Full Games List
Featured Games
New Games
Reviews
Media
Images
Blogs
Game Updates
Images Feedback Summary
Game Design Highlights
Tutorials
Articles
Scripts
Utilities / Plugins
Resources
Engines
Engine Bulletins
What is Makerscore?
Past Events
Achievements
Misaos
Forums
Post History
Chat
New to RMN?
Full Store List
RMN Music Pack (free)
[MAFIA] PRISONER'S DILEMMA. GAME OVER
Posts
AlaskanEmily
561
AlaskanEmily
View playlists
CloseYeah, if we have masons, a vigilante, and (probably?) a bodyguard, then it seems like we must be in a good position role-wise.
I'm still onboard with a PA or a Piano lynch. I'm no longer absolutely certain Piano is scum, but I'm still really leaning scum.
#lynch Piano
I'm still onboard with a PA or a Piano lynch. I'm no longer absolutely certain Piano is scum, but I'm still really leaning scum.
#lynch Piano
ivoryjones
75
There's a small possibility of a role that first is town but becomes scum when successfully "recruited" by scum. That's also why I still don't trust you, PA, since a lot of people who have that role tend to act "volatile" like you so they could grab scum's attention.
There's also the possibility of a scum role-blocker or a 1-shot-bulletproof lynch just to balance out the game on their side. Latter one would make sense if PA, piano or tale didn't mind getting lynched so they can have 1 more night to kill.
There's also the possibility of a scum role-blocker or a 1-shot-bulletproof lynch just to balance out the game on their side. Latter one would make sense if PA, piano or tale didn't mind getting lynched so they can have 1 more night to kill.
PlatinumAshes
I am now certain that you are not scum and are just town trying to play scum as hard as possible.
0
Mods are asleep.
Post copypastas.
Post copypastas.
Fomar0153
16396
Suspence! Last time I was away when everyone piled on Psy, didn't have this wait to find out if they were scum.
END OF DAY VOTECOUNT
pianotm (6):PlatinumAshes, Ozzy, fomar, PlatinumAshes, Ozzy, ivoryjones, demonlord, AlaskanEmily, fomar
AlaskanEmily (1): Shinan,pianotm
Fomar (0):ivoryjones, pianotm, ivoryjones
Tale (1): Tale
PlatinumAshes (0):pianotm, Ozzy, ivoryjones, PlatinumAshes, Ozzy
Oddrabbit (0):ivoryjones
Not Voting: oddrabbit, pianotm, kittenfood,
Pianotm was executed Day 2. He was vanilla town
pianotm (6):
AlaskanEmily (1): Shinan,
Fomar (0):
Tale (1): Tale
PlatinumAshes (0):
Oddrabbit (0):
Not Voting: oddrabbit, pianotm, kittenfood,
Pianotm was executed Day 2. He was vanilla town
Shinan was kill night 2. He was vanilla town.
Day 3 begins. Deadline is uhhhh Sunday evening since I know everyone here's a party animal who's gonna be bumpin and grindin Saturday night.
With 9 alive, it takes 5 votes to execute.
Day 3 begins. Deadline is uhhhh Sunday evening since I know everyone here's a party animal who's gonna be bumpin and grindin Saturday night.
With 9 alive, it takes 5 votes to execute.
demonlord5000
680
Sorry piano!
Here's where I'm confused right now. Why was our least useful town member killed when we have confirmed town in the game.
I guess you could argue that scum is trying to make us second guess emily since that was shinans vote...but why? Why go this route with confirmed town in the game.
Going to see what everyone else says before deciding if we stick to the original lynch PA plan or not. Scums poor choice of targets basically gave us an extra free day to make mistakes.
Here's where I'm confused right now. Why was our least useful town member killed when we have confirmed town in the game.
I guess you could argue that scum is trying to make us second guess emily since that was shinans vote...but why? Why go this route with confirmed town in the game.
Going to see what everyone else says before deciding if we stick to the original lynch PA plan or not. Scums poor choice of targets basically gave us an extra free day to make mistakes.
Yep, scum knows exactly what they are doing. They killed Shinan so that we would focus on Emily.
OR
Emily is scum and did the most obvious possible play to get us off her track.
I'm still in line with the PA vote as well, but I would like more input. Doesn't help that Shinan's interactions were so few to begin with, that it's hard to see anyone except Emily right now, which leads me to believe this is a trap from scum to set us on Emily.
