New account registration is temporarily disabled.

[MAFIA] PRISONER'S DILEMMA. GAME OVER

Posts

I still feel pretty good about my choice.

Does the person with the most votes against them die when the day ends or do we have to majority murder someone?
author=CAVE_DOG_IS_BACK
With 13 alive, it takes seven votes to execute.


I'd have to double check but I think the most anyone has is three.
pianotm
The TM is for Totally Magical.
32388
Shinan
I still feel pretty good about my choice.

Does the person with the most votes against them die when the day ends or do we have to majority murder someone?


I don't disagree, but Libby's being really obvious.
PlatinumAshes
I am now certain that you are not scum and are just town trying to play scum as hard as possible.
0
@kittenfood Welcome to Ridiculous Mafia Network.

@Fomar Don't worry I think you're doing very well so far. You're right, though, you should be a bit paranoid with every post you make. There are 12 other players going over every word and looking for a reason to hang you.
There's something Liberty said earlier that seems off to me.

author=Liberty
Well, if we all picked vanilla at least we know we're all equal!

Source- https://rpgmaker.net/forums/topics/24686/?post=887129#post887129


Vanilla town and vanilla mafia can be the best of friends? Maybe in the beginning but for how long.

I wasn't aware of the consequence of D1 no-lynch until after reading demonlord's opinion, psy's post, to the point of Fomar's stats.

author=demonlord5000
I'm anti no-lynch. I feel like no-lynch gives us nothing to go on day 2, but I'll leave it at that. I feel like I'm advocating it every game, so nothing I can say now that hasn't been said. Everyone has their own beliefs on this, and I'm going to stick to mine.


author=psy_wombats
That was a joke and I am not, in fact, the turbo deathmiller. However the way to get info during the daytime is by voting to kill people, and if there's a D1 no-kill, we gain no info.
author=tale
I wasn't aware of the consequence of D1 no-lynch until after reading demonlord's opinion, psy's post, to the point of Fomar's stats.


Given how the town's odds oscillate as you add additional townies I think psy's point about the odd/even number at the end is probably the main reason.

author=psy_wombats
In practice the endgame differs based on an even/odd number of players. 2 town 1 scum being lynch-or-lose, 3 town 1 scum being mislynch-and-lose. And generally you want LYLO over MYLO for better odds.
author=Fomar0153
Well if Liberty wants to play nice now then sure.
#cancel

So do the scum all know who eachother are?


author=ivoryjones
Honestly I really, really wanna lynch fomar because him saying he'll leave the game if people lynch him D1 just left a bad taste in my mouth. Until demon and AE kept spouting some "v vs nv" bs

Also lib going on a tangent with fomar in the game was just really scummy to me. Don't care if he's new or not. Them and tale seem likely but rn demon sounds the scummiest and needs out


@Piano

There. Not gonna quote every post he's made but these couple ones struck me as odd.

Also, THIS post was so fucking weird:

author=Fomar0153
PlatinumAshes is the player who has been the most suspect, practically everyone called him out on this, I can re-list the reasons everyone else stated if you would like, but surfice to say I don't follow his reasoning and no one else has really done anything that seems really suspicious to me. It really seems like there is basically nothing but paranoia and guessing on this first day phase.



Literally fucking flipping out like you did about psy. On one hand he keeps on asking stuffs left and right about the game even though most of his questions can easily be answered from cave's first post, on the other hand, somehow he manages to do a complete 180 and magically come up at that conclusion (about PA). Also who the FRACK asks if scum knows each other?? Srsly??

I am willing to switch my vote on PA just to get a lynch but would heavily prefer psy or fomar tbh.
author=tale
There's something Liberty said earlier that seems off to me.

author=Liberty
Well, if we all picked vanilla at least we know we're all equal!

Source- https://rpgmaker.net/forums/topics/24686/?post=887129#post887129


Vanilla town and vanilla mafia can be the best of friends? Maybe in the beginning but for how long.

I wasn't aware of the consequence of D1 no-lynch until after reading demonlord's opinion, psy's post, to the point of Fomar's stats.



Obviously, I was talking about town all picking vanilla... It was the overall tone of the conversation at the time. We were joking around about how bad it would be if town all picked vanilla, but feel free to read into things what you want, in order to act like your argument holds any water. It doesn't, but I trust everyone can see how dumb your throwing that out as any kind of 'proof' of anything is.

author=ivoryjones
Honestly I really, really wanna lynch fomar because him saying he'll leave the game if people lynch him D1 just left a bad taste in my mouth.


Eurgh here is what I said exactly.

author=Fomar0153
Lynching me on day 1 is likely to result in me never joining again when you're desperate to get enough people.


I never said I would leave the game, plus from what I understood if/once I am lynched I am not able to post further anyway. I don't normally play forum games but you all had been waiting around for a final player for a while so I thought I would give it a go. I simply stated how being lynched off on the first day when there is basically nothing to analyse except paranoid ramblings would not endear me to playing again.

Also here are the rules on the mafia:

Mafia
The Mafia (aka Scum) on the other hand, have a significant advantage over the Town. They can communicate with other scum members outside the thread during night phase. During the night, they can come together, discuss, and kill a townie. If all goes according to their plan (which it might not), then that townie will be dead -thus cannot post or vote- for the rest of the game.

It didn't say when they found out, i.e. when they got their PM saying they were in the mafia or for example if they found out at the first night phase. Obviously if it was the latter it might have given them more incentive to go with nolynch or on future days it would make day 1 actions even less meaningful.

author=ivoryjones
Literally fucking flipping out like you did about psy.


