[GAME OVER] M.A.F.I.A:PANDEMIC EDITION(POSTGAME DISCUSSION)
Posts
Okay. Yeah, you cancelled pretty quick. It's actually one of the things that makes me think you're town. Of course, as psy is right to remind us, that might have changed with the previous night phase.
I'm a little wary to follow psy's reasoning. He keeps going back to anecdotal evidence. It sounds convincing, but it could also be a ploy to divert lynch attempts from himself. Anecdotal evidence really seems to me like something that only gets used as defense in mafia, so to see it used offensively catches my eye.
:P I actually didn't expect my self-lynch to count so that was a surprise. The lynch seemed a bit early to me, but it was the beginning of the day so I could see you trying to get the most out of it/making a joke.
author=Blobofgoo
My silence at the end of day 1 was due to me playing Dark Souls 2 for 7 hours straight :v
>.< It takes all types of people I guess.
author=Ratty524
Right, anyone but InfectionFiles. After IF came out and the fact that someone pointed out that it wouldn't be fair to hammer someone without them speaking up, I cancelled. Sorry I wasn't clear on that.
I admit part of my reasoning for changing to Xoe was bandwagoning, but on the first day phase who could have been a better option, and with his slightly different posting style compared to the past, how could I have no been suspicious of him?
You definitely weren't clear on that, and that's a very different scenario to "switching votes". Sorry, I'm not convinced.
author=pianotm
Okay. Yeah, you cancelled pretty quick.
The cancel wasn't really a cancel - he just switched votes to someone else (Kloe).
So that's votes for four different people on a single day.
author=Gourd_Claeauthor=Blobofgoo>.< It takes all types of people I guess.
My silence at the end of day 1 was due to me playing Dark Souls 2 for 7 hours straight :v
What are you implying? XD
author=Yellow Magicauthor=Ratty524You definitely weren't clear on that, and that's a very different scenario to "switching votes". Sorry, I'm not convinced.
Right, anyone but InfectionFiles. After IF came out and the fact that someone pointed out that it wouldn't be fair to hammer someone without them speaking up, I cancelled. Sorry I wasn't clear on that.
I admit part of my reasoning for changing to Xoe was bandwagoning, but on the first day phase who could have been a better option, and with his slightly different posting style compared to the past, how could I have no been suspicious of him?
author=pianotm
Okay. Yeah, you cancelled pretty quick.
The cancel wasn't really a cancel - he just switched votes to someone else (Kloe).
So that's votes for four different people on a single day.
good case YM. I read it and it held my attention.
#lynch ratty
author=pianotm
Frogge, why are you trying to make yourself look suspicious? (ノωノ)
I would also like an answer to this question.
I think it's good case as well. I think it's also interesting that ratty is protecting IF, I wonder if maybe that's indicative of the two being scum?
If one of the two flip scum we would have a definite lead in the other person.
If one of the two flip scum we would have a definite lead in the other person.
Well, that's not fair. My last words weren't an act I very well thought I was going to be lynched. As much as I would love to claim that it was so moving to you guys it was very theatrical for a reason.
I'm not sure if this is your game or ploy but I'll nip that in the bud and vote #lynch Ratty524
Sorry man, you defended me and I hate to do it like this but I'm also looking out for myself. You couldbe defending me because as many of you I'm sure believe I'm town so it makes yourself look good. I've been watching and looking back for a suspect which honestly was Blob as my target. But there's enough evidence along with your current style that gives me enough reason to vote this for now.
We have a lot of time left so stuff can change. I dont mean to jump on a bandwagon here especially towards someone who has defended me but that's what I got for now.
I'm not sure if this is your game or ploy but I'll nip that in the bud and vote #lynch Ratty524
Sorry man, you defended me and I hate to do it like this but I'm also looking out for myself. You couldbe defending me because as many of you I'm sure believe I'm town so it makes yourself look good. I've been watching and looking back for a suspect which honestly was Blob as my target. But there's enough evidence along with your current style that gives me enough reason to vote this for now.
We have a lot of time left so stuff can change. I dont mean to jump on a bandwagon here especially towards someone who has defended me but that's what I got for now.
I don't know, I can be pretty impassioned when I'm being scum hunted. CAVE_DOG is usually very perceptive, but with Ratty, I'm seeing something very different from what everyone else is seeing. I do think he's being a bit cautious, but what do you expect? The guy was almost named Mafia's new Dudesoft a few weeks ago.
I'm going to wait and see. Of course, then there's this little tidbit:
This looks like scum shifting to me. I don't know how many people think IF is innocent, but my comments earlier should make clear that I don't think he's innocent. There's enough impetus on voting for Ratty that IF doesn't have to scum shift like this. So why is he?
