Full Games List
Featured Games
New Games
Reviews
Media
Images
Blogs
Game Updates
Images Feedback Summary
Game Design Highlights
Tutorials
Articles
Scripts
Utilities / Plugins
Resources
Engines
Engine Bulletins
What is Makerscore?
Past Events
Achievements
Misaos
Forums
Post History
Chat
New to RMN?
Full Store List
RMN Music Pack (free)
MIGHT, MAGIC, AND MAFIA (GAME THREAD)
Posts
Liberty
View playlists
CloseYeah, but the fact that he claimed death miller is still believable to me, since if he were mafia he could have gotten away with just claiming normal miller and be seen as more innocent. The fact that he claimed something that's deadlier to him as a player kinda makes me think he might be the real deal.
I would like to see more from the others and what they think, though.
I would like to see more from the others and what they think, though.
author=Liberty
So it's either one or two mafia. 3-4 townies and 1-2 independents.
It's two mafia. Obviously. Why are you all trying so hard to make false assumptions?
So... Only one vote so far?
Now I believe it's either Gourd + Liberty or rabitZ + TBG. Chearlie is quite suspicious too, but I can't read his alliance with someone. I'll hold my vote just yet. Make your moves.
It's number crunching, pure and simple. How are you so sure of the number of mafia? I mean, sure the likeliest number is 2, but there could be one, couldn't there? I'm sure there have been games where there've been only one before. It's a fair assumption.
But, yeah, most likely two. Frankly I think rabitz and Gourd are looking less likely to be mafia (that's just me). I'm not so sure about MM or Chearlie. TBG is a toss-up. He might be mafia lying about being cop, or (I think more likely) a cop. The thing is that he's not necessarily reliable until he gets a better read of his sanity and we can't chance a lynching on just his say-so. It could spell disaster.
...right. I'm going to vote no lynch for now. If that happens I can protect TBG tonight with an item and hopefully we'll have enough of a read with his powers to save ourselves from losing.
#vote no-lynch
But, yeah, most likely two. Frankly I think rabitz and Gourd are looking less likely to be mafia (that's just me). I'm not so sure about MM or Chearlie. TBG is a toss-up. He might be mafia lying about being cop, or (I think more likely) a cop. The thing is that he's not necessarily reliable until he gets a better read of his sanity and we can't chance a lynching on just his say-so. It could spell disaster.
...right. I'm going to vote no lynch for now. If that happens I can protect TBG tonight with an item and hopefully we'll have enough of a read with his powers to save ourselves from losing.
#vote no-lynch
The Day Phase 2 Vote Count Because I Forgot To Include Time Remaining Last Time:
no lynch 1 vote (Liberty)
Gourd_Clae: 1 vote (MrChearlie, rabitZ, thatbennyguy, rabitZ)
This Phase will last about 45 hours, or until a majority vote has been reached. With six people, it would take four to reach majority.
no lynch 1 vote (Liberty)
Gourd_Clae: 1 vote (
This Phase will last about 45 hours, or until a majority vote has been reached. With six people, it would take four to reach majority.
Liberty, 1 mafia means 1:8 at the beggining of the game. This is too much imbalanced, Marrend wouldn't do that. Nolynch today is counter-productive and even leads to our loss if there is one indi and mafia will lynch townie tonight.
@ rabitZ I think Marrend admitting that he gave me the picture would prove my innocence but I guess not? The worst part about it though is that you guys still won't know if you lynched me right when you killed me because of my role.
@Liberty Why are you no-lynching? Actually if there's no consensus then no-lynching will allow us to be us to be sure the game's not over yet. But, only as a last resort.
@Liberty Why are you no-lynching? Actually if there's no consensus then no-lynching will allow us to be us to be sure the game's not over yet. But, only as a last resort.
It's only for the interim. If we can root out a mafia member then I'll gladly change the vote, but I think considering the odds, I think it's the best move I can make right now.
I could change to vote a lynch on the people I suspect for the moment - that being MM and Chearlie, but if what happens last time happens again, I couldn't forgive myself. I voted lynch on cave and even though I didn't believe it would get him killed, it did. That ended terribly for us. We need to be careful because if we do lynch a townie by accident, and if the mafia kill a townie during this night phase, that's it, end of game. We'll have lost.
I'm about to head to bed for the night, so I feel this is my best bet. My vote is tied up in what I believe a good strategy for the day. If I'm not back before the days' end, I'll at least know I voted in a way I thought was best to win.