I don't recall "flipping out" and the only time I remember even talking to psy was about simulation stuff. I guess I'll go re-read my posts and see if I have forgotten something.
To be clear, I am also very much willing to change my vote to Psy to get a lynch.

author=tale
There's something Liberty said earlier that seems off to me.

author=Liberty
Well, if we all picked vanilla at least we know we're all equal!

Source- https://rpgmaker.net/forums/topics/24686/?post=887129#post887129


Vanilla town and vanilla mafia can be the best of friends? Maybe in the beginning but for how long.


This post feels fine to me. It was very early, there wasn't much to really say yet.

I have hard time knowing what to think of Liberty, based on what people say (like her previously wanting to nolynch D1) I'm not really sure this is scum read to me? I could believe she is just being extremely tolerant, but I could see this also be the play if she is scum with two new players.

So I don't really know what to make of her.
author=Fomar0153
author=ivoryjones
Honestly I really, really wanna lynch fomar because him saying he'll leave the game if people lynch him D1 just left a bad taste in my mouth.
Eurgh here is what I said exactly.

author=Fomar0153
Lynching me on day 1 is likely to result in me never joining again when you're desperate to get enough people.


I never said I would leave the game, plus from what I understood if/once I am lynched I am not able to post further anyway. I don't normally play forum games but you all had been waiting around for a final player for a while so I thought I would give it a go. I simply stated how being lynched off on the first day when there is basically nothing to analyse except paranoid ramblings would not endear me to playing again.

Also here are the rules on the mafia:

Mafia
The Mafia (aka Scum) on the other hand, have a significant advantage over the Town. They can communicate with other scum members outside the thread during night phase. During the night, they can come together, discuss, and kill a townie. If all goes according to their plan (which it might not), then that townie will be dead -thus cannot post or vote- for the rest of the game.

It didn't say when they found out, i.e. when they got their PM saying they were in the mafia or for example if they found out at the first night phase. Obviously if it was the latter it might have given them more incentive to go with nolynch or on future days it would make day 1 actions even less meaningful.

author=ivoryjones
Literally fucking flipping out like you did about psy.


I don't recall "flipping out" and the only time I remember even talking to psy was about simulation stuff. I guess I'll go re-read my posts and see if I have forgotten something.


I didn't word it well; so you didn't say you were gonna leave halfway but it might as well meant that (also I don't see the difference between not joining future games again and you "leaving" this game (if you got lynched) so...) plus it sure as hell seems like you're threatening here. Some of us always gets targeted day 1 and do you think just because of that they won't join future games? Hell I'm very suspicious to the other new players - not just you, but you just got the short end of the stick. Me gunning for you because you've acted suspicious to me does NOT mean I will do the same in future games. Please bear that in mind.

The flipping out thing was to piano, not you btw.
author=AlaskanEmily
To be clear, I am also very much willing to change my vote to Psy to get a lynch.


You better goddamn hold your word to it.

#Cancel
#Psy

I honestly don't think enough people care about Fomar right now so I'll just go ahead and change my vote on psy. I would APPRECIATE it if piano would stop his lil feud with Liberty temporarily and revert back to WHAT TRULY MATTERS - aka this:

author=pianotm
You need to be voting psy_wombats right now! He's shady as fuck! I love how nobody noticed that he absolutely waffled on his reason for voting for me when I called him for being scum on intuition. He didn't even use my total lack of an explanation against me. That is not town psy! Not by a mile!


Honestly I've seen Lib's "I'll lynch you since you lynched me first" waaay too many times and I don't agree with tale's or anyone's "reasoning" on their lynch on her. She definitely errs scummy to me before but from her earlier reaction now psy & tale's posts overshadows her scumminess so I'm not gonna jump on that bandwagon just yet.
pianotm
The TM is for Totally Magical.
32388
Alright!

#cancel
#Lynch psy_wombats
oddRABBIT
I feel bored. How odd.
1979
I do admit, I'm thinking Liberty might be suspicious. I guess for now, I can cancel and I'll vote however the majority votes. Right now, it seems like everyone thinks that Psy is suspicious, and, yeah, I kinda agree.

...It takes me way too long to read through this stuff over and over to understand everything.

But, yeah, I'll hop onto this bandwagon, I guess.

#cancel
#lynch Psy
Liberty- it doesn't really hold water. I'm sorry about being the first to No-Lynch, I didn't know that it's your thing.
You did say that you're bit out of practice and you're really joking around during the start. Hope you get enough rest.

#Cancel
#Lynch psy_wombats

I'm so sorry psy. I feel uneasy with getting rid power roles this early.
That was after Fomar lynch PlatinumAshes.

author=psy_wombats
The odds get better with power roles at least, but, yeah.


If you mean odds get better including stats, I apologize for the misinterpretation.

If I get lynched during night phase. Best of luck to everyone!
I'm willing to put my vote down on psy as well. I was trying to understand his argument, and his reasoning was that you voted for him without mentioning his hated claim. I just looked back and you in fact did mention it, and in fact the mislynch bit was his reasoning for voting you in the first place.

#lynch Psy

As for libby, I don't think there is anything wrong defending new players day 1. I've been doing the same. It's a whole different game once we see how people flip though.
Ninja'd by tale. Worth noting with my vote were one vote away from hammer. Also, we don't know if psy is a power role. His turbo death miller thing was a joke. I should probably cancel so he has time to claim.

#cancel