[MAFIA] RMN: WHEN THEY CRY (TEA PARTY)
Posts
Jeroen_Sol
Nothing reveals Humanity so well as the games it plays. A game of betrayal, where the most suspicious person is brutally murdered? How savage.
3885
Alright, I guess that sounds plausible. I'll wait for demon to come back though.
When I get off work, I'm going to go over all of Ozzy's, Cap's and YM's posts with a fine comb to see if I can find any potential proof of collaboration.
When I get off work, I'm going to go over all of Ozzy's, Cap's and YM's posts with a fine comb to see if I can find any potential proof of collaboration.
author=Yellow Magic
Regarding scenario 2, LOL I'm not the type to risk throwing a game by being cocky. I'm still trying to figure out what Mafia would gain by not choosing to kill demonlord.
Hm It makes sense but as u could see demonlord was ready to vote me and jore is the one who thinks about the game most. Also, It would be more logical for to protect demonlord.
Tbh i protected jero because i expected mafia to kill demonlord, who could ruin the game by voting me in lylo.
Jeroen_Sol
Nothing reveals Humanity so well as the games it plays. A game of betrayal, where the most suspicious person is brutally murdered? How savage.
3885
If you expected demon to get killed, then what was the added benefit of protecting me over not protecting?
Jeroen_Sol
Nothing reveals Humanity so well as the games it plays. A game of betrayal, where the most suspicious person is brutally murdered? How savage.
3885
author=Yellow Magic
Needless to say I'm at a loss.
Demonlord, Jeroen, can you remind me what makes you confirmed Defender and gunmen? I feel like quite frankly we're being playing like a fiddle, so it's hard to believe anything now.
About the being played like a fiddle thing. I thought this was a catchphrase of yours, but the only other time I found you using it was Cheesecake mafia. A game in which you were scum.
Jeroen_Sol
Nothing reveals Humanity so well as the games it plays. A game of betrayal, where the most suspicious person is brutally murdered? How savage.
3885
I should note that the actual phrase itself is less important than the following:
I seem to remember that acting thoroughly confused and bewildered on the final day is your scum MO. I'm going to read some older games when I get off work to see if I'm right, but I do recall you doing this more than once before.
I seem to remember that acting thoroughly confused and bewildered on the final day is your scum MO. I'm going to read some older games when I get off work to see if I'm right, but I do recall you doing this more than once before.
That phrase is from a video game that I like very much... I wouldn't read too much into it. Cool memory though,!
Also, of course I'm bewildered, I was gonna volunteer to eat my hat if Muffle wasn't scum and hey of course she was. One day I'll be an effective townie. I promise
Also, of course I'm bewildered, I was gonna volunteer to eat my hat if Muffle wasn't scum and hey of course she was. One day I'll be an effective townie. I promise
Jeroen_Sol
Nothing reveals Humanity so well as the games it plays. A game of betrayal, where the most suspicious person is brutally murdered? How savage.
3885
Well, my quest through the archives was less fruitful than I would have liked. Scratch that scum MO argument.
Jeroen_Sol
Nothing reveals Humanity so well as the games it plays. A game of betrayal, where the most suspicious person is brutally murdered? How savage.
3885
Though I did see you post a lot more in those games than you have these past few days, but that was independent of your alignment.
I do still find your big change in participation between being very quiet the first few days and now very active yesterday and today very weird, though.
I do still find your big change in participation between being very quiet the first few days and now very active yesterday and today very weird, though.
Jeroen_Sol
Nothing reveals Humanity so well as the games it plays. A game of betrayal, where the most suspicious person is brutally murdered? How savage.
3885
author=Cap_H
People reading too much in the flavour is something i dislike, demonlord. You managed to tell quite a lot without being active.
Talking about roles, the game is quite small to have more than one kp. Unless it's filled with protectives.
Cap, I'm going through your posts, and I find this one very alarming, as you seem to be suggesting there likely aren't multiple protectives, while you should have known for a fact that there were.
Jeroen_Sol
Nothing reveals Humanity so well as the games it plays. A game of betrayal, where the most suspicious person is brutally murdered? How savage.
3885
Well, Ozzy only mentioned YM three times. Two of those times are when he scumreads YM all of a sudden, even though the day before he said he didn't agree with voting YM and only went along with Cave's vote on YM because he had to.
Then an hour later YM asks what Ozzy thinks of Muffle and accuses him of not talking about Muffle for days on end.
That looks like it could have been coordinated to me to bus Ozzy in a way that paints Muffle as scum while preventing the same from being said about YM. Also YM only seemed to voice suspicions of Ozzy after everyone else already had. Cap has a better track record, being suspicious of Ozzy all game.
Cap's reads have also been more consistent than YM's, and he was less willing to lynch Muffle yesterday. The whole thing where Ozzy and him were at each other's throats since the beginning of the game could be a scum ploy, but I don't know. When I bussed piano early in that one game, the main reason was that piano was going to drop out anyway. I wouldn't have done it otherwise.
I also only just now while rereading all of Ozzy's, YM's and Cap's posts saw that Cap had already posted his list of who he defended each night before, and that list has stayed consistent. Which isn't much proof that it's legit, but it's something.
Conclusion: I still see both YM being scum and Cap being scum making sense. But I think it's YM.
Then an hour later YM asks what Ozzy thinks of Muffle and accuses him of not talking about Muffle for days on end.
That looks like it could have been coordinated to me to bus Ozzy in a way that paints Muffle as scum while preventing the same from being said about YM. Also YM only seemed to voice suspicions of Ozzy after everyone else already had. Cap has a better track record, being suspicious of Ozzy all game.
