[FINISHED] KLOE THE MURDERER MAFIA

author=pianotm
But you don't seem to realize that Kloe meta'd twice on Shinan. Not once, TWICE.

Are you counting the fact that she ate RabitZ after Shinan made several cannibalism jokes? I wouldn't call that "meta", that was a very intentional part of the roleplaying.

If it were me running the game, I'd say that it's more likely to be a real clue if Kloe thinks the town is at a disadvantage, and more likely to be a red herring if Kloe thinks the scum are at a disadvantage. Since the modkill shifted the balance of power slightly towards scum, that would imply it's slightly more likely to be real than fake. But Kloe might use a completely different decision-making process to decide whether to give real clues or fake clues. For example, she might give out red herrings early and real answers later in the story, like a TV drama would.

And another good point from LockeZ. He's making sense again.

Y-you said ratty two times. XD Yeah, shinan will most likely be lynched either way.

I so want to lynch pianotm. But he's also sort of super obvious. The current votes are very much against me, meaning that the scum is happy with how it stands and wouldn't want to throw blame around because that will put them in the crosshairs.

The problem is of course as pianotm says:

So what are you going to say when I flip town?

IF I flip town, what would that mean? (Also IF I flip scum, what would that mean?)

The thing is that currently I feel that maybe the scum is happy that when I flip town all suspicion is going to be on you. Of course that suspicion is also super-obvious so it might be doubleplay.

Also who cares about a bit of serial killing. Except if you mean that your role is serial killer, which I believe is a non-mafia night kill role?

Nope. It means I'm quoting CAVE_DOG and I might even have begun to understand why he always it regularly.

It doesn't matter who you lynch. There's no way to know until you've lynched them. So, in mafia, just kill everyone until you get scum.

You want to know what else doesn't matter? It doesn't matter how you act. Because I can act batshit crazy right now, and all the votes are still on you. Isn't that hilarious? But that's just how this game is. Cave_Dog did it every, single, fucking game! He acted like a deranged lunatic, everyone thought he was scum, and he rarely got lynched. Even better, the lynching always followed his bandwagons!

Bandwagons are the real power in this game. It isn't scum-hunting. Human's are too stupid to scum-hunt when they get together like this. We're not capable of it. It is our greatest mental deficiency. In groups hunting an unknown enemy with no evidence to help us, we become blithering idiots, tying string after string of nonsense together and pretending it's logic. For all of our "logic" we are never, ever right!

And you know what, I'm really beginning to believe that you might actually be town, and it doesn't matter. If you're not scum, I can't think of anyone else scum could possibly be except maybe LockeZ, and I don't think he's scum either.

Everyone's playing a godly mafia!

So, either you are scum, or you're not. It doesn't matter. There's no way to know until the moderator puts the rubber stamp on our dead carcasses.

So...I choose you! Shinan!

Okay piano that took a bit of a weird turn after I tried to imply your innocence.

Also, I may have a little bit of whiskey in me.