HAPPY'S PROFILE
I'm a very big fan of music of japanese role playing games for it has influenced me throughout my life since my early childhood. The day I saw Nobuo on the stage in front of me I decided I too will become a composer one day. It has been 9 years since that day.
You can't find my works anywhere right now, but that will change very soon this year as I will be contributing several original tracks for RMN Music Pack 2.
You can't find my works anywhere right now, but that will change very soon this year as I will be contributing several original tracks for RMN Music Pack 2.
Search
Filter
CYOR: Breath of Mafia Game Thread
author=Gourd_Clae
@Happy I didn't mean aggressive as in "nitpick things that could easily be explained another way".
You certainly are playing aggressively,and I didn't mean to say that there was no way your interpretations of his posts were incorrect - it's possible I just don't understand why you'd pick that as a reason to suspect him. Especially when his posts have seemed generally innocent.
I'm sorry, I couldn't understand this post. If you mean to ask why of all people I picked Isrieri of all people in the beginning: well, I think I already mentioned that before. Do you want quotes? You could just open Page 11.
I picked a person whose posts seemed most suspicious to me so far, and so far the discussion hadn't really advanced much, so I can see why you'd deem my starting points flimsy.
Also I'm still not sure what this means:
author=Gourd_Clae
"nitpick things that could easily be explained another way"
But if you mean that I pick things that could have multiple explanations for them, well, things usually do tend to have multiple possible causes. This is why you suspect something instead of straight out knowing it...
CYOR: Breath of Mafia Game Thread
author=Isrieri
You're pretty gung-ho on me, as well as Liberty a few pages ago. But now that I've voted Liberty, you felt the need to look at both sides. I'm not saying you're mafia, but I am saying this strikes my funnybone. Where's the need to mention any of this?
I raised suspicions towards Liberty as I caught her from that lie, but I think we pretty much discussed the topic over as thoroughly as possible, and there were no new perspectives, so I only posted my conclusion, which this point couldn't be more than indecisive. No use beating a dead horse.
author=Isrieri
Even now I don't quite understand your case against me. Because I've been acting in a mafia-like behavior I guess. I don't see me doing things that much differently from you though, save that I've been less vocal about it. I'm guessing its because of my earlier posts being "throwing out names" rather than discussing things? What was I going to discuss though? No one really wanted to discuss anything. I maintain I was trying to get things heated up.
There's plenty of folks around here who're acting way more fishy than I've been. So why the special attention on me and apparently PA (who I've got no connection with) when we've both been acting pretty town I think. I can think of a few reasons but I want to hear what yours are.
So what's up? Why am I still on your scum list? I have a good reason for asking this.
There's plenty more folk acting more fishy? Who're these folk? The reason why you're still on my scum list is because I haven't got anything out of you that would give me a reason to think otherwise, yet.
And why actually do you feel the need to change topic to you again?
CYOR: Breath of Mafia Game Thread
CYOR: Breath of Mafia Game Thread
I think it's really hard to tell Liberty's alignment at this point as there seems to be as much good points for her being a scum as being a townie.
Whether she made a mistake when calling herself a vanilla, or if it was intentional lie can't really be determined, and if it was a lie, I can't really tell if it was for hiding a scum or town power.
Though, I if it really was an intentional lie, which copying the phrase of Katt's role from her previous post nods towards to, I find it more likely that she's hiding a scum power than a town power, because if she's a townie, she really got herself some unwanted attention in general.
But then again, her behavior is hard to interpret. Sure, she is very disappointed, but she could also be disappointed at the fact she's caught in the shitstorm because of the mistakes in her play so far.
Whether she made a mistake when calling herself a vanilla, or if it was intentional lie can't really be determined, and if it was a lie, I can't really tell if it was for hiding a scum or town power.
Though, I if it really was an intentional lie, which copying the phrase of Katt's role from her previous post nods towards to, I find it more likely that she's hiding a scum power than a town power, because if she's a townie, she really got herself some unwanted attention in general.
But then again, her behavior is hard to interpret. Sure, she is very disappointed, but she could also be disappointed at the fact she's caught in the shitstorm because of the mistakes in her play so far.
CYOR: Breath of Mafia Game Thread
So you did not think about:
Liberty: Hey I'm vanilla! -> someone checks Liberty: She's not! -> Liberty: derp
Liberty: Hey I'm vanilla! -> someone checks Liberty: She's not! -> Liberty: derp
CYOR: Breath of Mafia Game Thread
Well, if you understand that your power could be only a false lead, it's a power that work against town.
Why didn't you reveal this?
Why didn't you reveal this?
CYOR: Breath of Mafia Game Thread
CYOR: Breath of Mafia Game Thread
My point being: If Liberty thought she had "an useless power", why'd she bother hiding it. (Especially if it can work against her.)
CYOR: Breath of Mafia Game Thread
Sorry Marrend, I must've misread your post.
Also, Liberty was initially hiding her power, claiming she was a vanilla town, HOWEVER yet she had a power, one which she claims that doesn't reveal her identity to a watcher.
Now, if a town watcher checks Liberty and it turns out she can't be read, wouldn't this appear suspicious to the watcher? In such case, wouldn't Liberty want to reveal her power from the get go, so that we don't become suspicious when she accused later on?
But if Liberty was initially hiding her power (of unable of being watched), until I called her out for claiming she was vanilla, wouldn't it mean she considers it usable in some scenario? Yet she said it's useless.
Also, if we can't confirm her role with a watcher, there's really no telling her alignment via night actions.
I just don't see why as a town player she'd want to hide that power from us, in case it can only do her harm. Though, mafia may have a watcher as well, but what good would Liberty's power do against them?
Also, Liberty was initially hiding her power, claiming she was a vanilla town, HOWEVER yet she had a power, one which she claims that doesn't reveal her identity to a watcher.
Now, if a town watcher checks Liberty and it turns out she can't be read, wouldn't this appear suspicious to the watcher? In such case, wouldn't Liberty want to reveal her power from the get go, so that we don't become suspicious when she accused later on?
But if Liberty was initially hiding her power (of unable of being watched), until I called her out for claiming she was vanilla, wouldn't it mean she considers it usable in some scenario? Yet she said it's useless.
Also, if we can't confirm her role with a watcher, there's really no telling her alignment via night actions.
I just don't see why as a town player she'd want to hide that power from us, in case it can only do her harm. Though, mafia may have a watcher as well, but what good would Liberty's power do against them?














