COTTON MAFIA (CONGRATULATIONS!)
Posts
Shinan
Alright I haven't kept up with how the votes are right now, but am I correct in assuming that we still only have guys on one vote against them?
Actually, I thought the tie should have been broken when I voted for you. With my cancel and now voting on YM, the tie is definitely broken now.
Hexatona
Is Cavedog's admission to not looking at their role PM some kind of sly trick to make anything he says come across as town? It's like making sure you have an alibi for when night comes.
He's pulled this in a past game. Sorry...getting some therapy. Will finish this thought in a bit.
#lynch Hextona
Reading back now and my reasons are trying to seem helpful/scum hunt with some half ass lists and then again saying "I'm gonna sit back and watch the pros" when I believe he would know better or at least not actually see themself as a bad/newbie player.
If Hexatona is not confident in their ability and did roll scum then I think their play would instead of actually being quiet and watching is posing as "investigative" while trying to blend town.
Reading back now and my reasons are trying to seem helpful/scum hunt with some half ass lists and then again saying "I'm gonna sit back and watch the pros" when I believe he would know better or at least not actually see themself as a bad/newbie player.
If Hexatona is not confident in their ability and did roll scum then I think their play would instead of actually being quiet and watching is posing as "investigative" while trying to blend town.
Sorry, Hex, I was getting blood drawn AND getting some physical therapy. As I was saying, Cave has pulled the "unread PM" thing in a previous game. It turned out he was town (and had lied about not looking at his PM). I don't know what to make of the claim. It could be either way.
damnit I'm too tired
#lynch hexatona
to make it official lol
#lynch hexatona
to make it official lol
author=pianotm
Sorry, Hex, I was getting blood drawn AND getting some physical therapy. As I was saying, Cave has pulled the "unread PM" thing in a previous game. It turned out he was town (and had lied about not looking at his PM). I don't know what to make of the claim. It could be either way.
this is not what happened. I really had not looked at my role PM. also, I said it was 'time to look at my role pm' earlier, indicating that I have read it since. Either way, it was a 'joke' that was supposed to be the punchline to the whole "i am confirmed town" thing. i was thinking about saying "hooo oboy are you guys lucky you didn't kill yourselves' but considering the frequency with which people take serious posts to be jokes and jokeposts to be serious in this very thread, I am sure someone would have wanted to kill me for that.
i'm not voting for hex d1 and anyone who does is scum irl
@Piano:
- You can't really compare Ozzy's post with LockeZ's. LockeZ made it out like he discovered the entire scum team. All Ozzy did was place a singular vote on me and then say "not feeling it", and then cancel. Maybe my funnyman skills are lacking but how is Ozzy's post at all a joke? Or is it really just not a joke post that wasn't funny?
Re: Ivory's post - absolutely zero context to her vote, making it seem an actual joke post.
- My interaction with Shinan was like, one question to him asking why he'd vote for me over CAVE_DOG. I'm not really seeing your point there.
- You can't really compare Ozzy's post with LockeZ's. LockeZ made it out like he discovered the entire scum team. All Ozzy did was place a singular vote on me and then say "not feeling it", and then cancel. Maybe my funnyman skills are lacking but how is Ozzy's post at all a joke? Or is it really just not a joke post that wasn't funny?
Re: Ivory's post - absolutely zero context to her vote, making it seem an actual joke post.
- My interaction with Shinan was like, one question to him asking why he'd vote for me over CAVE_DOG. I'm not really seeing your point there.
ivory isnt yelling at people so she may be scum this game
I can't remember Gourd posting in this game so far, which is concerning.
It's possible - they are the least active person in this whole game. Ivory might be trying to wait out day 1?
Anyway, it makes for a better case than infection, anyway.
#Cancel
#Lynch Ivory
I'm just putting up lynches as we go along, because I might not be able to be back on thread as much this afternoon.
I'll be checking in as I can.
Anyway, it makes for a better case than infection, anyway.
#Cancel
#Lynch Ivory
I'm just putting up lynches as we go along, because I might not be able to be back on thread as much this afternoon.
I'll be checking in as I can.
author=Yellow Magic
I can't remember Gourd posting in this game so far, which is concerning.
Actually, Gourd's posted in fits and spurts. Just not in the last little bit, I think.
also I gotta say this: 48 hours is way too short for dayphase on d1.
LockeZ
I'd really like to get rid of LockeZ. His play style is way too unpredictable. He's always like this too. If he ran a country, he'd just kill and imprison people at random until crime stopped.
