MAFIA OF THE DEATH NOTE - GAME THREAD

How do my points not stand? There was absolutely a reason to vote for TBG, there is never "proof" in mafia. What was going on was hardly confusing, and yes, he did cast suspicion onto everyone voting for TBG by implying that the votes were unfounded.

As for Gourd:
1 - he first claimed that his second win was to see Mello dead. This is a possible confirmation that Mello is a character in this game.
2 - he then claimed to be Near. This doesn't make sense in the context of the flavour.
3 - my scum detector is flashing.



(Also, I didn't see that there were two Independent roles. For some reason I saw mafia and figured it was, well mafia? WTF, eyes?)

author=Liberty
I don't see where that came from, Cave. It wasn't in this topic or the other one so it's META since it focusses on other games. Not this one.

RIP Liberty, for her incoming vig kill, metagaming is just using out-of-game information to influence your decisions in the game. that's what it actually means. Trying to break the game open by perusing your Death Note mangas or w/e and determining who hates who is using out-of-game information.

Can we please stop discussing this now since it does absolutely nothing to help town

author=CAVE_DOG_IS_BACK
How do my points not stand? There was absolutely a reason to vote for TBG, there is never "proof" in mafia. What was going on was hardly confusing, and yes, he did cast suspicion onto everyone voting for TBG by implying that the votes were unfounded.

No, he asked why we were voting on nothing. He never said anything that suggested that he thought we were suspicous because he thought we were wrong. That would be like me saying I think you're suspicious because I don't agree with lynching rabitZ. Really, all he did was say he fellt there was ntohing there and he didn't vote. I can't say I agree with him, but he never said "I think it's weird that you'r all voting for TBG" He just asked why.

Despite me being disagreed with Liberty (I'm too think that Mello is mafia(indi)), I'm more and more convinced in her innocence. She stands on her wrong and useless point against all others so fiercely... I don't think mafia wish to draw so much attention.
Gourd is more townie for me right now as well because of similiar reasons. So I'll #cancel. I'll watch a bit more to decide my vote.

author=itrombe

author=Liberty
??? might be Ryuk, though.

This is actually a really good idea. What sort of role/power do you think Ryuk would have in this?

Liberty, do not answer this question.

No, he asked why we were voting on nothing. He never said anything that suggested that he thought we were suspicous because he thought we were wrong. That would be like me saying I think you're suspicious because I don't agree with lynching rabitZ. Really, all he did was say he fellt there was ntohing there and he didn't vote. I can't say I agree with him, but he never said "I think it's weird that you'r all voting for TBG" He just asked why.

I think you're not reading into his post enough. To me it sounded like "Are we really lynching TBG for this?"

And I don't buy him being confused. There's not really anything to be confused about. People who act confused are generally scum (see: Liberty last game)

I told you where it came from. In the post where I said it.

Liberty, stop it. It's pointless. And #vote itrombe.
He is trying to continue this distraction, but not like Lib in just fierce arguing, instead he's just... trying to push us to a new discussion.

That's likely. I'm not one to read into posts, so I'm regarding it at face value. I think that Marrend has said alot of things wrong when I look into that but I dunno, I'm looking at it wrong.

Also, TBG is not being pursued why? Because he's vehemently defending his point? I did that alot when I'm mafia. Or, is that not it?