New account registration is temporarily disabled.

[PLAY TIME] BULLET BALLOT MAFIA

Posts

For some reason newbies tend to also be mafia for literally no reason. It happens A LOT. Obviously I would draw no conclusions from that, but that has been my experience.

It's day 1, so unfortunately we don't have much info to base any votes on. A lot of the time, there's a big debate about the ethics of voting day 1 just so that newbies know.
author=Liberty
Yeah, sorry fearful, but for that edit your ballot is rendered null and void for tonight's ballot count (tomorrow's will still work, as long as you don't break any of the other rules. Refer to this post for more rules that you might have missed: http://rpgmaker.net/forums/topics/20624/?post=726784#post726784 ).

I know there's a good amount of new people in the thread, which is why I've got a lessened punishment for rule breaking first, but keep in mind that the rules are there for reasons.

The edit rule exists because mafia is a game where what people say really counts against them. Ideally you will be quoting each other, digging up inconsistencies in arguments and referring back to older posts. If people can edit their posts then you can't trust that what was quoted is really what was said - otherwise people would go back and edit out little slip ups. Half the fun is digging out inconsistencies and using them to undermine each others' arguments in order to either find the truth or obscure it, depending on which team you are on. This is the main reason why talking really helps town out - by talking people get a feel for each other and can refer back to past posts in order to see who is lying, who is acting weird or who is being detrimental to the team.

Sometimes it is not as simple as 'this person is acting scummy' (the term scum refers to anyone who would be against town - it's a catch-all name for all non-town people, not meant as an insult). Sometimes a person might be lynched because they're obscuring the issue or causing trouble for town, even if they are town (basically, the reason Kloe was killed in the RP game was because she was more of a hindrance to town than a help).

So you need to try and talk, but also keep your cards to your chest a bit, but also weed out the mafia, but also try not to incriminate yourselves whilst serving your interests as best as you can.

Good luck~ :DDD


The only person allowed to edit their posts in this thread is me. ;p

Quoted so people actually see this since it was page sniped. >.>
pianotm
The TM is for Totally Magical.
32388
Gourd_Clae
For some reason newbies tend to also be mafia for literally no reason. It happens A LOT. Obviously I would draw no conclusions from that, but that has been my experience.

It's day 1, so unfortunately we don't have much info to base any votes on. A lot of the time, there's a big debate about the ethics of voting day 1 just so that newbies know.


Also, there's a lot of newbies in this game. Three confirmed newbies, and I think oddRabbit and Kloe might be newbies, too. So five, probably.
That was sure why I hung Kloe that game.

Hey, Kloe, don't give me reason to hang you a second time. Hanging the same kid two times in one month is tiring...
pianotm
The TM is for Totally Magical.
32388
What? Wait a minute!
@Libby Oops, sorry I would've quoted you but I didn't realize it would start a new page. My bad~
pianotm
The TM is for Totally Magical.
32388
Okay, so MakioKuta says:

MakioKuta
Yeah, I guess I'm just not clear on what we should be talking about. As Crystal-Mint said, the only other game I played close to this was a HEAVY RP one that played more like a murder mystery with a DM. xD

But I joined this to learn. So learn I will try to do.


And then says:

MakioKuta
That was sure why I hung Kloe that game.

Hey, Kloe, don't give me reason to hang you a second time. Hanging the same kid two times in one month is tiring...


I think I've figured out who I just might cast my ballot for. By all means, MakioKuta. Give us some context.
Is the rp game not the same game Kloe was hanged in?
Kloe was in the RP-based Werewolf Game with Crystal-Mint and I. She was playing a liar, and the village hung her for it.
pianotm
The TM is for Totally Magical.
32388
Thank you, Gourdy. Does that mean Makio was the killer in that game? If this is the case, I apologize for jumping the gun.

Let this be a lesson, Makio; be very careful what you say in Mafia.
Yeah, inconsistencies tend to get picked up on - liars die~

Luckily there's always room for discussion. Theoretically, if you're innocent, town can talk it out!
That said, how does everyone feel about voting on day 1? There are a lot of people here who are a big ? to me in terms of whether or not they are willing to vote day 1.
author=Liberty
- You all send in one ballot each. If a ballot is missing by end time that person is eliminated in place of the one who was to be lynched that day.


Don't you die if you don't vote?
pianotm
The TM is for Totally Magical.
32388
I honestly don't know. This not being able to lynch in the comments thing really has everybody quiet. It's hard to get a read on everyone. A random vote will probably end up with a nolynch.
pianotm
The TM is for Totally Magical.
32388
Hmm...well settles that. Gourdy, we're all going to vote, I think.
Or were you trying to pull a fast one of the noobs? xD
i felt very confident in my null and void ballet.
the idea is you read the rules before posting?
or did i break the rules after i read.
nope appears i broke the rules before reading phew.
FUCKok i better learn this really fast. i just developed this strange habit to edit every post i make almost.
Obviously I was trying to trick people~~~

(I may have forgotten... I guess a better question was how should we decide the first person to lynch?)