5958
I also voted for the game's moderator as one of my three lynches in that post, just in case the stupidity wasn't clear enough already.
However in past games I've definitely voted for someone and then cancelled it in the same post as a serious thing rather than a joke. It obviously doesn't count as a lynch but it still sends a message. It makes the person feel threatened and gets them to respond.
However in past games I've definitely voted for someone and then cancelled it in the same post as a serious thing rather than a joke. It obviously doesn't count as a lynch but it still sends a message. It makes the person feel threatened and gets them to respond.
author=Yellow Magic
@Piano:
- You can't really compare Ozzy's post with LockeZ's. LockeZ made it out like he discovered the entire scum team. All Ozzy did was place a singular vote on me and then say "not feeling it", and then cancel. Maybe my funnyman skills are lacking but how is Ozzy's post at all a joke? Or is it really just not a joke post that wasn't funny?
And what context did Ozzy's post have?
Re: Ivory's post - absolutely zero context to her vote, making it seem an actual joke post.
Except her vote is still on you, and given the fact that she's not going to wake up for awhile yet, I doubt that vote is coming off this day phase. Why dismiss her in favor of someone who hasn't actually voted for you, who's first actual scum accusations have been against Hex, Shinan, and CAVE; people who are decidedly NOT you? How can you say that Ozzy's "vote" on you wasn't a joke post, but ivory's vote was, how did that end up being scummier than anything else he did?
- My interaction with Shinan was like, one question to him asking why he'd vote for me over CAVE_DOG. I'm not really seeing your point there.
And you also pointed out who you think should live in such a scenario, and I commented on it. Just think; if you had just ignored me, who was just making passing observations, my vote would still be on Shinan, and we wouldn't be having this conversation.
since when is someone accusing you of being scum a good enough reason to suspect them on its own
also kill oddrabbit
also kill oddrabbit
LockeZ
I also voted for the game's moderator as one of my three lynches in that post, just in case the stupidity wasn't clear enough already.
However in past games I've definitely voted for someone and then cancelled it in the same post as a serious thing rather than a joke. It obviously doesn't count as a lynch but it still sends a message. It makes the person feel threatened and gets them to respond.
I've done the same thing. But Cave doesn't remember anyone doing it, so we must have imagined it. Sarcasm aside, I feel like if YM is taking Ozzy's post seriously, he should be taking yours seriously too, because frankly, they were equally absurd.
I'm going to vote now (takes the time to write out a vote), and meh, don't feel like it (cancels vote). YM takes that seriously? Especially, of all people, level headed, focused YM?
LockeZ
I'd really like to get rid of LockeZ. His play style is way too unpredictable. He's always like this too. If he ran a country, he'd just kill and imprison people at random until crime stopped.
5958
If Ozzy's goal was to provoke a reaction from Yellow Magic, I'd say it's succeeded.
LockeZ
If Ozzy's goal was to provoke a reaction from Yellow Magic, I'd say it's succeeded.
Yeah. Exactly. And honestly, I don't think that was Ozzy's goal at all. YM's response just looks really overkill. Ozzy hasn't even really addressed YM since except to ask why his posts seemed manufactured.
author=pianotmLockeZI've done the same thing. But Cave doesn't remember anyone doing it, so we must have imagined it. Sarcasm aside, I feel like if YM is taking Ozzy's post seriously, he should be taking yours seriously too, because frankly, they were equally absurd.
I also voted for the game's moderator as one of my three lynches in that post, just in case the stupidity wasn't clear enough already.
However in past games I've definitely voted for someone and then cancelled it in the same post as a serious thing rather than a joke. It obviously doesn't count as a lynch but it still sends a message. It makes the person feel threatened and gets them to respond.
I'm going to vote now (takes the time to write out a vote), and meh, don't feel like it (cancels vote). YM takes that seriously? Especially, of all people, level headed, focused YM?
i can't remember anyone else doing it in seriousness you dork, which is what ozzy's post reads like. there's no hint of "humor" and he only clarifies that it's a joke later. time moves from the past to the future. the fact that I didn't recognize it as a joke either should tell you that your case is hot air.
Piano is acting like me whenever I spot something I think is uber scummy and is absolutely determined to get to the bottom of the mystery - hell, I guess I'm doing it right now with Ozzy...
#cancel
....have you actually seen me play Mafia before?
#cancel
author=pianotm
Especially, of all people, level headed, focused YM?
....have you actually seen me play Mafia before?

















