[FINISHED] KLOE THE MURDERER MAFIA

Posts

pianotm
The TM is for Totally Magical.
32388
Shinan
However a classic scum tactic when someone innocent is being lynched is to say they are on the fence just before the deadline arrives. "I'm not so sure about this..." but still vote to lynch the person they know to be innocent.


Umm...this is true, and this is exactly what Crystal-Mint is doing.
pianotm
The TM is for Totally Magical.
32388
NeverSilent, I guess could be, also, but I don't see this nearly as much from him.
Kloe
I lost my arms in a tragic chibi accident
2236
(I said that since I thought you should explain since otherwise you'd look very random, people usually explain their lynches...)

Piano grabs the chair and trys to use it to open the cellar, he breaks the chair but alas, this is one strong door and despite the sacrifice of the chair, the door remains locked and closed.
What's the point of a random lynch if I explain it right away. It's all about gauging how people react to it.
pianotm
The TM is for Totally Magical.
32388
And Kloe, herein comes another problem with roleplay in Mafia: the moderator interacting with the players too much. I remember a player letting Liberty have it for doing this.

Now, you have inadvertently implicated Shinan as scum (he still might not be, but you've helped to cultivate that appearance with the cannibalism flavor on RabitZ death), and you have practically confirmed NeverSilent as town.
Ratty524
The 524 is for 524 Stone Crabs
12986
author=Shinan
Actually I have out of game knowledge that neversilent is probably not a werewolf.

Since Kloe on Slack was aghast and said "why did you vote to randomlynch neversilent"

Of course this might be some mastermind psychological trick though I don't think so. It "seemed" like a spontaneous remark.

However a classic scum tactic when someone innocent is being lynched is to say they are on the fence just before the deadline arrives. "I'm not so sure about this..." but still vote to lynch the person they know to be innocent.

A bit of a flipflop to say "I have out of game knowledge that NS isn't scum" and then say "yep he is" with that last paragraph. However...

author=pianotm
Umm...this is true, and this is exactly what Crystal-Mint is doing.

This could hold true. The fact she was pretty quick to come to defense against my admittingly misinformed accusation of her raises my suspicions. I mean, the other option could have just been not to say anything at all and let Kloe clear up the "Psychopath" ordeal, but she didn't do that.
Kloe
I lost my arms in a tragic chibi accident
2236
(I don't understand, I didn't think I did that!?)
No. I'm just saying that what NS did in the post I quoted was scummy behaviour and that was the reasoning behind my lynch vote. That was the info I had at the time of my lynch vote too.
I'm not really saying that I'm unsure, just that we should probably wait for an explanation before jumping to conclusions! Maybe Shinan just thought it was self-explanatory and didn't realize it wasn't (just like in the case of LockeZ). However, his explanation still seems pretty far fetched so I'll keep my vote on him.
author=Ratty524
This could hold true. The fact she was pretty quick to come to defense against my admittingly misinformed accusation of her raises my suspicions. I mean, the other option could have just been not to say anything at all and let Kloe clear up the "Psychopath" ordeal, but she didn't do that.

Is quick here referring to my speed at responding? I was just really confused by your accusation xD
Shinan what are your thoughts?
Ratty524
The 524 is for 524 Stone Crabs
12986
author=Shinan
No. I'm just saying that what NS did in the post I quoted was scummy behaviour and that was the reasoning behind my lynch vote. That was the info I had at the time of my lynch vote too.

You just said you have out-of-game knowledge that NS is "probably not a werewolf" and yet you are still pushing for his lynch. Can you see why I can't trust you in that regard?

author=Crystal-Mint
Is quick here referring to my speed at responding? I was just really confused by your accusation xD

That and you were the first to reply to it.
author=Ratty524
author=Crystal-Mint
Is quick here referring to my speed at responding? I was just really confused by your accusation xD

That and you were the first to reply to it.