Night all, and try not to lynch anyone that might be townie while I'm gone.
I could change to vote a lynch on the people I suspect for the moment - that being MM and Chearlie, but if what happens last time happens again, I couldn't forgive myself. I voted lynch on cave and even though I didn't believe it would get him killed, it did. That ended terribly for us. We need to be careful because if we do lynch a townie by accident, and if the mafia kill a townie during this night phase, that's it, end of game. We'll have lost.
I'm about to head to bed for the night, so I feel this is my best bet. My vote is tied up in what I believe a good strategy for the day. If I'm not back before the days' end, I'll at least know I voted in a way I thought was best to win.
Night all, and try not to lynch anyone that might be townie while I'm gone.
thatbennyguy
1612
I investigated Gourd_Clae to be guilty, and his portrait says something of a King, not a Death Miller (he's got a crown). Even Marrend said he was a king. Death Miller is a kind of out-there role for a small game like this, and I'm betting on me not being crazy, so-
#lynch Gourd_Clae
#lynch Gourd_Clae
author=thatbennyguy
I investigated Gourd_Clae to be guilty, and his portrait says something of a King, not a Death Miller (he's got a crown). Even Marrend said he was a king. Death Miller is a kind of out-there role for a small game like this, and I'm betting on me not being crazy, so-
#lynch Gourd_Clae
I already explained to you Deth Miller is a mafia role and has nothing to do with how you look.
#Cancel
#Lynch Gourd Clae
The moment of the thruth, in this moment, if gourd isn't mafia, mafia could jump and cause hammer time, I just hope that doesn't happen.
#Lynch Gourd Clae
The moment of the thruth, in this moment, if gourd isn't mafia, mafia could jump and cause hammer time, I just hope that doesn't happen.
Hm, my character is a prince and the picture has nothing to do with my role. I don't think we can count on flavour to pick mafia, unless it were the character itself.
Who hasn't proven their character so far? That's probably who we should look at most suspiciously. One of which is you, Chearlie. In fact, going over your posts, you're looking kinda suspicious the way you jump back and forth between people, especially since a few of your last ten posts say you think Gourd is innocent, then suddenly you're voting to lynch him? That is odd.
And benny, you've posted your portrait, but we know now that they can't be relied on - it's the name that counts and you haven't given up yours. Mirror also hasn't revealed his character, which, again, is suspicious. Or rabitz.
And yet, I thought we all agreed to do so. What gives?
Who hasn't proven their character so far? That's probably who we should look at most suspiciously. One of which is you, Chearlie. In fact, going over your posts, you're looking kinda suspicious the way you jump back and forth between people, especially since a few of your last ten posts say you think Gourd is innocent, then suddenly you're voting to lynch him? That is odd.
And benny, you've posted your portrait, but we know now that they can't be relied on - it's the name that counts and you haven't given up yours. Mirror also hasn't revealed his character, which, again, is suspicious. Or rabitz.
And yet, I thought we all agreed to do so. What gives?
Actually, the more I look at past posts, the more I'm growing suspicious of Chearlie. Not only has he tried to foster guilt onto TBG, myself, Gourd and Mirror, he's also tried to start a lynch mob on both Gourd and Mirror - Mirror for no real reason and Gourd because Mirror decided to lynch first. It almost looks like he's desperate to get a lynch no matter what.
The current flavour situation won't reveal anything to us, so lynching won't garner much information for us. The best plan is to have benny have another go at investigation and seeing if it pans out and verifies his character sanity at all. That's why I said a no-lynch would be best, but Chearlie is looking more and more scumlike with how he's been acting. Am I the only one that thinks so?
The current flavour situation won't reveal anything to us, so lynching won't garner much information for us. The best plan is to have benny have another go at investigation and seeing if it pans out and verifies his character sanity at all. That's why I said a no-lynch would be best, but Chearlie is looking more and more scumlike with how he's been acting. Am I the only one that thinks so?
what do we gain from a no lynch, liberty?
can you assure us that TBG will live another day, also, how will we know tomorrow if he is sane or not?
I am willing to change my vote to Chearlie, if you think that he is mafia.
But I want to take action today.
It's a small game, and from the moment the words "Death Miller" came into play I just want to know who the fucking mafia are and be done with this.
can you assure us that TBG will live another day, also, how will we know tomorrow if he is sane or not?
I am willing to change my vote to Chearlie, if you think that he is mafia.
But I want to take action today.
It's a small game, and from the moment the words "Death Miller" came into play I just want to know who the fucking mafia are and be done with this.
