Full Games List
Featured Games
New Games
Reviews
Media
Images
Blogs
Game Updates
Images Feedback Summary
Game Design Highlights
Tutorials
Articles
Scripts
Utilities / Plugins
Resources
Engines
Engine Bulletins
What is Makerscore?
Past Events
Achievements
Misaos
Forums
Post History
Chat
New to RMN?
Full Store List
RMN Music Pack (free)
MILLER'S HOLLOW MAFIA - GAME THREAD
Posts
Adon237
View playlists
Close
author=CAVE_DUMB
That was the only reason you stated for voting him, so it is a logical assumption that it is your only reason for voting him, as there is no reason for anyone to withhold reasoning for their lynches unless they are scum. Are you scum?
author=Yellow Magic
I also noticed that PlatinumAshes did the whole ratios thing that is so common amongst Mafia/Werewolf teams. Combined with the eagerness to elect someone at this early stage in the game, I think I'm ready to cast my vote.
I'd completely understand if you thought my reasons were BAD and then called me out on it (as I didn't realise that a sheriff could be picked at random if there was no clear majority at the time of voting), but Holy Massive Oversight Batman.
I don't understand your last two sentences.
Then read them again! Although admittedly, PA DID vote for wildwes right off the bat so I can't exactly say he/she's been in the background or anything. I'm not feeling the post with the numbers, though, and not just because of the numbers, but the pointing out of what PA admitted was obvious. If it was so obvious, why point it out in the first place?
author=Happyauthor=CAVE_DOG_IS_BACKSo now I'm supposed to have believed you were a cop? Also, you still seem to be entirely missing my play here. You just said how my act appears.
nobody in that game had claimed cop on day 1. also, I don't know what else I can say other than that I was literally required to read all the posts in that thread.
Now when it comes to night, who do you suppose the werewolves will kill first Cave?
i am not missing anything. please do not pretend that you are some kind of mastermind. i had two possibilities in mind for you: either you were just playing shittily or pretending to be very bad. i gave you the benefit of the doubt because the latter is so awe-inspirngly stupid
you are not trapping anyone for a number of reasons. the first is that the minute anyone says "yeah happy is playing bad" you give the game up. if you actually wanted to entrap someone with this, the proper thing to do would be to wait for some kind of a bandwagon to build on you, and then explain what you were doing, identifying who was just jumping on the bandwagon because it was easy. instead, when one person called you out, you immediately screamed that it was an act, achieving nothing. the second is that town players have legitimate reasons to call people out for bad play. this compounds itself on the first reason and holy shit i guess you have to be town to have not thought this through at all. there is no web of lies or multitude of shadows.
your second post is a meaningless question. I have a gambit for you to try running. it's very experimental. After this game, it shall be known as the cavedog gambit in honor of its maker. Here is how it is done: You look for scum and then lynch them. The trick for this gambit to work is to be correct.
author=Zeuzio
Yeah, sorry for lurking and stuff. I was hanging out with friends and was not able to check the game on most of the 4th and 5th, and I was exhausted by the time I got back, only to have six more pages of posts to look through. Sorry if I haven't been able to come up with a solid opinion of everyone yet. :P
you haven't been lurking at all, but you have been posting. But to what end...that is the problem. I will forgive you if you do this thing you say you will do and also elect me and help me murder wildwes.
author=Yellow Magicauthor=CAVE_DUMB
That was the only reason you stated for voting him, so it is a logical assumption that it is your only reason for voting him, as there is no reason for anyone to withhold reasoning for their lynches unless they are scum. Are you scum?author=Yellow Magic
I also noticed that PlatinumAshes did the whole ratios thing that is so common amongst Mafia/Werewolf teams. Combined with the eagerness to elect someone at this early stage in the game, I think I'm ready to cast my vote.
I'd completely understand if you thought my reasons were BAD and then called me out on it (as I didn't realise that a sheriff could be picked at random if there was no clear majority at the time of voting), but Holy Massive Oversight Batman.
I don't understand your last two sentences.
Then read them again! Although admittedly, PA DID vote for wildwes right off the bat so I can't exactly say he/she's been in the background or anything. I'm not feeling the post with the numbers, though, and not just because of the numbers, but the pointing out of what PA admitted was obvious. If it was so obvious, why point it out in the first place?
Here is a list of other players wanting to elect someone this early in the game:
Me
Gourd
Trihan
Liberty
Platinum
Dudesoft
Adon
Wildwes
I honestly didn't think that was a real reason for voting him because if so wow I hope town can survive the apparent 8-man scumteam. Please feel free to nitpick about how there were only x people voting to elect at the time of your previous post. The number was perhaps six. So far, your reasoning for voting him is that he guessed how many people might be on the scumteam and wants to elect someone. These are not real reasons to think someone is scum. I ask again, are you scum? Because the only reason I can see for you thinking that Platinum would be the most worthy to lynch today using that criteria as a basis for the lynch would be because you are scum and cannot produce actual content.
Also, no. you rephrase your last two sentences. I have no idea wtf is being said.
