ODDRABBIT'S PROFILE

oddRABBIT
I feel bored. How odd.
1979
I like puzzles.
The Quest of Lost Memori...
Piano's Quartet entry for McBacon Jam 3

Search

Filter

[MAFIA] Prisoner's Dilemma. Game Over

I can hammer if you all want. Obviously I'm not going to do it yet in case Shinan suddenly pops up and wants to say something.

[MAFIA] Prisoner's Dilemma. Game Over

author=psy_wombats
@Odd: do you think I'm scum? Your vote is still on me.


Well, um, see my above post, I guess? You, Liberty, and Piano all feel sorta off to me, but I'm an idiot, so I'm really just trusting my gut right now.

[MAFIA] Prisoner's Dilemma. Game Over

I should probably cancel for now, but right now, I have bad feelings about some of the players, so I'm wondering about how lucky I am when it comes to gut instincts in mafia.

I definitely feel that Liberty and Psy are suspicious somehow. Psy claimed rolecop, which I think feels more like a last-minute gambit than anything to me (though that's useless to think about, since technically it is a last-minute gambit if he's scum, and the same scenario if he's not). Meanwhile, the whole feud between Liberty and Piano earlier made me suspicious of them, though I do believe that Piano had a better argument overall, and that Liberty was just much more suspicious and too defensive in that case.

Meanwhile, I think Piano was super suspicious when he just immediately dropped everything when it came to Psy suddenly roleclaiming. It felt sudden, and just really off, and kinda just a dumb, suspicious move overall.

In the end, I'm super bamboozled (does anyone actually use that word anymore?), and I don't really know what to think right now, I guess? I guess my best move right now is just to try and understand everything, and make sure that I make the right decisions overall. If enough people think I should cancel and swap my vote to someone, I can do that, no problem.

[MAFIA] Prisoner's Dilemma. Game Over

author=OzzyTheOne
@Psy how does your role work? If you investigate someone, how does town get the info?


Just a guess, but it probably works like a seer or whatever. An investigation probably only tells the investigator? So, Psy would get it, and then he'd have to tell everyone what it is. That way, it can leave room for the investigated person to counter it, making it more balanced overall?

But, I wouldn't know, so I guess my guess is useless. I'm just basing it on what I think it probably is.

[MAFIA] Prisoner's Dilemma. Game Over

author=Liberty
What? Your post made no sense just now piano. What do you mean 'and then psy tomorrow'? Or that you'll be checked first tonight. He said he was going to check PA.


I think he means that Psy's gonna get killed Night 2, assuming that Psy survives tonight? I think the logic of his statement is "If Psy checks me, then my role will be revealed, but if I die tonight, then Psy's selection is useless, and then mafia can get another free kill off of Psy."

...But that doesn't really make sense in my head, so I'm pretty sure I'm wrong.

[MAFIA] Prisoner's Dilemma. Game Over

Oh, okay. Thanks, Demonlord, I'll look over it again.

[MAFIA] Prisoner's Dilemma. Game Over

What was Demonlord's reads again? I kinda lost track of them, sorry about that.

[MAFIA] Prisoner's Dilemma. Game Over

I do admit, I'm thinking Liberty might be suspicious. I guess for now, I can cancel and I'll vote however the majority votes. Right now, it seems like everyone thinks that Psy is suspicious, and, yeah, I kinda agree.

...It takes me way too long to read through this stuff over and over to understand everything.

But, yeah, I'll hop onto this bandwagon, I guess.

#cancel
#lynch Psy

[MAFIA] Prisoner's Dilemma. Game Over

So, this is probably a little out of character for me, but I agree with Piano on this one, I think? Liberty is just giving me really bad vibes, so I think I might actually swing my vote towards her. I'll vote for now, but if anyone thinks it's a bad idea, I'll cancel upon request from enough people.

But for now...

#lynch Liberty

Sorry if this is a bad call...

[MAFIA] Prisoner's Dilemma. Game Over

Uh, I don't really have any? I'm gonna stay as neutral as possible, like usual. Right now I think Liberty is a little suspicious from the lynch vote on you, but she wasn't in the game with Merlin, right? So it could be she isn't used to your playstyle, so I don't think she should get lynched just due to that?