[MAFIA] - SHIN MEGAMI TENSEI {GAME OVER}

Posts

oddRABBIT
I feel bored. How odd.
1979
I suppose it looks suspicious that I have not posted yet. Though, coming from someone as useless as me, I'm sure no one cares.
Kloe
I lost my arms in a tragic chibi accident
2236
I care Odd! What does your killer instinct say abkut who we should lynch?
CAVE_DOG_IS_BACK
On sunny days, I go out walking
1142
barely even demonic at all votecount

No Lynch - 1: Ratty
Kloe - 1: Lockez
Liberty - 0: Kloe
pianotm - 0: Ratty, Lockez
Lockez - 0 pianotm

Deadline in 56 hours.
Kloe
I lost my arms in a tragic chibi accident
2236
Welp, my head is on the chopping block, but look on the brightside, it's Day 1, the madness day of silly lynches and we still have 56 hours to go! :D
author=LockeZ
So, anything interesting happen on night 0? Anyone get any useful information? Find the key to Kloe's secret basement underneath the farmhouse?

Cave's paranoiapost to kick things off kind of discourages any kind of information sharing. (also @Frogge and @Ratty)

At everyone looking at no-lynch, what additional info are you waiting for? Trying to analyze nightkill?
Kloe
I lost my arms in a tragic chibi accident
2236
Well, I guess we are? I'm just waiting for someone to say something which feels suspicious!
LockeZ
I'd really like to get rid of LockeZ. His play style is way too unpredictable. He's always like this too. If he ran a country, he'd just kill and imprison people at random until crime stopped.
5958
As far as I can tell, the chaos team is the scum team, since they win if they outnumber the law team. The law team has to kill all chaos to win, so law is town.

Anyway, I performed a night action last night. The information I got is not useful yet, though. I'll share it when it is.
pianotm
The TM is for Totally Magical.
32388
Okay, LockeZ's probably town, unless he doesn't know his alignment (according to the game logic, that's a thing). After being warned that any information, no matter what it is, puts one at risk, he's willfully volunteering information, however vague it may be.
I do not yet know much either. Based on the information I have, I do think lynching will help us more than no-lynching, but as we have no real leads I can't argue against a no-lynch either. I'm fine with a no-lynch if we have no reads closer to the end of the day.
I used my power last night too. It... didn't do what I thought. >.<;

Had to ask for a LOT of clarification from Cave about how it works, but at least I have a good handle on it now.

And yes, from the sounds of it Law = Town, Chaos = Mafia, but apparently there might be a third faction too. At least, it was alluded to in my PM.




So number crunching:
This game has 13 players. That means 2-3 mafia. Most likely 2. Number-wise, as I always say, it's better to wait for the night kill and gather information from that. So I'm voting #nolynch
pianotm
The TM is for Totally Magical.
32388
I don't like this no lynch talk, mostly because it won't get us anywhere. It doesn't put pressure on anyone. Usually, I can understand the reasoning, but in a game where information has been made so vital, I feel like just waiting for something to happen is a dumb move.

This looks like a really good place to start twisting thumb screws:

Frogge
Hey guys! I'm here. I didn't pay a whole lot of attention to my role pm so I don't really know if I'm mafia or town or what and I figure I don't wanna find out anymore, it could be fun playing thay way

Anyway hi I may be mafia or town or neutral


#Lynch Frogge

Thinking of it, I really don't like this comment:

oddRABBIT
I suppose it looks suspicious that I have not posted yet. Though, coming from someone as useless as me, I'm sure no one cares.


He is going out of his way to say this, when he could have said anything. I've got my eye on odd.
pianotm
The TM is for Totally Magical.
32388
Okay, so no lynch looks like it could be a legitimate thing, here. Fine.
I think I am okay with lynching Frogge just based on the fact that he could become mafia. It also seems weird to me that he would volunteer this information so early. On the other hand, if he's telling us the truth he could become town...I just don't know how this game works yet.

I'd be okay with lynching Frogge or not lynching, but I'll start with #Lynch Frogge for now.
Yeah... that's not helpful. FROGGE READ YOUR GODDAMN PM and if you have questions, ask Cave about it. Geez. >.>
Ratty524
The 524 is for 524 Stone Crabs
12986
While I feel like I'm on the same page as Liberty right now, I am REAAALLLLY tempted to switch my vote to Frogge for his claim, assuming he's not pulling off some massive bluff, but what would the point be in saying that you didn't read your pm at all?
No, I don't think no-lynch is legitimate here.

Basically, as part of my night 0 action, I got to learn that there's an "end of the world" event. I'm trying not to reveal more until I know how it could be dangerous. But my point is, I'm thinking there's a timed element to the game that possibly gives chaos/scum another win condition that involves ending the world rather than killing all town.

Also I point this out a lot but the more kill coming from non-mafia sources the better.

However I don't think Frogge is a great lynch because I question the setup of a game where someone "becomes" mafia. I think cave would've learned from the pandemic game how that turns out, even if the game is entirely built around it. Unless you guys think Frogge is actually scum now and just lying.

@Frogge, please clarify though.
Kloe
I lost my arms in a tragic chibi accident
2236
OH! Like the SMT game with the phones which are like "1 day to live"

That's dire info, Psy!

I still think we should lynch frogge for now though, #lynch Frogge (SORRY FROGGE!!)
oddRABBIT
I feel bored. How odd.
1979
You mean Devil Survivor 1 and 2?
This information is quite interesting, Psy. However, I'm keeping my vote until Frogge explains himself better.

I am becoming more and more uncomfortable with a no lynch. This whole "end of the world" business scares me. It's also less likely we'll get more information from the night phase considering how little we got from night 0.
Ratty524
The 524 is for 524 Stone Crabs
12986
Yeah uh... If that information is precisely how you phrase it, wouldn't it be a better idea to lynch Frogge just to move the game along? It's not like he's being helpful atm.

#cancel

Though, maybe we should give Frogge a chance to explain himself.