TONFA'S PROFILE

your DRAMATIC Moldovian uncle

Search

Filter

Hunters: The Mafia, Day 3

P.S. YDS, also please form an opinion of some kind.

In fact, this is my problem with this kind of player.

If you are town, you are doing nothing to catch scum.
If you are scum, you are not giving any leads because of your adamant refusal to say anything.

Hunters: The Mafia, Day 3

author=Liberty link=topic=4041.msg82804#msg82804 date=1245951043
As you should have noticed, I have not voted - against you or anyone else. If someone comes up with a sound reason (imo) for voting against someone then I will duly consider a vote, but I don't think any reasons given as yet are sound enough.
Sure, killing someone may help you feel better and may garner more clues, but if they are an innocent we would have to deal with the fact that there is one less player on our side. Remember! Once a lynch is reached then a night phase begins in which we will lose another player! It may not seem like much but losing that extra villager may win or lose us the game. We have to be careful!

That said, if you truly feel that Myersguy is mafia, then by all means vote. However, don't expect me to believe the same and do as anyone else does.

I will vote when I feel that my suspicions are correct.

You are not helping at all. Your "suspicions"? How about you air some of those suspicions. Everything you've said can be summed up as: "Don't lynch!". You say you will place down a vote if there is a solid case but are doing absolutely nothing to contribute to a case against anyone but yourself. Wait and see, let the puppets dance, huh.

Hunters: The Mafia, Day 3

Not voting is not the same as refusing to vote.

I don't have enough time to make a proper analysis until today evening.

Hunters: The Mafia, Day 3

Also, all of you people who refuse to vote for frontrunning cases and go all "well you'll be looking really suspicious if it's a town!" are looking REALLY scummy. Like scum being extraordinarily careful not to participate in a town lynch. Scum know who they are lynching, townies do not.

Hunters: The Mafia, Day 3

author=Liberty link=topic=4041.msg82749#msg82749 date=1245926064
Pushing for a vote is an easy way to look suspicious, just an FYI. Especially to me. Sure, we may lose a person to the night kill but better to lose one to a kill than to lose two for just the sake of voting. The first few days we can afford to wait a little and try to make sure our votes are on the dot instead of random.

This is the absolute worst reasoning. If we don't lynch anyone we learn NOTHING about the voters or the lynchee.

Hunters: The Mafia, Day 3

author=Natook link=topic=4041.msg82624#msg82624 date=1245874926
it doesn't matter to me who gets lynched.

Actually this is even more alarming, is this an outright scumclaim

Hunters: The Mafia, Day 3

author=Natook link=topic=4041.msg82624#msg82624 date=1245874926
Since Autra and Myers both have 4, at this point it doesn't matter to me who gets lynched.

Why so hasty? Deadline isn't even close yet. You're letting yourself get tunnelvisioned into one of two cases, neither of which may be scum.

Hunters: The Mafia, Day 3

## unvote

That's either typical newbie confused town defense or scum pretending as much. I'm paging Occam's Razor here.

Hunters: The Mafia, Day 3

Oh, I misread your vote as for myers. Okay. Warning still stands though.

Hunters: The Mafia, Day 3

WE ARE AT -1 TO A MYERSGUY LYNCH BY MY COUNT.