WIP MIDIS: OPINIONS PLEASE!

I liked the first two. I'm not a composer, I'm a game designer, but I can at least give you my take what I could see myself doing with these songs.

The first one, Chilly Reception, is a nice quiet theme. Fitting for a nice quiet town or a nice quiet path. I probably wouldn't use it in my games because I like stuff to be happening all the time and generally avoid creating those kinds of areas, but I can definitely see it being used in a lighthearted game.

The second one, Frost-rimed Blade, I assume is a battle theme. It sounds like it would fit extremely well as the exploration music in a Castlevania game, actually. For an RPG, since it takes about half a minute to start feeling strong, I would probably use it for bosses or minibosses rather than normal battles. For normal battles, I like a song that starts out with a bang, because the battle can often end in less than a minute, and I don't like the song to feel like it's still getting started at that point. I don't want you to feel like I'm complaining; this isn't a bad point about your song at all. The song works perfectly as minor boss music and is really good.

I don't actually like Travelling the Frozen Wastes for some reason. The two main instruments in the melody seem to clash kind of badly and a single melody doesn't stand out. Maybe it's my computer's midi synthesizer. That's the problem with midis. They can sound wildly different on different sound cards (sometimes even leaving certain instruments out entirely). I'd be interested to hear an MP3 version of what it sounds like on your computer, but my impression is that it needs some work. And it desperately needs some, I dunno, some more oomph or something added about halfway through. I can't really picture it being appropriate for any particular kind of scene right now. I'm not good at describing the problem, sorry.