COTTON MAFIA (CONGRATULATIONS!)

Hexatona
Piano, you can either keep pointing your finger at me, or you can actually put up a lynch command. Shit or get off the pot.

Okay. I wasn't completely sure, but I was going to vote for you after this comment, but thank Shinan.

author=Shinan
I don't really see Hexatona's jump on my idea. Unless I'm not reading something that is obviously there.

You mean you didn't see the synergy between you two?

There's a lose-lose in this massive tie situation too. The first one to make someone have a majority of votes against them will be incredibly suspicious. So either someone paints a target on themselves in order to only kill one person or lots of people are going to die!

Oh, bullshit! You know perfectly well this is day 1. "Oh, if you kill someone on day 1, you're scummy!" How fucking stupid do you think we are?

I can dig it.

Well, let me oblige.

#lynch Shinan

author=pianotm
Might have been a joke, but Hex seemed a little more anxious to jump on shinan's tie vote idea than I'm comfortable with. Of course, a 13 way tie would be nigh impossible, so I doubt she was serious, but still, she seemed to be considering the real ramifications. Outside of that, her participation in the game has more been observing the game than the people. I feel like she's avoiding direct interaction.

author=Shinan
I don't really see Hexatona's jump on my idea. Unless I'm not reading something that is obviously there.

There's a lose-lose in this massive tie situation too. The first one to make someone have a majority of votes against them will be incredibly suspicious. So either someone paints a target on themselves in order to only kill one person or lots of people are going to die!

I can dig it.

What if Shinan and Hex are both scum? I think that's why Hex jumped into Shinans idea and why Shinan seems so intent on a multikill on day 1.

#Lynch Hexatona

Guys, start lynching Shinan and Hexatona. >_>

Piano, you're so paranoid, you'll be throwing cats at the mailman tomorrow - but if it makes you happy then I'll go back to what I had previously.

What confuses me is you're jumping on the person who was obviously joking when Cave dog literally said something insane and you're going to ignore it.

#lynch CAVE_DOG_IS_BACK

and it'll stay that way until they stop abusing logic so terribly

author=CAVE_DOG_IS_BACK
neither of those things are scummy

How isn't this scummy? They want a lot of people to die on day 1, that can only be scummy.

@Piano Keep and eye on CAVE,he'll probably try to pull off some crazy stuff if he pulled scum this game.

Why do you keep saying they? Are you referring to me and Shinan? Why!? I've been against this whole thing from first mention!

author=Hexatona
You know, with that many people with 1 vote, anyone could come out and lynch whoever they wanted with a single vote at the last minute - or, vote to brouden the damage to something almost unrecoverable.

author=OzzyTheOne

author=CAVE_DOG_IS_BACK
i also want a lot of people to die on day 1

This is too random for my taste

#cancel
#Lynch CAVE_DOG_IS_BACK

its literally a response to something you just said and is also consistent with my train of thought concerning my ultimate plan. so please point out how it is random.

Hexatona
Piano, you're so paranoid, you'll be throwing cats at the mailman tomorrow - but if it makes you happy then I'll go back to what I had previously.

I beg your pardon? I've made some mild observations about you and that's "so paranoid" I'll be "throwing cats at the mailman"? You're way more defensive than you should be. If you can't handle some scumhunting, time to play a different game.

What confuses me is you're jumping on the person who was obviously joking

Meanwhile, you pass over the part where Shinan literally makes the statement that anyone who breaks the tie is scum. This is a convenient misdirect and a logical leap that inexperienced players will readily fall in line with.

when Cave dog literally said something insane and you're going to ignore it.

Insanity is not a scum tell, but it is a commonly used play-style.

OzzyTheOne

CAVE_DOG_IS_BACK
neither of those things are scummy

How isn't this scummy? They want a lot of people to die on day 1, that can only be scummy.

I have to agree. Having personally attempted to pull this move in a previous game, I can promise you from the bottom of my heart that deliberate tie-lynching is a scum-move.

i've devised a way to kill a lot of town and also win us the game.

being scummy is not saying things like "i want to murder people in this game.' thats not how mafia "works"