PLATINUMASHES'S PROFILE
PlatinumAshes
I am now certain that you are not scum and are just town trying to play scum as hard as possible.
0
Search
Filter
CYOR: Breath of Mafia Game Thread
Right, Marrend, I see what you mean. I believe the word 'Godfather' is used to describe two different types of roles. I'm pretty sure Gourd was referring to the one I described, though. His post wouldn't make much sense otherwise.
CYOR: Breath of Mafia Game Thread
Black's my favorite color.
I'm going to go to sleep. Good luck everyone, I'll be back tomorrow afternoon.
I'm going to go to sleep. Good luck everyone, I'll be back tomorrow afternoon.
CYOR: Breath of Mafia Game Thread
CYOR: Breath of Mafia Game Thread
This game... xD This is really so awesome.
##pizza JalapeƱos!
The presense of a godfather is one possible explanation for the lack of a Mafia kill this night: When Mafia has a godfather, only he/she can perform lynches. So if the Godfather is role-blocked, Mafia loses a lynch.
Since gourd (sort of?) roleblocked Wes last night, and Mafia did indeed lose their lynch, Gourd thinks that Wes is the Godfather.
##pizza JalapeƱos!
author=Marrend
Maybewildwes is godfather, Gourd? That's a rather specific role that you're calling him out on. I mean, I fail to understand how do you even arrived to that assumption.
The presense of a godfather is one possible explanation for the lack of a Mafia kill this night: When Mafia has a godfather, only he/she can perform lynches. So if the Godfather is role-blocked, Mafia loses a lynch.
Since gourd (sort of?) roleblocked Wes last night, and Mafia did indeed lose their lynch, Gourd thinks that Wes is the Godfather.
CYOR: Breath of Mafia Game Thread
My explanation of these events:
1) Our vigilante shot Liberty.
2) Mafia either targeted the turncoat, were role blocked or targeted someone under the protection of the seraph knight or any other protection/revival ability. That last option seems like the most likely to me.
Anyway, Liberty's so good at game, I am really impressed. Her depression and frustration really made me question myself and my vote, and if forced us to waste our first lynch vote. Luckily for us, our vigilante saw through it all and had the nerve to pull the trigger.
Hahaha, this lore.
1) Our vigilante shot Liberty.
2) Mafia either targeted the turncoat, were role blocked or targeted someone under the protection of the seraph knight or any other protection/revival ability. That last option seems like the most likely to me.
Anyway, Liberty's so good at game, I am really impressed. Her depression and frustration really made me question myself and my vote, and if forced us to waste our first lynch vote. Luckily for us, our vigilante saw through it all and had the nerve to pull the trigger.
Hahaha, this lore.
CYOR: Breath of Mafia Game Thread
CYOR: Breath of Mafia Game Thread
So it's getting late here and I'm going to go to sleep soon (I don't have the commitment to stay up 'till 3 am), and that means I won't be able to change votes last-minute like I like too.
I have maybe 15 minutes of time left here. An Isrieri lynch, I hadn't even considered. To be honest, I've kind of nodded at most of his points and I haven't been exposed his text to much scrutiny. Whatever it is that you're finding suspicious, Dudes, I wish you had come up with it earlier, and explained it in more detail. I don't see it myself, but maybe after some explanation I would have. I don't think I can go with Isrieri, today.
I have considered Gourd: He's been more quiet than usual and, more importantly, seemingly less logically consistent. His arguments, particularly those against Liberty seem a little off to me, and he seems less occupied with getting the best target than usual. Here the blame's on me for not making a case for this earlier and testing the validity of these gut feelings... I think I'm still leaning more towards Liberty. The certainty of a very odd false claim in not as much as I'd like, but it's something.
Here's to hoping I wake up tomorrow and finding we got the right person.
I have maybe 15 minutes of time left here. An Isrieri lynch, I hadn't even considered. To be honest, I've kind of nodded at most of his points and I haven't been exposed his text to much scrutiny. Whatever it is that you're finding suspicious, Dudes, I wish you had come up with it earlier, and explained it in more detail. I don't see it myself, but maybe after some explanation I would have. I don't think I can go with Isrieri, today.
I have considered Gourd: He's been more quiet than usual and, more importantly, seemingly less logically consistent. His arguments, particularly those against Liberty seem a little off to me, and he seems less occupied with getting the best target than usual. Here the blame's on me for not making a case for this earlier and testing the validity of these gut feelings... I think I'm still leaning more towards Liberty. The certainty of a very odd false claim in not as much as I'd like, but it's something.
Here's to hoping I wake up tomorrow and finding we got the right person.
CYOR: Breath of Mafia Game Thread
CYOR: Breath of Mafia Game Thread
CYOR: Breath of Mafia Game Thread
This is a difficult position to be in. The suspicions I had of Liberty still stand, but are now weighed against the validity of her fustration. I can see why so many people have been slowly backing off, because her appearance is quite convincing.
That being said, to me her posts have gotten increasingly less convincing because has become increasingly hyperbolic and over the top. To me, her frustration seems disproportionate, and I would not (personally) react the same way if I were in her position.
Since the suspicion she's under is largely due to her own mistakes the way she's lashing out at Gourd and Isrieri just seems somewhat unjustified.
I think she is fully aware of the benefit of showing a strongly moved, aggravated stone in her messages. She's an experienced Mafia player, and she knows how being frustrated makes her seem town here. Even if she IS town, I'm really sure she is exaggerating at this point, to keep herself alive. She is either a townie and exaggerating, or scum and exaggerating greatly.
On top of that, we did not come up with other (decent) leads today. I'm not going to entertain the thought of a No Lynch, which I find an extremely timid and weak strategy (also, I don't think a no lynch is possible this game. Refer to the rules on page 1). I'd rather take a chance with Liberty.
##Lynch Liberty
PS: I'm sorry for my phrasing is offensive, Liberty . Perhaps you're actually really upset and I'm just being rude, but you never know with mafia, and you have to read into everything to win.
That being said, to me her posts have gotten increasingly less convincing because has become increasingly hyperbolic and over the top. To me, her frustration seems disproportionate, and I would not (personally) react the same way if I were in her position.
Since the suspicion she's under is largely due to her own mistakes the way she's lashing out at Gourd and Isrieri just seems somewhat unjustified.
I think she is fully aware of the benefit of showing a strongly moved, aggravated stone in her messages. She's an experienced Mafia player, and she knows how being frustrated makes her seem town here. Even if she IS town, I'm really sure she is exaggerating at this point, to keep herself alive. She is either a townie and exaggerating, or scum and exaggerating greatly.
On top of that, we did not come up with other (decent) leads today. I'm not going to entertain the thought of a No Lynch, which I find an extremely timid and weak strategy (also, I don't think a no lynch is possible this game. Refer to the rules on page 1). I'd rather take a chance with Liberty.
##Lynch Liberty
PS: I'm sorry for my phrasing is offensive, Liberty . Perhaps you're actually really upset and I'm just being rude, but you never know with mafia, and you have to read into everything to win.