OLDPAT'S PROFILE

OldPat
OrudoPatto, kisama!
5017
Hi, I'm OldPat, an italian indie game developer. I'm trying to improve as much as I can, hoping to reach a professional level one day.
I also like to draw a lot and that's another of the fields I'm trying to improve. My English is still a bit bad, so I hope you'll forgive me if I make any mistakes.^^'
Karma Flow - The Prototy...
A Short 2D Noir Open-Stealth game. "Florien Kealborn is ready to do anything for her own family, even challenge Karma itself."

Search

Filter

RPGmaker Mafia for Normal People GAME OVER [MAFIA]

I gave him the benefit of the doubt about the cop claim,which I just took for granted it only had a town version. Hence why for me he's fine, for now.

author=Cap_H
author=OldPat
Fomar is fine, for now. Emily partecipated enough recently, imo. For now, nothing that tickles me about her.
This mention smells of you trying to get over your partner as quickly as possible. What makes you think that Emily participated enough?

author=OldPat
I don't have much to say about LP, for now. She's behaving the same as the last game.

Hm, I can't really say. I would have to take a look. What makes you say that?


Emily is partecipating slightly more than in her last game and she's throwing some suppositions here and there (Believing Tale, saying that Demon doesn't feel great to her...). I can't see anything that's suspicious about her, for now, so I can't read her as scum. If I have to read her as scum for her low partecipation, then I would have to go after LP too.

About LP:
What makes you say that?


She's behaving exactly the same as in she doesn't pop up often but she tries to partecipate somehow, someway. I am aware of her poor scheduling and her inexperience from the last game (I've already talked about this), especially coupled with the fact that she also had trouble DMing me in private topic when we were partners (I do have to remind you, I was in the same private chat as her in our last game). So I'm not reading her as scum just yet. I know this comes from just *one* game with her, but it's something to go by.



RPGmaker Mafia for Normal People GAME OVER [MAFIA]

author=Fomar0153
author=OldPat
Still reading on Fomar, Emily and Tale.

Tale looks kinda "lost" to me because he's a newbie too (right?)
Difficult for me to do a reading on him, for now.
Tale is newish, I think he's played one or two fewer games than me. I think it's language more than anything.


Ah okay. Newish is close enough

RPGmaker Mafia for Normal People GAME OVER [MAFIA]

I would say this could change, but I don't think I'll be around much by the time day one ends

RPGmaker Mafia for Normal People GAME OVER [MAFIA]

After reading through, my final thoughts are as following:

tale is still new and he's still trying to partecipate and evaluate the situation. While I still can't get a full read on him, he didn't tickle my scum detector.

Fomar is fine, for now. Emily partecipated enough recently, imo. For now, nothing that tickles me about her.

I stand by my early reasonings, both Psy and Cap read town for now for the reasons I've explained before. Psy tries to evaluate the situation as much as Cap, who also looks like quite the aggressive townie.

I don't have much to say about LP, for now. She's behaving the same as the last game.

Jero and Demon are still on my possible lynch list. I didn't quite read them as town, yet, and the reasons why I got suspicious of them still remain.

But Odd probably takes the cake. His way of playing the game is annoying, the puzzle thing is off topic and a potential derail. He says he explained who he thinks is scum and yet he's still going by a joke lynch (maybe he wants to jump on a bandwagon himself later on?)

I've defended him in our last game, but in that game he only "stayed on the side". This time he's actually, actively, trying to derail attention away somehow.

And yes, those two posts I picked up still look suspicious to me.

I'll go for it.
#cancel
#lynch OddRabbit

RPGmaker Mafia for Normal People GAME OVER [MAFIA]

author=oddRABBIT
author=OldPat
In here: https://rpgmaker.net/forums/topics/25156/?post=905296#post905296
He says he can't counterclaim tale. That means he was obviously paying attention.

But *then* he says he can't remember who claimed what: https://rpgmaker.net/forums/topics/25156/?post=905309#post905309

That behaviour looked kinda suspicious for me.
I'm not familiar with Odd's passive playstyle, but still...
I just have a bad memory and I was too lazy to go back and check.

