[MAFIA] PRISONER'S DILEMMA. GAME OVER

Pretty sure this is emily's second game ever, at least on this site. That's one of the reasons I can believe emily made a bad call if she is scum. I also noticed that she avoided some accusations, while becoming incredibly defensive in this day phase. There's also the things I posted last night that I observed with her votes.

Ozzy has leveled up! Gained ability: Ninja the ninjs.

I'm going to have to strengthen my ways of the ninja.

well to me, PA just seemed like he was trying to make a big play but came off weirdly so he just stopped because we weren't into it.

and obviously we promised piano we'd get him but it's like, he kinda helped ivory stop that first lynch on shinan after it almost went through and was definitely all about getting psy lynched, a powerful maf role. i've seen worse and crazier fakeclaiming and he stopped and outted properly when he needed to. it looks like he just plays recklessly when not a PR, which can be useful if it gets mafia to kill you instead of one.

I agree that it's emily. I canceled my vote of consideration to hear others have to say.

Emily, what sort discussion were you expecting before lynch happened in D2? Do you think you could answer my suspicions at the time if I'm ready?

D2 was a wreck to town as D1 to scum. I can a place vote- to participate in a discussion I might as well explain why I voted.

In case, anyone's wondering "why shinan", I think it's most likely because I've put a post re: lib's "reads" on everyone before - The only 3 who I've mentioned was psy, emily and tale. Primarily, tale; next were the former 2 but I've accidentally left another player - fomar. I know 99% of lib's post of that time were basically "___ needs to post more!!" which makes her "list" incredibly useless but the other 3 definitely stood out, yet fomar's one was so subtle that I've completely ignored it. It was just a simple "He needs to post more...", but, I mean, ellipses are super suspicious, right?

Previously after process of elimination from lib's and psy's lynches, I've concluded that no way in hell shinan would be scum considering he was a very easy target that no one cared to leave alive D1. I basically said he was 99% town due to that.

Me, ozzy and kitten being confirmed town, along with shinan, lessened the list of scum considerably. Given that ozzy "claimed" to be 1-shot "vig" first, there was no way that scum would be certain that kitten was too, since ozzy claimed first, so she could always lie about being 1-shot. And also later on I came out and revealed that I was in fact the vig. If scum was being extremely careful, it would make sense why they were hesitant to kill either of us 3. Psy mentioned he was "2-shot" so it wouldn't be weird for scum to assume that either one of us were lying too. (Also, in case anyone's wondering, psy's death flavor never mentioned how many "shots" he's got so he may or may not have had unlimited shots.

Also, unless anyone's got any funny idea, it's just a lynch I'm putting out here.

Yup.

Not an invitation to hammer. Yup.

What if the 3 scums really don't know who each other are in D1? If that's true, how can Liberty's list be reliable? Would Liberty really sold Psy out like that?

ivory, oddrabbit = confirmed town

I'm just reminding about ivory about you if she didn't catch with recent posts.

author=tale
Emily, what sort discussion were you expecting before lynch happened in D2?

Usually I would want to wait because more information and more interaction usually benefits town. I would want to have heard more from Piano, even though I thought he was scum, because when he flipped town I could trust his suspicions were at least made in good faith.

I'm aware that doesn't sound great for me since most of what he got to say was about why he thought I was scum. Although he did cancel his vote on me, so...I guess make of that what you will.

author=tale
Do you think you could answer my suspicions at the time if I'm ready?

I'm sorry I don't understand, what do you mean?