ESBY'S PROFILE

author=Cap_H
#lynch ESBY

I think you've said enough now. Your either scum or so wrong that you're being completely detrimental to the town.
The repeated insistence on day one that Ozzy refusing to vote for Gourd is alarming sticks out like a sore thumb. Also this;

author=Cap_H
It's six people on Gourd. I suggest someone unvotes, so there's no accidental hammer.

author=Cap_H
Ok, reading Cave's posts again I'm not all that sure. I got too many people, who could be wolves and the most likely pack is something like
Gourd + Ozzy + ESBY. Ozzy refusing voting Gourd is alarming and so is esby ending up voting piano for raisins.

Just so we're clear, your logic was "Don't vote for Gourd we don't want accidents, also Gourd is scum."?
If these three names were your most likely pack, why didn't you vote for any of them?

#lynch Cap_H

author=Muffle
Cave wasn't threatening, they were simply telling you with your arguments and responses it'd be very easy to mislynch you, assuming you could be town because you're coming off as just a little suspicious. Also, if we have no one else to lynch off with good reasoning by the end, we'll probably just take a random vote for people who aren't helping or aren't responding. You should stop assuming things.

Sure, on it's own it doesn't sound like much of a threat. But...

author=CAVE_DOG_IS_BACK
esby needs to be taken out probably.

hmmmmmm

Let me ask you a little question. If I was scum then why would I be drawing this much attention to myself?

author=Muffle
Again, if you and Ozzy had had any type of reasoning for not lynching Gourd you should have said.

The reason to save him was the lack of evidence against him.

author=pianotm
Oh, very well done. If you don't want it to happen again, maybe next time you'll, you know, play the game and make a case as to why you think my scum hunt is wrong, or you know, do something aside from crack jokes and insult people. Just a thought.

I can't make a logical argument against illogical reasoning. For what it's worth I think your hunt was simply misplaced and not malicious.

author=demonlord5000
Esby: Hasn't contributed anything, and what was that random piano vote? I really don't know here but he hasn't been useful. Going to put him down here for now.

Do you mean that vote where if I was scum I could've easily voted out Gourd by going with the common consensus. That vote where I said I wasn't willing to kill Gourd - the same innocent Gourd you in fact voted for. That vote where I voted for the person I thought was acting most aggressively towards Gourd. That vote?

author=CAVE_DOG_IS_BACK
esby needs to be taken out probably. if only we had some kind of...gunner...

If only... If only someone never switched votes last minute without explanation he might still be here.

I don't suppose you have any idea who that was now do you?

realise this is game one turn one for me
i'm still trying to get to grips with what's going on
everything is so erratic and nonsensical