As for the digital root thing, I might as well say... What the heck, Jeroen? You just overthought that by a million. I'm pretty sure Psy already solved it, anyways.

My lynch towards OldPat was just me returning his lynch on me. I don't particularly care who dies this phase, so that's the only reason I'm keeping it around after he cancelled the one towards me.


Okay, but as now I've shifted my "joke" lynch to someone else... what are your thoughts on who could be scum?

RPGmaker Mafia for Normal People GAME OVER [MAFIA]

There's something... odd about Odd, I just noticed.

Not only the puzzle thing was very misleading as it was pointed out, and that would put LP on a tight spot too, potentially, but...

In here: https://rpgmaker.net/forums/topics/25156/?post=905296#post905296
He says he can't counterclaim tale. That means he was obviously paying attention.

But *then* he says he can't remember who claimed what: https://rpgmaker.net/forums/topics/25156/?post=905309#post905309

That behaviour looked kinda suspicious for me.
I'm not familiar with Odd's passive playstyle, but still...

RPGmaker Mafia for Normal People GAME OVER [MAFIA]

@Jero:
Fair enough, but that also has something to do with my "unavailability".
At least for me, it's kinda hard to pick up on stuff that already "flew by me".
You all had time to pick up on stuff and build conversation, I came in kinda late.

I did read pretty much every post and I did as much analysis as I could. Demon striked me as potentially scummy because of the reasons he gave for lynching LP. It was certainly subject to change (again: because it was day one and some weak reasonings are understandable), but I still went for it. But it was kinda late in my timezone when I wrote that post and I didn't wanna do a big wall of text then. There was still a long way to go for day one anyway. I just wanted to express my doubts on Demon's post and give my own point of view on that part, adding the LP's schedule thing which no one mentioned.



RPGmaker Mafia for Normal People GAME OVER [MAFIA]

Still reading on Fomar, Emily and Tale.

Tale looks kinda "lost" to me because he's a newbie too (right?)
Difficult for me to do a reading on him, for now.

RPGmaker Mafia for Normal People GAME OVER [MAFIA]

Okay, I'll have to admit, it was certainly a lynch that I gave at the heat of the moment.

It's just that I saw a similarity in both Demon's and Jero's lynch with that of LockeZ during the last game we had (he turned out to be scum there). In the last game we had, LockeZ picked on LP because she was the easier target, as she was having trouble not only keeping up with the game but also with her schedule (and she was a newbie).

As Jero himself said, we were a pair in the last game, so I was aware on when she picked up or not (by comparing when she answered to me through private topic VS public Mafia topic). But it's something everyone could see anyway.

Jero himself knows about both mine and her schedule. I also told him through Discord chatting that I was gonna get back to work again before the second game of Mafia began. Hence he was aware of my unavailability. Voting me for that felt like an "opportunity voting" more than a scum hunting kinda thing.

Hence why him suddenly shifting the blame on me looked odd. And I already had two votes right there, so it was kinda easy to suddenly make my lynch become "trending". Cap said before that Jero was following trend way too much. It looked as if he wanted to pick on a ... not-that-much-suspicious one with his vote on me.

I take back the "stronger reasoning" part though. After all, most of what Jero said is the same thing I said. Only I also added the part about LP's scheduling. It felt strange that someone would go after me after a reasonable reading just because I was "riding a bandwagon". Especially when you got much more easier reads for scum right there.

We got Odd, voting people for no reason at all, even saying he didn't have one and we got Demonlord going for a lynch because a joke hasn't been answered to and using as reason something that was already proven and disregarded in the last mafia game we had (imo, not enough reason for LP to be scum).

I will take my time to do some more readings. I got time to catch up, now.

For now, both Cap and Psy looks town to me, in lack of other readings, as they are pretty much on costant alert and their playstyle for now isn't differing from that of the last game (in which they both were townies).

RPGmaker Mafia for Normal People GAME OVER [MAFIA]

I'll be home and set in three hours from now