MUFFLE'S PROFILE

LockeZ and Piano seem very town-esque to me. They're constantly giving helpful info and trying to bring out reasons as to why someone could be suspicious, as well as scumreading people to try and get them to step up and give a valid reason not to be suspected.

Cave also seems quite town-esque to me. Their chaotic posts don't rub me off in a bad way as they have a sort of innocence to it. They're also being very helpful and asking necessary questions.

demonlord is giving some valid points and has given a few reasonings as to not lynch him, so I have no reason to suspect him. He's more of a neutral read though.

Cap also seems neutral though some of his posts come off as strange.

Ozzy is teetering on the mafia side for me, but I'm going to trust his rolecall for now as to not make a mistake like we did with Gourd.

Esby I'm not sure. I think they're just trying to be obnoxious and an asshole, but there's no way to know if he's town or mafia. I don't like his way of playing and he's tried to blame people with lack of reason as well as choose to lynch a couple people off for no indicating reason except they're suspecting him. Either way, he's not that helpful but I don't think lynching him would do much good if we go the route that Ozzy will agree to lynch with us and we could be wrong. Plus I think the shooters might get to him first.

YM isn't saying much and what they're saying comes off as a bit defensive. They also seem to be reading piano and I post wrong as if we're attacking them when we're not. This could be just a misread/misinterpretation or they could be trying to make us somehow look suspicious. I don't have enough to lynch them though I do want them to participate a little more. They've only really put their word in when the subject is turned to them.

I'd rather not lynch of Tman when it seems like they might get modkilled with their lack of participation. Besides them sitting quietly on the sidelines and only saying a couple comments, I don't have any other reason to vote a lynch against them. However, they could just be a bit busy and not monitoring the thread constantly like I am. (I constantly refresh the page like every three minutes, I feel no guilt)

Sol's participating more in Day 2 which is understandable. They seem to be giving some reasonable information and scumhunting so I see no reason to suspect them currently. However, and this is just a feeling and I have no reason, I just have a bad feeling about them. I have no real evidence so I will not vote, but I'm just putting that out there.

I think that's about everyone. I haven't gone back and read yet and my memory could be off so please correct me if I'm wrong on something. That's all I've gathered on people so far though. I'm having a hard time figuring out who I find suspicious enough to lynch. I don't want to mislynch if Ozzy is going to lynch with us, not to mention I feel really bad for overlooking Gourd just being eager so I'm trying to make sure I am SURE this is who I REALLY suspect and want to lynch.

Okay... I didn't want to say this because I was hoping at some point I could figure it out.

I'm confused on how this "I target was Cave so he's probably town." "If two people attack the same person something happens." Things that popped up when the roles and stuff were brought up.

I just don't understand the mechanics how this works. Is there someone who could explain... in a way that might be easier for me so I can comment on it. It's just one gigantic mess.

I should scumhunt more? mm, right now I've just been trying to collect reasons as to why someone might be scum. When you say scumhunt, do you mean a list? I thought I've pointed out several reasons as to why people could be town or scum. I'm just sitting back watching and reading because I don't have much to say that has already been said, and I don't want to repeat myself.

Also, I'm not attacking you cave. I just don't fully understand what you mean.

author=pianotm
Well, we heard there were two guns. Those seem separate from any possible scum kill ability. Then again, that was in the flavor. Still, don't dismiss it.

That is also true, I will keep this in mind though it still seems slightly unlikely. Then again I've only ever played one Mafia before.

author=pianotm
Because at the time, it seemed LockeZ came in to be a rules nazi and then posted nothing else for a time.

Ah, I see. I don't know why I find that funny. Probably not serious though.

These decisions seem to be getting rash. Ozzy shows up for the first time today and automatically lynches Demonlord. Piano automatically lynches Ozzy for saying one thing. <.> Shouldn't we try to find some more evidence against these people?