MILLER'S HOLLOW MAFIA - GAME THREAD

author=CAVE_DOG_IS_BACK
I have looked at the thread. The statement that I have not is ridiculous in of itself because i modded the goddamned thing. I am dying to hear what your trap was.

Yeah you modded it, but you're still being ridiculous by saying:

author=CAVE_DOG_IS_BACK
Actually trihan strikes me as genuinely annoyed in general. he's probably town. I don't want to kill dudesoft day 1. Consider this my anti-policy lynch. I would probably kill Happy though as he seems to be acting very out of character.

Because at the time when you said that, everything I had posted so far in day one of this game fell exactly to the same strategy as I had in the earlier game. You clearly have not taken a look at my posts there, so how come you're using them as your emphasis?

Also, if you're curious about my "trap," well, I was just looking for people who're fast to jump to conclusions and are suspicious of other people with flimsy evidence. I thought you'd see what I was trying to do with my posts (there was other thing too, which you might realize if you read them some more.)

That's all I'm going to say for now. I was originally planning to lift my lynch vote from you before the day ends, but you're acting really strange, so I'm going to wait and see a bit further.

author=Happy
Because at the time when you said that, everything I had posted so far in day one of this game fell exactly to the same strategy as I had in the earlier game. You clearly have not taken a look at my posts there, so how come you're using them as your emphasis?

Also, if you're curious about my "trap," well, I was just looking for people who're fast to jump to conclusions and are suspicious of other people with flimsy evidence. I thought you'd see what I was trying to do with my posts (there was other thing too, which you might realize if you read them some more.)

That's all I'm going to say for now. I was originally planning to lift my lynch vote from you before the day ends, but you're acting really strange, so I'm going to wait and see a bit further.

nobody in that game had claimed cop on day 1. also, I don't know what else I can say other than that I was literally required to read all the posts in that thread. also, that's not a trap. acting like a huge idiot and voting for a cop claim without a word is legitimately scummy/stupid behaviour, so it's justified when someone calls you out for it. you've 'trapped' me into admitting that i am looking for scum/willing to call out trash. this 'look at my chessmastery' bs is awfully annoying when you actually haven't done anything clever and have proven yourself in the past to be a net loss to the town regardless of alignment.

it's difficult to say, but this game has so many awful lurkers that i'm willing to just policy lynch them all until only people who actually post are alive. besides that, zeuzio is looking bad to me. he's made zero calls of any kind other than putting down a vote on wildwes and then removing it when i unclaimed, quotes a post by PA which said that lurking scum would be a 'tactical decision' (tactically unsound) so that he could say that this was 'a fair point' without actually adding anything. Why. What was the point of saying that.

In general, all of his posts seem to be using too many words to say nothing at all while purposely avoiding taking a side or opinion of anything.

wildwes is a goofball and is going to reveal himself explicitly if he is scum. if we apathy lynch a lurker, we will have a day 2 that is going to look an awful lot like day 1. the best move is to take a gamble with zeuzio. ##lynch zeuzio

if PA = scum
trihan = scum
cavedog != scum
else
cavedog = scum
end

#lynch PlatinumAshes

Better then nolynching, I suppose.

author=Gourd_Clae
But Zeuzio is a lurker, that's a little contradictory to the rest of what you said in that post. Besides, he hasn't sided with anyone save for agreeing with PA. It really wouldn't help gather any new information for day 2.

he's not lurking. he's been posting each day, just not anything of substance. It would help garner information based on who participates in the lynch and why, and also his flip.

Trying to gather information based on a flip's player's day 1 stances is a fool's game because scum are required to lie, not just about their views on their teammates, but about everyone. On the other hand, town players are often mistaken, so taking their viewpoints as gospel is also bad.

PlatinumAshes is a lazy lynch and I've seen zero reasoning as to why we should kill him today.

author=CAVE_DOG_IS_BACK
zeuzio is looking bad to me. he's made zero calls of any kind other than putting down a vote on wildwes and then removing it when i unclaimed, quotes a post by PA which said that lurking scum would be a 'tactical decision' (tactically unsound) so that he could say that this was 'a fair point' without actually adding anything. Why. What was the point of saying that.

In general, all of his posts seem to be using too many words to say nothing at all while purposely avoiding taking a side or opinion of anything.

these are real, actual reasons. ingame reasons to kill zeuzio. the reasoning so far for PA is: He guessed how many people might be on the scumteam.

author=CAVE_DOG_IS_BACK
estimating how many people are on the scumteam is not a scumtell, sorry. Why did you ignore everything else that has happened in lieu of making this vote, when most of the players have thought, at some point, about how many people might be on the scumteam.

author=CAVE_DOG_IS_BACK
estimating how many people are on the scumteam is not a scumtell, sorry. Why did you ignore everything else that has happened in lieu of making this vote, when most of the players have thought, at some point, about how many people might be on the scumteam.

Please point out where I said that was my only reason for voting for PA.

Yes, circumstances have changed since then wrt knowledge of random electing, and it may be the case that PA genuinely was trying to be helpful, but I'm not sure whether this pseudo analysis really points to anything useful, or if its just a neat way of seeming of value to the team without actually providing any new leads lest they allow PA to screw up.

I'm gonna have a look through PAs posts in this thread to see if anything was mentioned about possible Werewolves. If nothing pops up my vote stays.

I am a goofball.

If I may ask, why are you voting to lynch me again, CAVE?

... I feel like I should add more to this post, but I don't really have anything else to say. Oh well.

author=CAVE_DOG_IS_BACK
nobody in that game had claimed cop on day 1. also, I don't know what else I can say other than that I was literally required to read all the posts in that thread.

So now I'm supposed to have believed you were a cop? Also, you still seem to be entirely missing my play here. You just said how my act appears.

Now when it comes to night, who do you suppose the werewolves will kill first Cave?