Full Games List
Featured Games
New Games
Reviews
Media
Images
Blogs
Game Updates
Images Feedback Summary
Game Design Highlights
Tutorials
Articles
Scripts
Utilities / Plugins
Resources
Engines
Engine Bulletins
What is Makerscore?
Past Events
Achievements
Misaos
Forums
Post History
Chat
New to RMN?
Full Store List
RMN Music Pack (free)
[MAFIA] GAME OVER - FREQUENCY MAFIA
Posts
pianotm
View playlists
Close
author=ESBY
it's stupid to rush into lynchings in day 1 without a read and that's why i vote for piano
I like this post.
author=Frogge
Also libby actually lynched someone on day 1 for once and for that I move my vote to #lynch Piano
I don't like this post.
author=Cap_H
Lib definitely should think a little about that wolf. Her argumentation feels like an overexplanation for an rvs vote and it is wolfy as a serious vote. Libby overexplaining things might be a case, tho.
I liked some of the newer stuff from Ozzy and I agree with Gourd that Frogge's vote is among the weakest.
Demon stepped it up a little bringing in an actual wagon read!
But... I only made two posts up until the point you said this? And both were kinda eh.
Read up on some stuff, gonna continue posting my thoughts as I get along.
author=OzzyTheOneauthor=ESBYI like this post.
it's stupid to rush into lynchings in day 1 without a read and that's why i vote for piano
To specify, I like the part about not rushing to a lynch on day 1.
OzzyTheOne
Y'all need to stop meta-gaming. It makes me want to no longer play mafia.
This is one of the things that's been pissing me off, lately. Quit telling other people how they're supposed to play the game. If you don't like it, maybe RMN mafia isn't for you.
As for my opinions so far:
Frogge: Likely scum or just unhelpful town
ESBY reeks of town so far.
That's all I've got to say so far, I didn't like Cap's initial posts that much as he was reading very hard into obvious joke posts, but he looks way better now.
Frogge: Likely scum or just unhelpful town
ESBY reeks of town so far.
That's all I've got to say so far, I didn't like Cap's initial posts that much as he was reading very hard into obvious joke posts, but he looks way better now.
I wonder when Libby and Piano will start barking at each other again like last game and which of both will end up being scum this time.
psy_wombats
13315
author=Hexatona
I don't like how the two people who participated the least showing up at pretty much the same time.
This strikes me as disingenuous
#cancel
#lynch hexatona
psy_wombats
13315
author=pianotmOzzyTheOneThis is one of the things that's been pissing me off, lately. Quit telling other people how they're supposed to play the game. If you don't like it, maybe RMN mafia isn't for you.
Y'all need to stop meta-gaming. It makes me want to no longer play mafia.
^ and I'm not really sure how to interpret this because I know scum-Piano (much like scum-Liberty) loves to play mustache-twirling villain but I'm not sure where actively discouraging people from playing falls on that.
I've even made this a scum-play at some point to yell at piano for this, I think he's my #2 or #2 priority vote at the moment. and if piano is town, lighten up Piano.
Oh, but don't you know? Piano is sure I'm town! So if he's town and is sure I'm town then I must be town. And if he's mafia and is sure I'm town, I must be town! :D
No, but seriously, both piano's posts and emily's make me suspicious of them. I'm also suspicious of the fact that ozzy just spammed a bunch of posts after being called out for not posting. Instead of making one or two normal, detailed posts, breaking them up into sentences seems kinda like you intend to just disappear and sit on the laurels of your current post count and lay low. A rather scum play, methinks.
No, but seriously, both piano's posts and emily's make me suspicious of them. I'm also suspicious of the fact that ozzy just spammed a bunch of posts after being called out for not posting. Instead of making one or two normal, detailed posts, breaking them up into sentences seems kinda like you intend to just disappear and sit on the laurels of your current post count and lay low. A rather scum play, methinks.
psy_wombats
13315
I see nothing wrong with ozzy, he doesn't post unless he's got something to do. I don't think piano townreading one way or another is relevant because no one's actually done anything in the game so far.
It's more the fact he said he was sure that I was town when at this point the only people sure of anyone being town would be scum. It could easily be a slip-up, or mean nothing, but it's something that's niggling me and really my sole reason for keeping the vote on him as long as I have.