Cap's reads have also been more consistent than YM's, and he was less willing to lynch Muffle yesterday. The whole thing where Ozzy and him were at each other's throats since the beginning of the game could be a scum ploy, but I don't know. When I bussed piano early in that one game, the main reason was that piano was going to drop out anyway. I wouldn't have done it otherwise.
I also only just now while rereading all of Ozzy's, YM's and Cap's posts saw that Cap had already posted his list of who he defended each night before, and that list has stayed consistent. Which isn't much proof that it's legit, but it's something.
Conclusion: I still see both YM being scum and Cap being scum making sense. But I think it's YM.
Jeroen_Sol
Nothing reveals Humanity so well as the games it plays. A game of betrayal, where the most suspicious person is brutally murdered? How savage.
3885
Everyone, please respond while I take a break from overthinking this game. I'm getting really tired.
I'm around now.
I'm finding all of jeroens post to be logical. I just went through caps post myself, and I'm not seeing any real inconsistencies except for that odd cap post, but not too far from that comment was a list where he was considering the possibility I was scum, but wasn't going full in yet because of a reason. Overall, he has been very consistent in his posts. He was also trying to lynch ozzy for most of the game.
Yellow on the other hand has been a little out there.
My moneys on ym as well.
I'm finding all of jeroens post to be logical. I just went through caps post myself, and I'm not seeing any real inconsistencies except for that odd cap post, but not too far from that comment was a list where he was considering the possibility I was scum, but wasn't going full in yet because of a reason. Overall, he has been very consistent in his posts. He was also trying to lynch ozzy for most of the game.
Yellow on the other hand has been a little out there.
My moneys on ym as well.
author=Jeroen_Sol
If you expected demon to get killed, then what was the added benefit of protecting me over not protecting?
You got me there.
author=Jeroen_Solauthor=Cap_HCap, I'm going through your posts, and I find this one very alarming, as you seem to be suggesting there likely aren't multiple protectives, while you should have known for a fact that there were.
People reading too much in the flavour is something i dislike, demonlord. You managed to tell quite a lot without being active.
Talking about roles, the game is quite small to have more than one kp. Unless it's filled with protectives.
Not really? The last part suggests my role and it should have been a subtle wink.
I think we got another day? But I'm decided to vote YM here as every other solution sounds overly paranoid to me.
Ozzy made a very sketchy post early on and it didn't get better. I'm usually changing my reads more (especially my townreads to scumreads).
author=demonlord5000
I'm around now.
I'm finding all of jeroens post to be logical. I just went through caps post myself, and I'm not seeing any real inconsistencies except for that odd cap post, but not too far from that comment was a list where he was considering the possibility I was scum, but wasn't going full in yet because of a reason. Overall, he has been very consistent in his posts. He was also trying to lynch ozzy for most of the game.
Yellow on the other hand has been a little out there.
My moneys on ym as well.
Ozzy made a very sketchy post early on and it didn't get better. I'm usually changing my reads more (especially my townreads to scumreads).
Jeroen_Sol
Nothing reveals Humanity so well as the games it plays. A game of betrayal, where the most suspicious person is brutally murdered? How savage.
3885
There actually is no timer today. It ends when we decide it to end.
I want YM to respond once more as well, but I'm pretty sure I'll end up voting YM. At this point I feel I've invested enough energy into this game. If you are scum (or demon somehow, that'd be the mindfuck of the century) then gg, you deserve the win.
Though if that post is a subtle wink, then why did you say you didn't breadcrumb your role?
I want YM to respond once more as well, but I'm pretty sure I'll end up voting YM. At this point I feel I've invested enough energy into this game. If you are scum (or demon somehow, that'd be the mindfuck of the century) then gg, you deserve the win.
Though if that post is a subtle wink, then why did you say you didn't breadcrumb your role?
I'm on the way home, will be able to reply properly in an hour or so. Let's end this!!
author=Jeroen_Sol
There actually is no timer today. It ends when we decide it to end.
I want YM to respond once more as well, but I'm pretty sure I'll end up voting YM. At this point I feel I've invested enough energy into this game. If you are scum (or demon somehow, that'd be the mindfuck of the century) then gg, you deserve the win.
Though if that post is a subtle wink, then why did you say you didn't breadcrumb your role?
I don't consider it breadcrumbing as it couldn't be really connected at that point. And I don't remember all my posts. I remember suspecting demonlord for talking about the flavour all the time, but knowing my own role, I waited for him to hint more too.
Ok, I'm slowly heading to bed, so I put my vote down now as no other option makes sense to me.
#lynch Yellow Magic
Aright, boom, so there is this idea that Cap_H was gunning for Ozzy the whole time, which is false.
In the beginning, when Cap H did the whole list thing that I didn't like very much, he put Ozzy right in the middle.
Then votes starting piling up on Ozzy, and there were two on Cap_H as well. It was at this point that Ozzy revealed his (now known to be fake) sacrificial lamb role.
I'm still not really sure why Ozzy fakeclaimed at this point. He might have seen votes on both himself and Cap_H and panicked, idk. Whatever the reason, Ozzy became a dead man walking, as all Townies had to do was test his theory by having him always be on the lynch. It was AFTER this point was revealed that Cap_H started gunning for Ozzy.
In the beginning, when Cap H did the whole list thing that I didn't like very much, he put Ozzy right in the middle.
Then votes starting piling up on Ozzy, and there were two on Cap_H as well. It was at this point that Ozzy revealed his (now known to be fake) sacrificial lamb role.
I'm still not really sure why Ozzy fakeclaimed at this point. He might have seen votes on both himself and Cap_H and panicked, idk. Whatever the reason, Ozzy became a dead man walking, as all Townies had to do was test his theory by having him always be on the lynch. It was AFTER this point was revealed that Cap_H started gunning for Ozzy.
















