MILLER'S HOLLOW MAFIA - GAME THREAD

My Phone is screwing with me. Bare with me here.
Keep it short:
Cave you talk a lot, but that's how you are always. Ironic from a guy who denounces roleplaying to basicly hide behind flapping head talk. (see ghost avatar for visual)
Wildwes, I'll hold off on bandwagoning. You were new to Mafia in my game, iirc, so I'll just watch.
So... For now #nolynch

as for Sheriff? Yeah, same reasons, and I assume we can change the election if it doesn't work out??
#Elect Happy

yeah electing happy has no veritable reason

he just popped in lynched and elected himself

Maybe Dudes could be scum... along with Happy?

(yeah i am really rusty)

can't be sure your town, but right now there really aren't any leads, so i'll let myself be naive
(plus i am usually always town, only in my last mafia game was i scum)
Let me see what other have to say before making any further voting~~ i strongly suspect Happy and Dudes atm.

In general, the first player to make wild accusations in these kind of games is a werewolf himself. However, I've never played here before, so I'm not familiar with everyone's usual personas- it could be this accusative behavior is Cave's standard protocol.

Thus, I'm going to take the safe route and put my bets on Trihan's deduction: If Wildwes turns out to be innocent, Cave's almost certainly a werewolf himself. If he really was a werewelf, well, we'll lose Cave on night 1 to the wolves, but we'll have hanged one of them in return.

So either way, it's a 1 for 1 trade, which, since we are in the mayority, is favorable.

#Lynch Wildwes

##unvote

It sure is convenient that your admission of flat-out lying comes after people point out how flimsy the claim was. And don't call us ignoramuses as if you were weaving an elaborate web of wonderful lies and caught us right up in them; you were making a role claim. The only thing you can accomplish by falsely claiming a role and result is confusing the town, which doesn't help us in the slightest.

I wasn't framing the lynch as anything; you said you had scanned wes and he came up scum. Usually the only reason someone claims that is because it's true or because they're scum trying to get rid of a townie. Either way, the optimal thing was to go with your lynch because then we get a piece of information we didn't have before: whether or not you were telling the truth.

"obviously we have to kill cave tomorrow if wildwes is scum!!!" okay, now you're blatantly trying to twist what I said to make it look more suspicious and less insightful. I said I would want to lynch you if wes WASN'T scum. Why would I want to lynch you if he was? You'd be proven to be telling the truth and assuming you didn't die during the night I wouldn't try to lynch you. That said, if that happened and you didn't die during the night you might end up being scum anyway, but that's a less likely outcome.

I have no idea what wes is; like I said before you tried to implicate me, the only reason I voted was to out you. That's happened now, so I remove my vote.

Let's just kill someone.

author=Trihan
##unvoteIt sure is convenient that your admission of flat-out lying comes after people point out how flimsy the claim was. And don't call us ignoramuses as if you were weaving an elaborate web of wonderful lies and caught us right up in them; you were making a role claim. The only thing you can accomplish by falsely claiming a role and result is confusing the town, which doesn't help us in the slightest.

I wasn't framing the lynch as anything; you said you had scanned wes and he came up scum. Usually the only reason someone claims that is because it's true or because they're scum trying to get rid of a townie. Either way, the optimal thing was to go with your lynch because then we get a piece of information we didn't have before: whether or not you were telling the truth.

"obviously we have to kill cave tomorrow if wildwes is scum!!!" okay, now you're blatantly trying to twist what I said to make it look more suspicious and less insightful. I said I would want to lynch you if wes WASN'T scum. Why would I want to lynch you if he was? You'd be proven to be telling the truth and assuming you didn't die during the night I wouldn't try to lynch you. That said, if that happened and you didn't die during the night you might end up being scum anyway, but that's a less likely outcome.

I have no idea what wes is; like I said before you tried to implicate me, the only reason I voted was to out you. That's happened now, so I remove my vote.

nobody ever pointed out anything about my claim being flimsy. the best was zeuzio going "I don't think trihan would put a daycop in this game." that's it. nobody put forth anything of substance as to why it could not be true. I unclaimed because Wildwes was at -2 and I didn't want someone to hammer and end the day early. Also, I fakeclaim day 1 of every game, so that is why you are all ignoramuses. d/w/i

Here is the thing. You said that even if I was a cop who got results erroneously, I should still be lynched as I am not helpful to town. According to that logic, the following people would be lynched afterwards:
*all vanilla town
*nobody else because the game would be over

Pretty scummy to want to suggest lynching people for reasons other than "they are scum!!!"

as to third paragraph, I made a typo. Pretend I said the opposite thing, as that is obviously what I meant.

author=PlatinumAshes
Just pointing out that I meant to say 'if cave really was a daycop' in my previos postIf you weren't sold on his guild, you shouldn't have implied so. What were you trying to accomplish lynching someone who's (lack of) guilt you weren't aware of to begin with? Moreover, don't you think it's suspicious that you're retreating your vote now that you're being helt to your word?

I wasn't trying to lynch him. You can tell because I'm not voting for him. I was always going to be held to my word. As I said above, I'm unvoting because I don't want day 1 to end so quickly and am not 100 percent sold on wildwes.

Also if I hadn't done what I did all of you would have just meandered around doing nothing for four days and then lynched dudesoft.

it's cave's style, he's the reason the game moves on really.

His actions are designed to fuck our brains hard, and then get scrambled and wildly accuse others and destroy ourselves while he maniacally laughs in the background, watching his victory unfold.

#Cancel