[PLAY TIME] BULLET BALLOT MAFIA

Eh, we all have our "Oops, I was led astray" days.
No-one is at a disadvantage except maybe YM, since I'm not 100% sure I trust her, even slightly, people keep pointing out her lies and she seems fairly defensive. Let's see how that turns out, eh?
Also I don't think odd is mafia, but your theory could work (in theory) BADUM CH.
Anyway, sacrificing odd for Piano would be a TERRIBLE move on their part, we were already suspicious, I mean most of the heat on odd was by Piano himself, his last chance to mislead us.

Well, of course I know that, Kloe! It's a good rule of thumb for now.

author=Gourd_Clae
I voted for YM. And that is... an interesting death? I think Jeroen is innocent - I'm pretty sure no mafia would have suspected their scum buddy so quickly and then defended the decision so thoroughly when questioned.

I already shared. I was making the list for the sake of who we should be looking at, but it can always be changed.

Oh, sorry, I was just basing that on the cool list you showed.
I understand why you voted for YM, though Piano was the true villain. Maybe YM is too, but I'm sure she'll go "OBJECTION" to that.
Right now we haven't got much to go on, most people are asleep or don't know the day started.

Good Night Gourd, just don't get eaten by YM.

Ha, I knew it. There was no way piano was innocent with that tirade. I also voted for him, obviously.

author=Kloe
I don't think Isrieri was killed for some grand reason though, I think it was becaus there was no grand reason and that it means we can't get closer by examining who died.

Why do you say that? There's no doubt about the fact that he is a very strong player, so that's already a possible reason why he was killed off. But only people who have played games with him in the past should know that. I think it's very likely there's another experienced player in scumteam.

Incidentally, YM is a "he", Kloe.

I'm not sure. So far, OddRabbit has been the most suspicious out of everyone. But piano was targeting him pretty hard, so it seems unlikely he's scum. It seems more likely piano was just trying to push the lynch onto him in order not to lynched himself. I guess it's possible that was just an act, though? Or that piano tried to throw him under the bus? Doesn't seem likely, though. Especially not so early in the game, on day 2.

Cool~ We made some progress last night. I also voted for pianotm; glad to see that that hunch paid off.

I'm quite curious who voted for Isreiri yesterday. Mostly because that was not a name that was discussed with any suspicion at all and I expected all the votes to be between oddRABBIT, YM, and piano. But with Isreiri dying last night, I doubt anyone is going to own up to that.

Gourd is not the only one to praise piano's way of playing, Isreiri did as well:

author=Isrieri
piano, I swear to god, if you're mafia then you're doing an excellent job.

A think I plainly just don't understand because piano was nothing but suspicious to me. Stringing along everyone's thoughts, being one of the most active people and constantly stating that mafia will try to keep quiet to slide under the radar. Avoiding accusation with counter-accusations and tirades. idk - maybe it's being a noob and not knowing the rules, but everything piano did was suspicious as heck.

They also jumped on me the first day for what was literally the silliest thing. Jumping on people seemed to be their game. Godly? I don't understand it.

Isreiri can't explain this comment now, and Gourd has already said they do not know. I think it's hard to suspect Gourd based on this. But there is some other things I would like us to look at about Gourd's behaviour.

author=Gourd_Clae
In all fairness, that is a very strong scum tell. In piano's case he just gets a bit excited as evidenced by previous games I've played with him. (It was mostly cave who made him angry, but you know~)

First we have this. Gourd was defending pinao's tirade. I find this VERY odd.

I also don't think Gourd ever put much questioning into piano's claims and went along easily with their votes; and I cannot recall piano ever pointing their finger at Gourd. True, they voted for YM last night, not oddRABBIT, but if they voted earlier in the time period, suspicion was being pointed more strongly at YM.

Gourd has returned to my suspect list.

--

There's the deal with oddRABBIT as well. Was that or was that not a last ditch effort to protect piano?

I had the null vote last night and I'm pretty sure it saved your life from hanging due to a tie, oddRABBIT. Don't make me regret it.

Wait, so you're accusing me? I voted for pianotm the first day too, you know.

author=MakioKuta
Oh, we're saying who we voted for? I voted for pianotm. If only because they were adamant about orchestrating us against Ratty.

Basically I have no good reasons; I don't know what I'm doing.

I voted for piano last night and also nulled piano's vote.

piano was the most obvious person who was going to vote for oddRABBIT and NOT for himself. I felt that to get piano to hang, that was the best choice. And I wanted piano to hang because, like you, I've suspected him from very early on. For all the reasons I stated.