer Time:
Sheriff: - CAVE_DOG_IS_BACK
Lynch:
CAVE_DOG_IS_BACK: 4 -MirrorMasq, Yellow Magic, Dudesoft, Adon237, wildwes, MirrorMasq, Dudesoft
Dudesoft: 3 - CAVE_DOG_IS_BACK, Happy
PlatinumAshes: 0 -MirrorMasq, Dudesoft
Yellow Magic: 1 - Gourd_Clae
Adon237: 1 - Liberty
Not voting: Trihan, SorceressKyrsty, PlatinumAshes, Adon237
With 12 alive, and 1 Sheriff, it takes 7 to hammer.
Day 2 ends 12:00 GMT Summer Time, July 12, that is in a little less than 16 hours.
Sheriff: - CAVE_DOG_IS_BACK
Lynch:
CAVE_DOG_IS_BACK: 4 -
Dudesoft: 3 - CAVE_DOG_IS_BACK, Happy
PlatinumAshes: 0 -
Yellow Magic: 1 - Gourd_Clae
Adon237: 1 - Liberty
Not voting: Trihan, SorceressKyrsty, PlatinumAshes, Adon237
With 12 alive, and 1 Sheriff, it takes 7 to hammer.
Day 2 ends 12:00 GMT Summer Time, July 12, that is in a little less than 16 hours.
Jesus christ you people post fast.
I live in Scotland and have a job and responsibilities and such, so I haven't been around much lately. Sorry! Also, I am indeed simultaneously a werewolf and dracula and the tooth fairy and George Bush and a bear. I've really been away cursing the fact that I didn't get to nom on delicious MirrorMasq last night, if Adon's roleclaim is to be believed. I'm not entirely sure why MM would have been targeted as CAVE was the most likely candidate, but they obviously had a reason for it.
Honestly, I've been able to check this thread so infrequently for the 25 pages it's ballooned to that I can't remember half of what anyone said or did, so offering my own opinions on who might be scum is pretty much going to be a crapshoot. CAVE is pretty clearly town at this point; I don't think scum would intentionally draw this much attention and he does seem to have the town's best interests at heart. Adon's claim sounds legitimate and nobody has countered it; I doubt he'd have claimed witch if there were a chance that a real witch might out him, so that means MirrorMasq is town too.
That leaves YM, Dudesoft, wildwes, Happy, Gourd, Liberty, me, Kyrsty and PA.
I know I'm a werewolf, and some of the rest of you know it too. If I had to guess who my scum mates were, I'd say Gourd and Kyrsty. They've been far too quiet.
I live in Scotland and have a job and responsibilities and such, so I haven't been around much lately. Sorry! Also, I am indeed simultaneously a werewolf and dracula and the tooth fairy and George Bush and a bear. I've really been away cursing the fact that I didn't get to nom on delicious MirrorMasq last night, if Adon's roleclaim is to be believed. I'm not entirely sure why MM would have been targeted as CAVE was the most likely candidate, but they obviously had a reason for it.
Honestly, I've been able to check this thread so infrequently for the 25 pages it's ballooned to that I can't remember half of what anyone said or did, so offering my own opinions on who might be scum is pretty much going to be a crapshoot. CAVE is pretty clearly town at this point; I don't think scum would intentionally draw this much attention and he does seem to have the town's best interests at heart. Adon's claim sounds legitimate and nobody has countered it; I doubt he'd have claimed witch if there were a chance that a real witch might out him, so that means MirrorMasq is town too.
That leaves YM, Dudesoft, wildwes, Happy, Gourd, Liberty, me, Kyrsty and PA.
I know I'm a werewolf, and some of the rest of you know it too. If I had to guess who my scum mates were, I'd say Gourd and Kyrsty. They've been far too quiet.
i could not bear the after-game gloating if trihan was a werewolf, claimed it in thread, and then lived to the end of the game. we have to kill him. to satisfy honor.
i think i want to lynch kyrsty over dudesoft.
i think i want to lynch kyrsty over dudesoft.