OR
Emily is scum and did the most obvious possible play to get us off her track.
I'm still in line with the PA vote as well, but I would like more input. Doesn't help that Shinan's interactions were so few to begin with, that it's hard to see anyone except Emily right now, which leads me to believe this is a trap from scum to set us on Emily.
demonlord5000
680
Alright, cya in a bit ozzy. I still don't understand this play though. They essentially ignored three confirmed town (you, ivory, kitten) in favor of some weird move. Going back to the ivory list, that leaves us at PA, tale, fomar, emily, odd, and myself.
PA: Nothing has really changed here.
Tale - Piano said he had strong reasons for believing tale, and since he flipped town I'm willing to believe it.
Fomar: He's playing well enough. Feels more town to me than other options.
Emily: Either scum just made the most obvious play possible, or she's town. She feels town to me, and I think I'm more willing to believe that scum is trying to make her a target. It doesn't feel like a veteran move though because it leaves confirmed town in the game. Could also be PA making a weird move to cause that exact line of reasoning as well though.
Odd: Speak up man. I could see odd being scum this game because we haven't been hearing much from him.
PA: Nothing has really changed here.
Tale - Piano said he had strong reasons for believing tale, and since he flipped town I'm willing to believe it.
Fomar: He's playing well enough. Feels more town to me than other options.
Emily: Either scum just made the most obvious play possible, or she's town. She feels town to me, and I think I'm more willing to believe that scum is trying to make her a target. It doesn't feel like a veteran move though because it leaves confirmed town in the game. Could also be PA making a weird move to cause that exact line of reasoning as well though.
Odd: Speak up man. I could see odd being scum this game because we haven't been hearing much from him.
Fomar0153
16396
Sorry Piano :(
Can't say I'll miss Shinan's input but bizzare choice, we would have lynched him sooner or later anyway. Like everyone else already said it does raise suspicion on Emily but is it just a trick?
As for going straight for PlatinumAshes, I'm happy to lynch if we don't come up with any better scum candidates but I regret rushing into lynching Piano now. I just wonder whether if PA was scum whether or not he would have pushed so hard for Piano, going as far to say we should lynch him if Piano flipped town. Or is it just a high risk strategy?
I'm tired and not sure what to think, good night.
Can't say I'll miss Shinan's input but bizzare choice, we would have lynched him sooner or later anyway. Like everyone else already said it does raise suspicion on Emily but is it just a trick?
As for going straight for PlatinumAshes, I'm happy to lynch if we don't come up with any better scum candidates but I regret rushing into lynching Piano now. I just wonder whether if PA was scum whether or not he would have pushed so hard for Piano, going as far to say we should lynch him if Piano flipped town. Or is it just a high risk strategy?
I'm tired and not sure what to think, good night.
Fomar0153
16396
Ninjas!
When Piano said about Tale being town I went and re-read Tale's posts, he asked about the possibility of a godfather, which as far as I understand would only matter to a detective. I didn't say yesterday and I assume Piano didn't as it could have revealed a possible power role but since everyone else has had x shots e.g. Psy's 2 shot role cop. It's hopefully safer to mention now and if I noticed I'm sure virtually everyone else did.
When Piano said about Tale being town I went and re-read Tale's posts, he asked about the possibility of a godfather, which as far as I understand would only matter to a detective. I didn't say yesterday and I assume Piano didn't as it could have revealed a possible power role but since everyone else has had x shots e.g. Psy's 2 shot role cop. It's hopefully safer to mention now and if I noticed I'm sure virtually everyone else did.
demonlord5000
680
Also worth noting; I've claimed vanilla, formar claimed vanilla, and we've had two vanilla flips. That puts us at 4 vanilla when ivory was considering the likelyhood of 4-5 vanilla.
Also hmm I see. There is no guarantee he is a detective but that is worth considering. In most cases I don't think it'd matter if someone brought it up for discussion, but it is a bit weird for him as a new player to wonder about that. I have trouble making out many of his posts so I think I didn't fully take that in when he mentioned it.
Also hmm I see. There is no guarantee he is a detective but that is worth considering. In most cases I don't think it'd matter if someone brought it up for discussion, but it is a bit weird for him as a new player to wonder about that. I have trouble making out many of his posts so I think I didn't fully take that in when he mentioned it.
