PHOENIX MAFIA: ONLINE TURNABOUT
Posts
I could post a giant case about how it's liberty but we could also save me the trouble and just lynch her now.
wildwes please. my hands are tired.
every time i lead the town in lynching people we inevitably win the game. this time will be no different. except hopefully people will just blindly trust in me this time because i have a LOT of always sunny episodes to watch
every time i lead the town in lynching people we inevitably win the game. this time will be no different. except hopefully people will just blindly trust in me this time because i have a LOT of always sunny episodes to watch
well I mean we have a little less than 72 hours, just check back and explain your reasoning before the day ends if you would. We'll just continue babbling or being silent over here while you marathon your show.
Blindly trusting and going along with a lynch, whether it works or not, tends to look extremely suspicious. No one in their right mind's just gonna go along with you for fear of looking suspect anyways.
Blindly trusting and going along with a lynch, whether it works or not, tends to look extremely suspicious. No one in their right mind's just gonna go along with you for fear of looking suspect anyways.
Liberty's posts remind me why I don't like vigilantes, and Cave, don't be ridiculous: the things you write in these threads are too entertaining to not read.

I want to hear (read) people's thoughts. The more Liberty talks, the more I feel she's town. I know my "reads" on people don't mean anything in a game of mafia; nobody's does. The "feels" are simply all we have to go on.
Cave, please post your reasons for disagreeing with my opinion on Liberty.
Also, I've forgotten something. Cave, what is your feeling on Yellow Magic, and why haven't you mentioned him today?

Cave, please post your reasons for disagreeing with my opinion on Liberty.

Also, I've forgotten something. Cave, what is your feeling on Yellow Magic, and why haven't you mentioned him today?

I've already given mine: I don't think we are in any better of a position than on day 1, unless someone is with holding something they found out in the night. Which I know from personal experience, might be the right way to go about it
Also, I've forgotten something. Cave, what is your feeling on Yellow Magic, and why haven't you mentioned him today?
Out of all the players in this game, I've only talked with wildwes today, and mentioned liberty. this day just started. why would I be mentioning yellow magic at all, except to get him to answer the coin question.
I think he's town now, fwiw. we've had very similar reads on players.
Yellow Magic hasn't seen anything unusual from Liberty thus far. Voting to no-lynch on the first day is a bad thing to do, but most people here seem to think it's okay for some reason. I doubt everyone is Mafia otherwise Yellow Magic would have lost by now.
Why does it matter whether CAVE_DOG has mentioned Yellow Magic or not? Yellow Magic hasn't mentioned Mr_SuNa the whole game (Yellow Magic says hi, Mr_SuNa).
Why does it matter whether CAVE_DOG has mentioned Yellow Magic or not? Yellow Magic hasn't mentioned Mr_SuNa the whole game (Yellow Magic says hi, Mr_SuNa).
Yellow Magic is never answering the coin question
yellow magic will be dead before lylo unless the matter of the coins is settled
That's fine. I'm not Yellow Magic.
Okay, I'll buy that. I've reread the thread, and there is absolutely nothing useful. Everyone except for SuNa, MK, Dudesoft and Ratty has flip-flopped on an opinion at least once. MK never posts often, so his lack of participation here isn't very useful or telling. Ratty and Dudesoft have posted the least. Of them, Ratty has had the most to say.
I agree with YellowMagic that Ratty's comment's seem questionable. "I didn't even know he was here," almost feels like it could be a denial.

I agree with YellowMagic that Ratty's comment's seem questionable. "I didn't even know he was here," almost feels like it could be a denial.

LockeZ
I'd really like to get rid of LockeZ. His play style is way too unpredictable. He's always like this too. If he ran a country, he'd just kill and imprison people at random until crime stopped.
5958
I might regret this tomorrow but
#lynch Liberty
If someone else suggests a lynch with a better reason than "because she is glancing to the left slightly when she talks" then I will probably change my vote, but at this point, as I predicted, we are in the same situation as yesterday with no more information and one less person. So right now I'm willing to defer to the person with better people-reading skills than me, while continuing my already-explained plan of trying to avoid no-lynches. (the plan to choose a target based on metagame info being abandoned since no one wants to do that and since there's a better criteria now)
#lynch Liberty
If someone else suggests a lynch with a better reason than "because she is glancing to the left slightly when she talks" then I will probably change my vote, but at this point, as I predicted, we are in the same situation as yesterday with no more information and one less person. So right now I'm willing to defer to the person with better people-reading skills than me, while continuing my already-explained plan of trying to avoid no-lynches. (the plan to choose a target based on metagame info being abandoned since no one wants to do that and since there's a better criteria now)
Any particular reason you chose Liberty?
You could have chosen MajoracanKing, or Ratty, or Dudesoft, who each haven't posted enough to count on one hand. MajoracanKing might barely have enough posts to require a second hand for counting. Lack of posting if not an indicator of scum, is generally bad for town. Why not one of them?
Cave voted YellowMagic: you voted YellowMagic.
I voted Cave (I'm told I technically don't have a vote, but then have a power that counts as two votes): You voted Cave.
Cave votes Liberty: you vote Liberty.
You haven't just bandwagoned. You've followed the discussion leaders like a lost puppy. Would you care to explain this phenomenon?

You could have chosen MajoracanKing, or Ratty, or Dudesoft, who each haven't posted enough to count on one hand. MajoracanKing might barely have enough posts to require a second hand for counting. Lack of posting if not an indicator of scum, is generally bad for town. Why not one of them?

Cave voted YellowMagic: you voted YellowMagic.
I voted Cave (I'm told I technically don't have a vote, but then have a power that counts as two votes): You voted Cave.
Cave votes Liberty: you vote Liberty.

You haven't just bandwagoned. You've followed the discussion leaders like a lost puppy. Would you care to explain this phenomenon?

author=pianotm
I agree with YellowMagic that Ratty's comment's seem questionable. "I didn't even know he was here," almost feels like it could be a denial.
More like I completely glanced over his posts since I had no apparent reason to pay attention to him, but yeah maybe I should have. ('^_^ )
