No lynch would mean someone would die in the night but we won't lost, that means one less suspicious, but I am pretty sure rabitZ will be the one since he is the less suspicious and we would be the same, another reason, the only one I consider good is TBG could do an investigation, but I don't trust him much, So I feel would be in the same place that we are now. Although we could go for it if we need to.
Also I didn't vote for MM for no reason, I just didn't tell it. I voted for him cause he have to decided for someone at the end of the day, so I start making couples of who could be mafia and MM turn out to be in most of them. Also, the only who haven't voted yet are MM and Liberty, I am doing a very risky move, pretending, one of them could be mafia and they won't vote cause they would kill one of them, liberty has good reasons of not to vote, but MM haven't talk to much about it, I just hope gourd and MM are mafia.
Also I didn't vote for MM for no reason, I just didn't tell it. I voted for him cause he have to decided for someone at the end of the day, so I start making couples of who could be mafia and MM turn out to be in most of them. Also, the only who haven't voted yet are MM and Liberty, I am doing a very risky move, pretending, one of them could be mafia and they won't vote cause they would kill one of them, liberty has good reasons of not to vote, but MM haven't talk to much about it, I just hope gourd and MM are mafia.
I think he might be. He's playing really scummy, bouncing back and forth between people like he is. I'm not sure if that's his regular mode of play, but it is rather suspicious, if you ask me. He was one of the few who didn't vote cave, almost like he knew he was innocent. The only people who know who are innocent or not are mafia. This is really suspicious.
And yes, I can guarantee benny's safety tonight, though it'd probably compromise my own. See, I'm an inventor (nothing to do with my role as a Prince >.<; ) and I just so happen to have a bullet proof vest on my person. I'll give it to him and he can make it safe through the night hours. If you want a complete list of my inventory, just let me know. I've only got a few, though, since I used one last night to do a reading.
Since any mafia would be crazy to claim Death Miller (it's practically a death sentence for anyone who does claim it) I'm inclined to believe that that just might be Gourd's role. Sure, it doesn't fit with the whole King motif, but who said roles had to fit flavour?
The reason I said it'd help prove his sanity is because of the claim that Gourd was mafia - it was a chance that Benny might be paranoid, crazy or random and lynching Gourd on that alone could spell disaster - especially since sanity isn't known by the player. The chances remain that he might be random (we'll be screwed if this is the case), paranoid (which is still a possibility) or just plain insane (this is looking less likely now that Gourd has claimed). If he targets someone we know is innocent, then that should give us both confirmation that he's not paranoid as well as someone we can know for a fact is townie. We can build off this information to try and root out the mafia among us - especially since they'll be gunning for innocents. That way, we have at least another day to work with.
And yes, I can guarantee benny's safety tonight, though it'd probably compromise my own. See, I'm an inventor (nothing to do with my role as a Prince >.<; ) and I just so happen to have a bullet proof vest on my person. I'll give it to him and he can make it safe through the night hours. If you want a complete list of my inventory, just let me know. I've only got a few, though, since I used one last night to do a reading.
Since any mafia would be crazy to claim Death Miller (it's practically a death sentence for anyone who does claim it) I'm inclined to believe that that just might be Gourd's role. Sure, it doesn't fit with the whole King motif, but who said roles had to fit flavour?
The reason I said it'd help prove his sanity is because of the claim that Gourd was mafia - it was a chance that Benny might be paranoid, crazy or random and lynching Gourd on that alone could spell disaster - especially since sanity isn't known by the player. The chances remain that he might be random (we'll be screwed if this is the case), paranoid (which is still a possibility) or just plain insane (this is looking less likely now that Gourd has claimed). If he targets someone we know is innocent, then that should give us both confirmation that he's not paranoid as well as someone we can know for a fact is townie. We can build off this information to try and root out the mafia among us - especially since they'll be gunning for innocents. That way, we have at least another day to work with.
thatbennyguy
1612
author=MirrorMasq
Liberty, 1 mafia means 1:8 at the beggining of the game. This is too much imbalanced, Marrend wouldn't do that. Nolynch today is counter-productive and even leads to our loss if there is one indi and mafia will lynch townie tonight.
If you want to do something today, MM, you're gonna have to vote Gourd_Clae. I'm starting to have reason to be Liberty's just trying to stall us so that the mafia can pick us off. Either way, nolynching is a crazy idea, because we're desperate as it is.
And desperate times call for desperate measures.
