ULTIMA FANTASY MAFIA - GAME ON! [POSTGAME]

I think the optimal use would be disguising scum as a town. Like if someone disguised as the seer roleclaimed right before their death, infodumped, then flipped seer, everyone would believe their info. Not to mention they'd be immune to scouting from the seer.

author=psy_wombats
I think the optimal use would be disguising scum as a town. Like if someone disguised as the seer roleclaimed right before their death, infodumped, then flipped seer, everyone would believe their info. Not to mention they'd be immune to scouting from the seer.

This is a good point actually. I'm very nervous of mafia somehow knowing cave was the seer in the beginning.

Yeah it's possible that scum might be the recipient. But if that's the case and we're already about to lynch an innocent person, then there's nothing to lose by sharing who you gave it to, even if they deny it. Worst case scenario, if one person denies they got the sword from another, then we know one of those two people is definitely scum.

I wonder if blob would let us get to = numbers of mafia to town. I guess his answer was vague enough to allow for that possibility but that's traditionally not a possibility because it puts in situation where the two teams will just vote against each other and it's left up to luck. >.<

@Gourd: Mafia doesn't necessarily have to do that, they just need to wait for a town to slip up and vote against the other town. Then it's hammer time. Can't do that if Tung's not around though

e

@tunger That dismissal of my vote on Kloe might be more effective if I didn't express interest in Kloe day 1, then agreed with IF on Day 2 (before LockeZ said anything), then was one of the only 3 that bothered to vote for her. Unlike you. Or psy.

In case you couldn't tell those are the two people I suspect today.

Mainly because LockeZ didn't have to be the first vote on Kloe at all if he was mafia, though I guess it's possible she was annoying him and he saw a chance to get an almost guaranteed win. I don't really think that's the case though.

Gourd is probably the towniest person in this game to me, though to be honest that's probably true in almost every game he's in, regardless of whether he's town or scum. He's extremely good at appearing friendly and helpful and calm and collected. But it seems very genuine! If I'm being forced to trust someone, I think Gourd's my choice right now.

Psy is acting similarly, the one thing that really worries me is the crazy story about losing the sword.

Tunger just deserves to die one way or the other. I refuse to let him be the last person standing in this game. I'm not sure if the final scum is him or psy, but at least if it's psy, I can say I was beaten by cleverness instead of by someone who was AFK.

#lynch TungerManU

Tunger still seems like the best choice to me, especially after ratty defend him yesterday. But, then again, I wonder if the black mage made ratty flip mafia specifically to create more suspicion regarding tunger.

Tung I really wish you hadn't denied you had the sword.

Gourd your reasoning's believable. There's one case I considered where LockeZ voted against Kloe because she was the actual white mage deceit'd to look like thief, so he'd be vindicated when she flipped. Not likely but w/e. I think I'm going to go crazy trying to figure out all the possible scenarios where Ratty or Kloe were not real mafia. All of them lead to the same thing anyway: 2v2 today. We'd only be able to win by RNG so it might just be more honorable to die anyway.

That does leave the question of what exactly scum did with deceit. Probably just cast it on the assassin to make them immune to the seer? Is there any other possible use?

We should also keep in mind that with some cooperation from the order of operations, Odd could've killed Ratty and now isn't around to claim credit.

LockeZ, PM Blob about whether hitting white mage protection generates a public message. There's no PM copypasting but I should be vindicated. I still don't understand why it's not possible for him to announce this in thread.