[MAFIA] GAME OVER - FREQUENCY MAFIA
Posts
can you all weigh in on the validity of hunting the other scum. like. imagine fomar is 100% confirmed scum and we can hold him accountable to deliver his weirdass night action results which, I don't even remember what he does. who is the other scum.
Also Odd just sent a message in our private chat saying he should have clarified that me and Hex are both town. That means among Fomar, Gourd or Liberty one is a mafia and Fomar is still the most likely among all of them.
And since I had a play in mind for day 3 I witheld something Hex said in case he turned out to be scum and lying. Apparently Hex asked Odd why he didn't get the broadcast and Odd said it was because he has a role. Guess that pretty much confirms that Fomar is lying about his role. He got the PM (confirmed) and claims to have a night action that got blocked.
CAVE_DOG_IS_BACK
can you all weigh in on the validity of hunting the other scum. like. imagine fomar is 100% confirmed scum and we can hold him accountable to deliver his weirdass night action results which, I don't even remember what he does. who is the other scum.
I missed a lot because there was a fuckton of pages and I was doing a bunch of other stuff. We know I got a broadcast because I was the very first one to post about it. We know Cave got a broadcast because he was the first to actually use the word. I'm willing to buy that Fomar got a broadcast because he managed to say one word in his secret code that was so cryptic it could have been pure coincidence.
Who else claimed to get a broadcast and how did they confirm it? I'm going to read back to see if I can spot the broadcast claims, but it'll be good to have nice list of that on the current page.
i would be grateful for any arguments that didn't involve radios
Might as well confirm I got mine I guess. I was listening to bass when frogge popped up on the radio.
People who got the broadcast (green = confirmed, yellow = unconfirmed, red = didn't)
Cap - Knew that there were two seperate messages.
Fomar - Pointed out the word ponty.
Esby - Pointed out the word queer.
Piano - First to post.
Cave - First to say it's called a broadcast.
Psy
Demon
Gourd - has a special role
Hex - confirmed town and has a special role
Libby - claims indie and has a special role
Cap - Knew that there were two seperate messages.
Fomar - Pointed out the word ponty.
Esby - Pointed out the word queer.
Piano - First to post.
Cave - First to say it's called a broadcast.
Psy
Demon
Gourd - has a special role
Hex - confirmed town and has a special role
Libby - claims indie and has a special role
Lemme break it down;
Only people without roles get the broadcast.
Fomar - Claims to have a special role but is almost definitely fake.
Gourd - Claims to have gotten broadcast but did not confirm it, although he used "starts with a p" to imply he did, but that could easily be a guess.
Gourd, if you actually got the broadcast, what's the very last word?
Only people without roles get the broadcast.
Fomar - Claims to have a special role but is almost definitely fake.
Gourd - Claims to have gotten broadcast but did not confirm it, although he used "starts with a p" to imply he did, but that could easily be a guess.
Gourd, if you actually got the broadcast, what's the very last word?
Also i was confused about demon's way of confirming he got it at first but I was rereading just now and got what he means. He also 100% got the broadcast.
Also about this
I highly doubt grand daddy themselves can get the broadcast if it isn't sent to people with special roles.
author=demonoboyo
First, gourd revealed a mafia head. Gourd claims they direct the kills, but if this is indeed a godfather type role, then couldn't that person potentially get the froggecast and share it with their scum buddies? I do think former and gourd are still suspect but I'm not ready to end the day just yet.
I highly doubt grand daddy themselves can get the broadcast if it isn't sent to people with special roles.
Me
https://rpgmaker.net/forums/topics/24770/?post=892439#post892439
CAVE_DOG
https://rpgmaker.net/forums/topics/24770/?post=892441#post892441
ESBY
https://rpgmaker.net/forums/topics/24770/?post=892442#post892442
ESBY's doesn't have any real verification that he's telling the truth but the earliness of his claim suggests he really got one.
Demon
https://rpgmaker.net/forums/topics/24770/?post=892452#post892452
Again, doesn't give any confirming details but it's just a brief statement that he got a broadcast and immediately gives some scumreads and forgets about the broadcast.
psy_wombats
https://rpgmaker.net/forums/topics/24770/?post=892486#post892486
This one's questionable. He's posting several times on the previous page before confirming that he got a broadcast and simply repeats me calling it a Froggecast. He didn't think it was important and then when he does, he finally says, "Oh, yeah, I got that too!"
Cap_H
https://rpgmaker.net/forums/topics/24770/?post=892548#post892548
He says that he got Frogge's broadcast the post after a massive read post but never verifies. At least he doesn't seem to have completely forgotten and he's at least discussing the broadcast in his previous post.
Fomar
https://rpgmaker.net/forums/topics/24770/?post=892642#post892642
Having actually gone through these claims, I actually think Fomar saw this broadcast.