Oh yeah, I've been really active today due to having a lot of free time at school! Most of my classes were basically free periods so I just saw your post right away ;v;
author=Ratty524
author=Shinan
No. I'm just saying that what NS did in the post I quoted was scummy behaviour and that was the reasoning behind my lynch vote. That was the info I had at the time of my lynch vote too.
You just said you have out-of-game knowledge that NS is "probably not a werewolf" and yet you are still pushing for his lynch. Can you see why I can't trust you in that regard?

Yeah I get it. I just don't see a point in canceling a lynch. I'll just change my vote when someone better comes along to kill.

Currently I'm most curious about what LockeZ take is on all this. If he doesn't ragequit due to Kloe's "interfering" with the neutrality of the game I can't wait to see what he has to say or if he has any useful information.
pianotm
The TM is for Totally Magical.
32388
Shinan
No. I'm just saying that what NS did in the post I quoted was scummy behaviour and that was the reasoning behind my lynch vote. That was the info I had at the time of my lynch vote too.


So do you still think he's scum?

Crystal-Mint
Ratty524
Crystal-Mint
Is quick here referring to my speed at responding? I was just really confused by your accusation xD

That and you were the first to reply to it.
Oh yeah, I've been really active today due to having a lot of free time at school! Most of my classes were basically free periods so I just saw your post right away ;v;


Yeah, given the nature of mafia, I'm not a big fan of reading timing-of-reply as a scum-tell.

Hmm...

Shinan
Actually I have out of game knowledge that neversilent is probably not a werewolf.


Ratty524
*ahem*
"I am Ratty MacLeod of the Clan MacLeod. I was born in 1518 in the village of Glenfinnan on the shores of Loch Shiel. And I am immortal."


http://www.werewolves.com/do-werewolves-age/
...they are virtually immortal...


pianotm
The TM is for Totally Magical.
32388
Shinan
Yeah I get it. I just don't see a point in canceling a lynch. I'll just change my vote when someone better comes along to kill.

Currently I'm most curious about what LockeZ take is on all this. If he doesn't ragequit due to Kloe's "interfering" with the neutrality of the game I can't wait to see what he has to say or if he has any useful information.


Oh, never mind my question.

And I'm waiting on LockeZ, too.
InfectionFiles
the world ends in whatever my makerscore currently is
4622
#lynch Shinan

You have been acting strangely and scummy the whole game
You also don't like explaining yourself and generally act silly because if you are town then you're just being weird.

Also, you started with the Frogge lynch so I dont want whoever you randomly lynch be a target. Not again!

So, I'm with the others and suspected you and Ratty the most after how you both have been acting. Since it's in majority for you that's where my vote goes for now.

And poor YM. I kinda missed that whole thing.
What's with the bloody knife LockeZ what's the purpose?
Ratty524
The 524 is for 524 Stone Crabs
12986
author=Shinan
Yeah I get it. I just don't see a point in canceling a lynch. I'll just change my vote when someone better comes along to kill.

Currently I'm most curious about what LockeZ take is on all this. If he doesn't ragequit due to Kloe's "interfering" with the neutrality of the game I can't wait to see what he has to say or if he has any useful information.

Interesting, why do you value LockeZ's position in particular? After all, there are two other people (OddRabbit and Gourde) who haven't really provided any input on this either. How does LockeZ differ from them?

@pianotm: Werewolves die from silver, not from heads been cut off (or can it?)
pianotm
The TM is for Totally Magical.
32388
Ratty524
Interesting, why do you value LockeZ's position in particular? After all, there are two other people (OddRabbit and Gourde) who haven't really provided any input on this either. How does LockeZ differ from them?


Because LockeZ has been the most vocal in his opinions of the game and how it should be played. With YM out, that makes Shinan the most experienced player here. He'd of course want the input of the players who have demonstrated the most skill in past games and the current one. I feel the same way. I bet LockeZ does, too.

Also, a little meta is agreeable in determining other player's behaviors and styles, and anyone who's been keeping up with the recent mafias can see that oddRabbit is playing the way he usually does. So is Gourd_Clae.

@pianotm:Werewolves die from silver, not from heads been cut off (or can it?)


As I understand it, beheading something is usually pretty effective. It works on vampires, at least. It doesn't work on Deadpool, though...and probably not Wolverine, Sabertooth, or X-23.