[MAFIA] RMN: WHEN THEY CRY (TEA PARTY)

Not trying to get your sympathy. If I still had a way to defend myself, trust me I'd use it. But I've said everything I can and it seems I'm going to get lynched either way. I'm giving you an easier way to get me out of the way if you truly disbelieve my claim. So come on, just two more if you really think I'm Mafia. I give up, I can't do anything else to back myself up. It's all up to you.

I do think YM is scum, I've said this before. I've said most of what I have to say about the others, so still not much I can say. YM had little reason to shoot me last night so I'd like to hear what they have to say about it.

Please stop trying to make me say stuff I've already said when you can go back and look at it. I've said everything I have to say. Instead of making me repeat myself and waste my time go back, read everything, and fully decide if you believe my claim or not.

I've defended myself and did scumhunting at the beginning of the day. I will admit scumhunting isn't my best ability, but I've done what I'm capable of. So, you know. It seems only Cap sees my reasonings for what they really are.

I can't be sure whether there is more than one scum left. I am definitely sure that YM is scum. But if there is 2 scum left, and you out me, well not much you can do tomorrow.

Cap would be my second pick for scum, however, he's changed my opinion the last two days. So I'm leaning on one more scum. But I think three scum in the entire game would be quite likely.

Final full read:

YM I believe is scum. Why did you try to shoot me last night, YM? Until today I don't think there was much reason to shoot me. You've always seemed suspicious of me with lack of reason, but this doesn't help your case. I think last gunner would definitely be Mafia.

I'm sure that Sol & demonlord are towns, I've gotten that read for a while.

I'm indifferent about Cap. If there are two scum, I'd definitely think it is him. Otherwise, I think it's just YM being the last scummyscum.

author=Jeroen_Sol
Cap, I figured you would claim third protector. You did telegraph this when you said a third protector role would make sense. However, that was after everyone else had already roleclaimed, so it'd be an easy fakeclaim. Did you telegraph this in any of your earlier posts, perhaps?

Not really, I only suggested that protectors should protect demonlord on d2.
Frankly, I see this reaction more often from frustrated new players than scum.

author=Muffle
Please stop trying to make me say stuff I've already said when you can go back and look at it. I've said everything I have to say. Instead of making me repeat myself and waste my time go back, read everything, and fully decide if you believe my claim or not.

I asked whether your opinion had changed now that YM has told us he attacked you. That's not something you'd told us yet. But thank you for your final reads. If you're town, that'll be helpful.

I definitely think last gunman could very well be scum. If you're town, YM will be at the top of my list. However, if there were two scum left, and you were town, the game would be over by now, so I don't think that's the case.

author=Cap_H
Hey, I'm not doing that anymore because it got me killed few times. Also, breadcrumbing is sometimes taken as a tactic scum uses. But I guess that some of my reactions could suggest it. I was staying low when there was a discussion about pms and roles. I was fast to put Demonlord in my townreads after he claimed.

Hmmm fair enough. And that's true, CAVE_DOG breadcrumbed when I was Mafia with him one time.

I'll give it two/three minutes before I vote for Muffle. Muffle, if you want to remove the vote on yourself, you better do it soon...it'll be hammer once I vote.

Wait, Sol, we're at five players right? So it's possible for there to be two scum. If you lynch me that'll make two towns two mafias, meaning mafia wins because it's equal or less too. I'm hoping this isn't the case.

Btw, I would lynch YM over Muffle. Given the situation I think there's one wolf left. Wolf gunner would make sense to me, but it's still a better claim than her.
I'm quite sure the two aren't aligned.

But there's so much about muffle, what makes her a more logical lynch.
On the other hand, Muffle's role is hard to prove (nobody would target her after the claim) and it's not so far from Ozzy's claim. Given the claim, her is worse.
But I have reasons to townread her like this breakdown and overthinking the game previously. But that's my feeling and not an objective fact. Both of these things could be considered wolfy.
So, I'm going with Jero, who is a proven town
#lynch Muffle

Yes, there could be two scum. But if that were the case, and you were also town, the two scum would be YM and Cap. Who are online right now and could have quickhammered you to immediately end the game in their favour. That's why I don't think it's the case.