I would also like to posit that some of us may have abilities that let us spy on a broadcast even though they aren't actually sent it. We know there are hacker roles. Both hackers have claimed rolecop. I think they're both lying about that, but I don't think that's actually a scumtell. I think their actual power is to hack into the broadcast. This gives me the following scumvibe: Gourd or Fomar are scum, but not both. The reason is that Fomar actually gave us a specific color: White Hat hacker, while Gourd simply claimed hacker. Either Fomar gave us the wrong color to make himself look better or Gourd didn't give us a color because he didn't want to potentially get counterclaimed and caught lying.
https://rpgmaker.net/forums/topics/24770/?post=892439#post892439
CAVE_DOG
https://rpgmaker.net/forums/topics/24770/?post=892441#post892441
ESBY
https://rpgmaker.net/forums/topics/24770/?post=892442#post892442
ESBY's doesn't have any real verification that he's telling the truth but the earliness of his claim suggests he really got one.
Demon
https://rpgmaker.net/forums/topics/24770/?post=892452#post892452
Again, doesn't give any confirming details but it's just a brief statement that he got a broadcast and immediately gives some scumreads and forgets about the broadcast.
psy_wombats
https://rpgmaker.net/forums/topics/24770/?post=892486#post892486
This one's questionable. He's posting several times on the previous page before confirming that he got a broadcast and simply repeats me calling it a Froggecast. He didn't think it was important and then when he does, he finally says, "Oh, yeah, I got that too!"
Cap_H
https://rpgmaker.net/forums/topics/24770/?post=892548#post892548
He says that he got Frogge's broadcast the post after a massive read post but never verifies. At least he doesn't seem to have completely forgotten and he's at least discussing the broadcast in his previous post.
Fomar
https://rpgmaker.net/forums/topics/24770/?post=892642#post892642
Having actually gone through these claims, I actually think Fomar saw this broadcast.
I would also like to posit that some of us may have abilities that let us spy on a broadcast even though they aren't actually sent it. We know there are hacker roles. Both hackers have claimed rolecop. I think they're both lying about that, but I don't think that's actually a scumtell. I think their actual power is to hack into the broadcast. This gives me the following scumvibe: Gourd or Fomar are scum, but not both. The reason is that Fomar actually gave us a specific color: White Hat hacker, while Gourd simply claimed hacker. Either Fomar gave us the wrong color to make himself look better or Gourd didn't give us a color because he didn't want to potentially get counterclaimed and caught lying.
Frogge
People who got the broadcast (green = confirmed, yellow = unconfirmed, red = didn't)
Cap - Knew that there were two seperate messages.
Fomar - Pointed out the word ponty.
Esby - Pointed out the word queer.
Piano - First to post.
Cave - First to say it's called a broadcast.
Psy
Demon
Gourd - has a special role
Hex - confirmed town and has a special role
Libby - claims indie and has a special role
Oh, this has even better details!
Yours has good info too. Give me a minute to combine the two.
Here's another possibility that occurs to me. All hackers are just scum in this game and town is supposed to be protecting the broadcast from them.
Another possibility is that there is a town side hacker and a scum side hacker. In this game, it seems like "hacker" is a skill that scum absolutely should have.
Gourd and Fomar. One of these two is scum, guaranteed.
Gourd and Fomar. One of these two is scum, guaranteed.
what if you all read peoples posts and made arguments based on the content of their posts instead.
Frogge
People who got the broadcast (green = confirmed, yellow = unconfirmed, red = didn't)
Cap - Knew that there were two seperate messages.
Fomar - Pointed out the word ponty.
Esby - Pointed out the word queer.
Piano - First to post. Confirmed town through role check.
Demon - Pointed out the word bass. "Again, doesn't give any confirming details but it's just a brief statement that he got a broadcast and immediately gives some scumreads and forgets about the broadcast." May not have gotten it back when it was relevant. Says he's reluctant to prove he got it earlier in fear of breaking rules but just now confirmed he got it. If mafia team has a frequency spy, they may have told Demon about the contents later on.
Cave - First to say it's called a broadcast.
Psy - "This one's questionable. He's posting several times on the previous page before confirming that he got a broadcast and simply repeats me calling it a Froggecast. He didn't think it was important and then when he does, he finally says, "Oh, yeah, I got that too!"" - Piano
Gourd - has a special role
Hex - confirmed town and has a special role
Libby - claims indie and has a special role
I highly doubt there is a frequency spy role, though. People without roles get the message. It's a role made specifically to get the message? Seems more likely that there is simply a mafia with no ability rather than that contradiction since that would mean they'd get it. Since piano's been confirmed town, it means either Cap, Esby, Demon, Cave or Psy fit into that role.


















