PHOENIX MAFIA: ONLINE TURNABOUT

also im about to head to bed and NOW you guys get active? really?

I think you should eat it. I have reasons;

1.(this is somewhat selfish) I think we have enough mysteries in this game, and this one seems simple to solve.
2. The only thing I can think of(going off of the OP) is that if it is scum, maybe it is a conversion cookie? I mean in real life someone has to make a conscious choice to turn their back on people and join a new game, it could work that way in the game. However, a problem with this theory is I figure you would know if it would convert you or not if that was its purpose.
3. I looked through the Op in the citizen area and this is a stretch, just like reason 2, but maybe it is part of the programmer? Maybe it is the boost? Once again you would probably know if it did that.
3. This isn't a reason, just an idea. If you don't want to eat it, maybe you should wait until the night phase and see if you can gift it to someone else and maybe they'll take the chance and eat it.
(I haven't used a gif in a while, can't let Piano and Puddor have all of the fun.)

Wait, it's safe? Was it from you Piano?

Yeah, it was from me. I had just lost my detective to a night kill, and I was looking for any angle I could find. Isrieri gave me a cookie; I gave it to the experienced player I was least suspicious of.

author=Ratty524
Was the cookie a snickerdoodle?

If not, then it doesn't prove shit.

It's interesting to see who came out of the woodwork for this. MK, and Ratty, both of whom have been accused by different experienced players of being scum, trying to denounce another player. Shifting suspicion onto another player is a known scum move.

I don't really think I've been flat out accused yet, and I flat out said I thought she was town. ._.

Well, I guess my reasons and idea are useless, ah well. That was a good idea Piano!

Oh, well if it's from you, piano, I've no issues eating it! Thank you for the meal!

#eat cookie

I'm baaaack

I'm interested in what evidence Puddor has against me. But I'm guessing she's still asleep so I guess I'll just wait. Anyone else think I feel "off" or is it just the attorneys? And also, how do I feel "off", exactly?

This whole cookie thing's a little strange. Why'd Isri give one of the attorney's a cookie? Is it chocolate chip? And what's it do? I suppose the answer to that last question gonna be answered soon, since Libby just ate it. I wasn't sure what to think of Liberty before but I have to agree with some others peeps here that her reaction to having the cookie makes her feel a bit more town to me.

OK, I changed my mind. Putting the cookie consumption up to vote was actually a genius move if she was town. If it killed her, we would have a list of who voted for her death. If she were scum and were worried about it being a "gift" from the vigilante, there would be no particular reason to do that - it would be much more useful for scum to just ask who it was from, effectively forcing a roleclaim out of the town.

I'm no longer in favor of lynching her.

#cancel