#Lynch InfectionFiles
I'm going to wait and see. Of course, then there's this little tidbit:
InfectionFiles
Sorry man, you defended me and I hate to do it like this but I'm also looking out for myself. You couldbe defending me because as many of you I'm sure believe I'm town so it makes yourself look good.
This looks like scum shifting to me. I don't know how many people think IF is innocent, but my comments earlier should make clear that I don't think he's innocent. There's enough impetus on voting for Ratty that IF doesn't have to scum shift like this. So why is he?
#Lynch InfectionFiles
Well, I'm not scum.
I've been looking for someone, anyone to suspect because it's abit hard right now to get anything from anyone. I could of course just go back to CAVE but I dont think he's mafia. I guess he could very well be now because of the virus but that's impossible to tell.
However, you piano have the need in this game to try and lynch whoever is most obviously town. That's scummy. You aren't targeting any veterans or those who haven't given themselves away so easily. The fact is you know I'm town and that's why you're trying to lynch me. It's a big difference from last game where I made it obvious and you defended me because of it. Because you were in fact town, so of course you would. Now it's a tad too obvious because I'm an easy target. The fact that I'm not dead is because mafia wanted to infect somebody rather than kill them which is the smart play.
so
#cancel
#vote Pianotm[/b and this isn't retaliatory, just something I've been feeling for awhile. You want the easy town kill knowing you aren't killing a special, someone you would like to infect.
I've been looking for someone, anyone to suspect because it's abit hard right now to get anything from anyone. I could of course just go back to CAVE but I dont think he's mafia. I guess he could very well be now because of the virus but that's impossible to tell.
However, you piano have the need in this game to try and lynch whoever is most obviously town. That's scummy. You aren't targeting any veterans or those who haven't given themselves away so easily. The fact is you know I'm town and that's why you're trying to lynch me. It's a big difference from last game where I made it obvious and you defended me because of it. Because you were in fact town, so of course you would. Now it's a tad too obvious because I'm an easy target. The fact that I'm not dead is because mafia wanted to infect somebody rather than kill them which is the smart play.
so
#cancel
#vote Pianotm[/b and this isn't retaliatory, just something I've been feeling for awhile. You want the easy town kill knowing you aren't killing a special, someone you would like to infect.
welp I screwed up the bold so the #cancel still stands and #lynch pianotm
Lynch Tally
CAVE_DOG_IS_BACK-1-Frogge,
Ratty524-2-Yellow Magic, CAVE_DOG_IS_BACK,
InfectionFiles-1- pianotm,
pianotm-1- InfectionFiles,
Unused Votes-4
CAVE_DOG_IS_BACK-1-Frogge,
Ratty524-2-Yellow Magic, CAVE_DOG_IS_BACK,
InfectionFiles-1- pianotm,
pianotm-1- InfectionFiles,
Unused Votes-4
InfectionFiles
You aren't targeting any veterans or those who haven't given themselves away so easily.
You say this while tagging onto a bandwagon on Ratty. Can you say, "Hypocrit"? So, where's your case against YM?
However, you piano have the need in this game to try and lynch whoever is most obviously town.
No, I have the need to get rid of whoever's proven himself not useful to town. You went after Cave_Dog for the flimsiest reason. He's acting strange! He must be scum! Now, you make no effort to scum hunt on day to and glam onto an easy lynch, and that's exactly what Ratty is; an easy lynch. But I'm going to be the one laughing when he flips town.
Because you're not town, are you? You want to lynch me but are worried/or find it hilarious if Ratty flips town? I'll flip town if you lynch me. You lose either way and then you won't be laughing because the game is going to be brutal after this Day/Night.
The biggest thing for me personally is that you don't give off that sense of security you have before and that worries me. I could always vote for Ratty still. And like I said it's not an easy intentional bandwagon because y'all make it difficult.
I suspect Psy because how strong he is and also Yellow Magic because I'm suspicious of anyone who voted for Xoe. Bar myself because I know what I am, Kloe made it painfully obvious that she was the scientist and her defending Xoe made it clear that she was town. xoe could have been a special but didn't role claim it. So just as I'm suspecting you I am them as well. Except you voted for me. I dont want to suspect them since they defended me. you've done nothing but hound me this game. So you're my first target.
The biggest thing for me personally is that you don't give off that sense of security you have before and that worries me. I could always vote for Ratty still. And like I said it's not an easy intentional bandwagon because y'all make it difficult.
I suspect Psy because how strong he is and also Yellow Magic because I'm suspicious of anyone who voted for Xoe. Bar myself because I know what I am, Kloe made it painfully obvious that she was the scientist and her defending Xoe made it clear that she was town. xoe could have been a special but didn't role claim it. So just as I'm suspecting you I am them as well. Except you voted for me. I dont want to suspect them since they defended me. you've done nothing but hound me this game. So you're my first target.



















