[MAFIA] RMN: WHEN THEY CRY (TEA PARTY)

author=OzzyTheOne
I pointed out how they could be trying to paint themselves as town. We have no real idea how many nightkill roles there are, yes. But have you ever been in a game of 12 with 3 nightkills plus lynch? I know it's meta and some people hate that, but I can't wrap my head around it. It rubs me the wrong way too much.

I have. We've had games on here like that. You've been in games where that could have happened but didn't.

Yellow Magic
Piano, I have a question about your hiding behind the closet. Does your flavour end there? Is there any other info about the attacker, like being a shadow or whatever?

No, it doesn't. Whoever tried to kill me shredded my bed. The PM describes the debris flying everywhere and then says in black bold letters that someone or something tried to kill me.

Agggghh if pianos argument is sound and there are indeed two protectors, it's still hard to believe. Both protectors protecting both the people that claim they were attacked? That could truly just be that rare coincidence but I just can't wrap my head around that actually happening.

I just assumed that the flavor didn't actually correlate with what saved me, but it is probably a mechanic thing that we don't understand.

Bold letters were my indicator too, but I didn't want to delve into pm details. In my flavor they hit me over the shoulder with a vase, which is then when I dove for cover under the stairwell.

I happen to know we have more than one protector as well, but I'd rather not say more than that for the time being.

author=ESBY
Let me ask you a little question. If I was scum then why would I be drawing this much attention to myself?

the only reason the spotlight has fallen on you is to a lack of doing anything, so, yes.

if you are town, i think it would be good if you stopped trying to defend yourself, because its pointless, and instead try to make a case for someone you think is scum


i think i'm cooling on ym. i've got a headache so i'll post more tomorrow. anyone know what's up with that blue text at the start of the day. is that supposed to be gourd's thoughts on who the killers are.

I think describing text formatting like bold and color is WAY over the line as far as rules against quoting PMs, guys. In this case it's probably mostly irrelevant, but please don't ruin the game with meta info.

Gourd's role was "Gunner." That's a vague, non-standard name for a role. My best guess is that it's either a Vigilante or a Paranoid Gun Owner. If he was a paranoid gun owner then I'm not too broken up about him being dead. If he was a vigilante, though, then there's no way in hell that there's a second vigilante. Which means one of the two people who was "attacked" last night is more likely to be lying.

author=LockeZ
Gourd's role was "Gunner." That's a vague, non-standard name for a role. My best guess is that it's either a Vigilante or a Paranoid Gun Owner. If he was a paranoid gun owner then I'm not too broken up about him being dead. If he was a vigilante, though, then there's no way in hell that there's a second vigilante. Which means one of the two people who was "attacked" last night is more likely to be lying.

This makes a lot of sense imo. I feel it very unlikely that two attacks happened in one night.

author=CAVE_DOG_IS_BACK
hello lockez. i am starting to reconsider my opinion of you as town. good night.

Wait, why? XD

author=LockeZ
Bite me.

lol, perfect response.

author=Muffle

author=LockeZ
Gourd's role was "Gunner." That's a vague, non-standard name for a role. My best guess is that it's either a Vigilante or a Paranoid Gun Owner. If he was a paranoid gun owner then I'm not too broken up about him being dead. If he was a vigilante, though, then there's no way in hell that there's a second vigilante. Which means one of the two people who was "attacked" last night is more likely to be lying.

This makes a lot of sense imo. I feel it very unlikely that two attacks happened in one night.

Well, we heard there were two guns. Those seem separate from any possible scum kill ability. Then again, that was in the flavor. Still, don't dismiss it.

author=CAVE_DOG_IS_BACK
hello lockez. i am starting to reconsider my opinion of you as town. good night.

Wait, why? XD

Because at the time, it seemed LockeZ came in to be a rules nazi and then posted nothing else for a time.

I'm starting to get a working theory on what's going on. I could be completely off base though. Before I go off on a big post that could end up being pointless, I need to ask: Has there ever been a game where scum has had multiple powers, but can only choose one per night phase?

If not, then my theory is completely wrong and not worth posting.