SIDEWINDER'S PROFILE

Search

Filter

[RM2K3] [RM2K] Looking for Chipset Packs

www.rpg-maker.fr is pretty good.

I'm Leaving

There are better forums out there.

Maybe check out the Yesterweb?

Is AI generated art ethical?

author=Darken
I mean it's not hard to find glancing around wikipedia.

That's... not really a very good response.

To begin with, Mussolini's Italy leaning heavily into the Roman Empire stuff wasn't ever in contention. The issue was what parts of (at the time) modern culture did they consider degenerate?

That's what I can't find a source for. As far as I can tell (again, I'm not actually a historian) there was never any Italian version of 'Degenerate Art', or the book burnings.

Secondly, the link you provided includes a list of Core Tenants of Fascism:

- Palingenetic ultranationalism
- Nationalism
- Imperialism
- Militarism
- Racism
- Dictatorship
- Anti-communism
- Anti-intellectualism
- Anti-pacifism
- Chauvinism
- Conspiracism
- Direct action
- Social interventionism
- Social order
- Indoctrination
- Irrationalism
- Machismo
- Perpetual war
- Propaganda
- Populism
- Syncretism
- Heroism
- Economic interventionism
- Statolatry
- New Man
- Reactionary modernism

Note that 'culture is degrading' isn't one of them.

Thirdly, Wikipedia isn't... really a great source. Especially when dealing with a subject like fascism. There's been more than a few documented cases of Wehraboos just straight up writing fanfiction:
https://www.wired.com/story/one-womans-mission-to-rewrite-nazi-history-wikipedia/

author=Gourd_Clae
Actually, I guess fascism didn't originate in Italy! https://www.britannica.com/topic/fascism/Intellectual-origins

In hindsight, it's probably more accurate to say that Italy was the first fascist country.

author=Gourd_Clae
Try searching for "italian fascism vs decline" or "italian fascism vs decadence" they're essentially the same concepts! I think the way neofascists use it is probably more important though.
https://www.britannica.com/topic/fascism/Volksgemeinschaft (There's a section on it here)
https://sjsu.edu/faculty/wooda/2B-HUM/Readings/The-Doctrine-of-Fascism.pdf

I'm actually pretty sick right now (don't really want to be looking at a screen for much longer), unless there's something in particular you want me to read, I'm probably just going to bow out of this conversation.

Most of the results I'm getting from those two searches don't seem relevant to the conversation, and I'm not sure what I'm supposed to see in the two links you gave me.

I guess the tl;dr is that I don't think criticism or disenfranchisement with modern art is necessarily a gateway drug to the alt-right.

That being said, I also don't think iddalai's right about modern artists being inferior to older ones, either. Guys like Craig Mullins likely won't be remembered the same way Michelangelo was, but they're still just as cool.

Is AI generated art ethical?

author=Gourd_Clae
I don't know if I could really comment on the specific eccentricities of German v italian fascism tbh with you! It's probably more accurate to say that "culture is degrading" is a core tenant of fascism of which the idea of degenerate art is an extension.

Again, I'm not really finding a source for that.

I'm not a historian, nor am I even Italian so I'm probably not the best person to make this point, but as far as I can tell, protecting their culture from "degeneracy" was never a core component of Italian Fascism.

Which is kind of a problem since Italy is where the concept began.

author=Gourd_Clae
The concept of degenerate art is super important to neofascists in particular since it's a really subtle way of infecting ppl with the idea that society is worsening. (also that's an embarrassing typo on tenant on my part)

They'll cling to ideas of cultural degeneracy to give them a sense of legitimacy but in my experience the alt-right spent most of its time recruiting gamers.

Is AI generated art ethical?

author=Gourd_Clae
The idea that modern art has degenerated (along with the rest of culture) is a core tenet of fascism, along with veneration of tradition over all else, rigid violently enforced hierarchies etc. It's not just a random opinion that a random fascist happens to agree with.

A core tenant, though?

Kind of a stretch, plus (as far as I can tell) the concept of 'degenerate art' was more a German thing, not particularly practised by the Italian fascists.

Are vampires overdone?

author=Strak
Having said that, it's good to know that the darker, more monstrous and scarier vampire trope isn't considered overdone, and I like the idea of drawing from various regional folklore as opposed to pop culture. That does give me some more material to work with.


Back when Twilight was this massive juggernaut of a YA series, I'd maybe say to avoid vampires, but this isn't 2007 so you're probably safe.

author=Strak
And that begs the second question, if mechanics and gameplay are original, how much originality is necessary for a story to have?

Plagiarism is bad, but being original is overrated. Don't start thinking that just because a similar story has been told before that yours isn't worth reading.

Recently Watched Movies

Galarians.

I knew it was an obscure PS1 title, picked up a movie adaptation of it at a retro media store.

Kind of reminds me of being a kid, and watching some random garbage on teletoon, late at night.

Is AI generated art ethical?

author=Irog
I always do my best to credit the artists when I use art. If I use AI, how should I credit the art source ?
My personal take is that AI generated images are transformative and should fall under fair use. Crediting the AI would probably be fine.

author=Red_Nova
There is a MASSIVE difference between taking inspiration from other works and copy/pasting pieces of said works into your own
So... how do you feel about the Millennium Falcon?

[RM2K3] Incredibly stretched window skins

Under the System settings in the database, there's an option to set the window skin to 'tile' or 'stretch.'