CAVE_DOG, earlier you were pretty suspicious of PlatinumAshes but now you've backed down a bit, and almost defending him, saying, and I quote, "PlatinumAshes is a lazy lynch and I've seen zero reasoning as to why we should kill him today." Care to explain the change?
#lynch wildwes
Cavedog, what happens if wildwes is town? People will definitely become suspicious of you, and I will look like scum because I lynched the same as you.
Cavedog, what happens if wildwes is town? People will definitely become suspicious of you, and I will look like scum because I lynched the same as you.
i said he was an okay lynch at one point. I changed my mind upon rethinking and witnessing the influx of absolutely godawful votes for him. also, he falls under the wildwes clause: he will reveal himself explicitly if he is scum, as he is apparently eight years old like me.
author=Adon237
#lynch wildwesCavedog, what happens if wildwes is town? People will definitely become suspicious of you, and I will look like scum because I lynched the same as you.
first of all: I'm not voting for wildwes right now. Second of all: Do you have reason to believe that he is town?
author=CAVE_DOG_IS_BACK
I honestly didn't think that was a real reason for voting him because if so wow I hope town can survive the apparent 8-man scumteam. Please feel free to nitpick about how there were only x people voting to elect at the time of your previous post. The number was perhaps six. So far, your reasoning for voting him is that he guessed how many people might be on the scumteam and wants to elect someone. These are not real reasons to think someone is scum. I ask again, are you scum? Because the only reason I can see for you thinking that Platinum would be the most worthy to lynch today using that criteria as a basis for the lynch would be because you are scum and cannot produce actual content.
Also, no. you rephrase your last two sentences. I have no idea wtf is being said.
Yeah, uh, you mentioned none of this to me previously, instead jumping on to the ratio post. Why? Could it be that the post was a genuine mistake by your fellow Werewolf, and that you had to play it down?
author=CAVE_DOG_IS_BACK
i said he was an okay lynch at one point. I changed my mind upon rethinking and witnessing the influx of absolutely godawful votes for him.
Weak reasoning to be honest. You DID say "PlatinumAshes is a lazy lynch and I've seen zero reasoning as to why we should kill him today", but this can't be true because you came up with your own reasoning today. To me at least, it makes sense that you were playing pretend with PlatinumAshes, but then when votes started piling up you had no choice but to start defending him.
I'd like to hear other people's thoughts on this just to make sure I'm not getting overexcited. Anyone else seeing what I'm seeing?
no it's because, as i said, if you are using 'wants to elect' as a basis for voting someone then you are also by extension calling half the thread scummy. is the next logical step perhaps to call for the heads of all players who use capital letters and proper punctuation because I am ready to do it!! also, seeing the roster for this game, if i was a werewolf i would be bussing all my werewolf buddies and surfing on their dead bodies to the finish line.
author=Yellow Magicauthor=CAVE_DOG_IS_BACKWeak reasoning to be honest. You DID say "PlatinumAshes is a lazy lynch and I've seen zero reasoning as to why we should kill him today", but this can't be true because you came up with your own reasoning today. To me at least, it makes sense that you were playing pretend with PlatinumAshes, but then when votes started piling up you had no choice but to start defending him.
i said he was an okay lynch at one point. I changed my mind upon rethinking and witnessing the influx of absolutely godawful votes for him.
I'd like to hear other people's thoughts on this just to make sure I'm not getting overexcited. Anyone else seeing what I'm seeing?
"i've seen zero reasoning as to why we should kill him today" pretty obviously, to me, refers to the votes cast for him by other people. literally my only post that could be construed as me wanting to lynch him said that he would be an okay lynch but that there were better options available. this is not contradictory because half of the people in this game would be okay lynches. he became a lazy lynch when more people started to vote for him with awful reasoning. Adon's reasoning was some kind of web of alignments that could somehow be construed by his flip (untrue) and gourd's was "the guy's acting suspicious!!"
I've already acknowledged several times that the election thinking may have been a bad reason, and I readily admit that! I'm still not convinced that PlatinumAshes is in the clear, though, and debating with you's not helping - so yeah, I do believe that you and PA are in cahoots.
#cancel (lynch)
The first day is always the worst day.
Wildwes is really new at this, so I am going to assume any odd behavior is him fudging up because he has the same problem I do. Unless there is undeniable proof that he is scum, lynching him won't make any sense.
Cave_Dog your opinions are doing some sort of hop-scotch in a mirror thing and you seem to be AGAINST everyone.
The first day is always the worst day.
Wildwes is really new at this, so I am going to assume any odd behavior is him fudging up because he has the same problem I do. Unless there is undeniable proof that he is scum, lynching him won't make any sense.
Cave_Dog your opinions are doing some sort of hop-scotch in a mirror thing and you seem to be AGAINST everyone.
i am against anyone who is against good sense and pure ideals, but my targeting reticle is currently centered on zeuzio. arguing with other townspeople is perfectly normal because you have to convince them to lynch the right person instead of the wrong person.