The numbers thing is basically just the cream on top at this point and was meant initially as a way for me to show my displeasure at bringing numberplay into a game as though it's the Word, when there are issues with relying on straight numbers like that (that I've already pointed out). I would have removed the vote by now but that one post is what niggled me.
No one should be sure enough of anything to say so seriously. Joking around, sure, but preeeeetty sure he wasn't joking around. So, yeah.
The numbers thing is basically just the cream on top at this point and was meant initially as a way for me to show my displeasure at bringing numberplay into a game as though it's the Word, when there are issues with relying on straight numbers like that (that I've already pointed out). I would have removed the vote by now but that one post is what niggled me.
No one should be sure enough of anything to say so seriously. Joking around, sure, but preeeeetty sure he wasn't joking around. So, yeah.
psy_wombats
13315
I'll advocate my Hex vote, we should murder him:
- he canceled his esby vote because some other mathnerd canceled their vote and didn't supply a vote of his own, I think this would be because he was scum worried about being exposed on a train, otherwise why post just to cancel
- finds it suspicious that ozzy/gourd show up despite neither of them being suspicious on the basis of no-show. like if they were the scumteam the only evidence I see of it is gourd asking ozzy his suspicions, but... ozzy never replied. no way that's coordination.
- he canceled his esby vote because some other mathnerd canceled their vote and didn't supply a vote of his own, I think this would be because he was scum worried about being exposed on a train, otherwise why post just to cancel
- finds it suspicious that ozzy/gourd show up despite neither of them being suspicious on the basis of no-show. like if they were the scumteam the only evidence I see of it is gourd asking ozzy his suspicions, but... ozzy never replied. no way that's coordination.
psy_wombats
13315
author=Liberty
It's more the fact he said he was sure that I was town when at this point the only people sure of anyone being town would be scum. It could easily be a slip-up, or mean nothing, but it's something that's niggling me and really my sole reason for keeping the vote on him as long as I have.
The numbers thing is basically just the cream on top at this point and was meant initially as a way for me to show my displeasure at bringing numberplay into a game as though it's the Word, when there are issues with relying on straight numbers like that (that I've already pointed out). I would have removed the vote by now but that one post is what niggled me.
No one should be sure enough of anything to say so seriously. Joking around, sure, but preeeeetty sure he wasn't joking around. So, yeah.
On the other hand, he was convinced a game or two ago that we were scum when nothing much had happened aside from us both being scum.
author=Fomar0153
Now onto the Piano and Libby thing. Eurgh, my gut is saying Piano is being paranoid about Libby which probably means he is town. Libby does seem to hate maths, just ask her to do a Sudoku. It also feels like a replay from Cave's last game, although Piano was spot on about scum Libby that game. Despite all this I am just not getting any scum vibe from Libby so far.
Yeah, Cave, this is such a weird comment. It's a lot of meta with one sketchy assumption - Piano being town for being paranoid about Liberty. I think Piano's town for reasons I stated before and they have nothing to do with meta (so, no need to feel excluded, Esby).
Hexatona got some towncred because of making some bad comments, which look like they have town perspective (asking about subs in particular). And just siting in the thread without having anything to say. It's not solid evidence, tho.
author=CAVE_DOG_IS_BACK
if you click on fomar's posts and go read his ones in spy vs spy mafia, where he was town, they read different to me than the posts he is making in this game.
This is true, a change of style indicates a change of alignment.
psy_wombats
13315
To clarify, that piano asserted /surety/ that you were town I don't think is an issue, because there's nothing to make a reasonable player convinced, like game actions or vote or w/e. I'm remembering last game where demon immediately believed Odd or Ozzy or whoever was "confirmed" despite their only evidence being their own claim and in retrospect that was pretty damning. In this case it just sounds like piano following his own hunches vs overplaying a hand based on evidence.
author=OzzyTheOneauthor=Cap_H
I liked some of the newer stuff from Ozzy and I agree with Gourd that Frogge's vote is among the weakest.
Demon stepped it up a little bringing in an actual wagon read!
But... I only made two posts up until the point you said this? And both were kinda eh.
Read up on some stuff, gonna continue posting my thoughts as I get along.
I'm just liking them, the impression was good. It's not a strong read.
psy_wombats
13315
fomar's interactions with frogge and piano+liberty come as legit, I think he's fine at the moment. Because fomar was town-read for the sim stuff in the past, I'd expect scum-fomar to be playing up the math garbage at this point (yelling at piano for his bad odds) where he's mostly been playing better than that.
