New account registration is temporarily disabled.

[MAFIA] TREACHEROUS - GAME OVER

Posts

Cap_H
DIGITAL IDENTITY CRISIS
6625
author=OzzyTheOne
However, this could simply just have been an oversight on your part, I don't think it's an indication of you being scum just yet, as it stands, you're clear from my radar. Also! Reminder to you all that apparently Scum couldn't talk to each other before night 1 if I understand correctly? So if both Cave and Piano were scum which is the most unlikely scenario, there is no way to know if either one bussed the other because they didn't know each other was scum. But I think this is the least likley scenario and Piano is most likley town.


If this was the case, it makes the game a lot spicier.
pianotm
The TM is for Totally Magical.
32388
It was just a very strange post, and it seemed like a very Ozzy-like post to me. I didn't particularly see it as scummy, but I can see how it would seem that way given the way he flipped his logic. Yeah...I think I'm going to

#guard Ozzy
PlatinumAshes
I am now certain that you are not scum and are just town trying to play scum as hard as possible.
0
author=pianotm
It was just a very strange post, and it seemed like a very Ozzy-like post to me. I didn't particularly see it as scummy, but I can see how it would seem that way given the way he flipped his logic. Yeah...I think I'm going to

#guard Ozzy

This post was hammer.
PlatinumAshes
I am now certain that you are not scum and are just town trying to play scum as hard as possible.
0
With 8 living players, it takes 5 votes to hammer.
Votecount:

Not voting: 7 - pianotm, Jeroen_Sol, Cap_H, Gourd_Clae, demonlord5000, AlaskanEmily, OzzyTheOne
OzzyTheOne 1 - psy_wombats

Town has voted to guard OzzyTheOne
Guarding Votecount:

Not Guarding: 4 - Jeroen_Sol, Gourd_Clae, demonlord5000, AlaskanEmily
Guarding: 4 - psy_wombats, OzzyTheOne, Cap_H, pianotm

Day 2 ends on Friday 12th of July, 19:00 CEST.
There are 45 hours and 42 minutes remaining.
1: Why would scum not know who the other scum is? Even if there's no daychat, mafia is still supposed to be informed. That there's even daychat at all on RMN is weird but no way scum didn't know who they were supposed to be guarding

2: Why would you all passing up a kill coming from probably-not-scum? Especially when we're at 8 players and need another kill for MYLO vs LYLO.

3: Without the daychat Ozzy probably just tried to bail out his partner and failed terribly. I mean come on, the guy was trying to get us to vote for what we now can see as *confirmed cop* vs *confirmed scum*
reaaally

Dammit now we do have to actually kill him today. Why does guarding have a hammer
Actually #cancel.

It should be pretty obvious to non-Ozzy town why Ozzy would be better off dead, and it'd be in scum's benefit to string him along to eat a daykill somewhere. Luckily we have a very short list of people who want Ozzy alive. I'm willing to vote piano or Cap today.
When cave flipped scum I was so relieved you would not believe. He was already pegging me as a lurker and being opportunistic even though the game hadn't gone very long at all. I thought if he flipped town then I would be a big target next day for sure. I'm so glad I followed my gut when it told me that he was being disingenuous in response to me. Especially since he has just town read me earlier seemingly arbitrarily ;w;
pianotm
The TM is for Totally Magical.
32388
psy_wombats
Actually #cancel.

It should be pretty obvious to non-Ozzy town why Ozzy would be better off dead, and it'd be in scum's benefit to string him along to eat a daykill somewhere. Luckily we have a very short list of people who want Ozzy alive. I'm willing to vote piano or Cap today.


Could you please explain this sentence? Are you saying you think Ozzy is town and think we'd benefit from killing him anyway?
Umm is it only clear to me that psy is kinda acting like a nut today or do I have to point it out?
Oh nvm piano is already asking about one of psys posts

I might have to look back at the op to see what it says about scum chat if anything. Ozzy seems to have a lot of info I don't about that topic.
Well I thought he was scum until certain people hammered to guard him. If he's town, it there would've been no great harm in losing him because no one is going to trust him all game and we'd wind up with LYLO in two days vs MYLO. So even if I was ~70% confident he was town, yes he should've been killed.
(Srry I have a few thoughts but I'm a little scattered atm. In order
Psy is bring kinda weird
Cave was almost certainly bussed
Ozzy seems to know a lot about scum chat
Why is everyone claiming)
I'll come back and clarify on those give me a hot second
Cap_H
DIGITAL IDENTITY CRISIS
6625
author=Gourd_Clae
When cave flipped scum I was so relieved you would not believe. He was already pegging me as a lurker and being opportunistic even though the game hadn't gone very long at all. I thought if he flipped town then I would be a big target next day for sure. I'm so glad I followed my gut when it told me that he was being disingenuous in response to me. Especially since he has just town read me earlier seemingly arbitrarily ;w;


If anything I wouldn't call CAVE a lurker. He was in the thread and it made his duel way more reliable at first.
pianotm
The TM is for Totally Magical.
32388
psy_wombats
Well I thought he was scum until certain people hammered to guard him. If he's town, it there would've been no great harm in losing him because no one is going to trust him all game and we'd wind up with LYLO in two days vs MYLO. So even if I was ~70% confident he was town, yes he should've been killed.


Fair. If Ozzy survives the day, I guess we've got at least one more night to investigate. If people actually think his posts were that bad, he seems to be the next one to investigate.
pianotm
The TM is for Totally Magical.
32388
Cap_H
Gourd_Clae
When cave flipped scum I was so relieved you would not believe. He was already pegging me as a lurker and being opportunistic even though the game hadn't gone very long at all. I thought if he flipped town then I would be a big target next day for sure. I'm so glad I followed my gut when it told me that he was being disingenuous in response to me. Especially since he has just town read me earlier seemingly arbitrarily ;w;
If anything I wouldn't call CAVE a lurker. He was in the thread and it made his duel way more reliable at first.


He wasn't calling Cave a lurker. He was saying that Cave was calling him a lurker. Cave was actually incessant with his posting.
Also, I missed the piano partner id thing. It's relevant in that if piano was scum, his primary target would be the other detective, so that he could stop the investigations. So he might've wound up hitting the monk by mistake, thinking Cap/Emily was his partner, if they had only posted once or twice or something like that.

Does Jeroen strike anyone else as a weird investigation target? He was #1 on my town list (aside from maybe piano) when the day ended. Curious which detective proposed him.
Agreed investigating Ozzy would be a very good idea.