THATBENNYGUY'S PROFILE

author=Jeroen_Sol
You're 90% sure?
Now I'm having the feeling Chearlie is hiding something... or you are...

I just love how I was suspicious of nobody yesterday and everybody seems like a possible suspect now. -_- Great job on your reasoning, Jeroen, great job. -_-

Yeah, I'm 90% sure. Because of my PM, which according to the rules, I'm not allowed to divulge. But it implies something along the lines of me locking myself in the office. And only the paranoid doctor has anything to do with the office, so it seems I'm safe. Unless someone else can confirm that that's what a normal doctor does.

As for your second point, Jeroen, I think it would be more beneficial to deduct mafia based on their self-claims, since the flavour-text seems to indicate that each person is given a clue of who they are via private message. If anyone else knows who they are, it would be safe to out yourself now. Unless, of course, you are sane doc. We need more of those ;)

Also, we can't protect ourselves again, which is a shame. CAVE_DOG's rules state that you can't protect the same person two days in a row, so we're going to have to figure out some sort of strategy based on the results. I'll start compiling some solutions now.

Cool! Judging by the flavour text I received, I am most likely the Paranoid Doctor. I'm 90% sure.

However, since we don't have any cops to figure out people's alignment, then we cannot make any logical deductions based on our findings. This leads me to believe that simply using our powers, we may not be able to win this game.

This game will be based on "finger of suspicion" votes more than anything, and after we've weeded out the "bad" doctors, we will be forced to lynch those that seem the most "scummy", since there is no way to roleclaim or deduce anything logically from that point on. Unless we find a way to confirm each of our roles based on placement of night actions.

On that note, there may be a better way to go about night 1, so for now I'm unlynching. Perhaps we can find a better solution that will guarantee our survival. It's hurting my brain muscle though, so I better get some sleep.

#cancel

I like Little Wing Guy's term "towntelling". It works better than "scumhunting", because that way, instead of accusing each other madly, mafia has to act more "town" than town, which is difficult to pull off. So we should use that from now on.

Also, I'm calculating the odds of if we made a chain like MrChearlie suggested: doc1->doc2->doc3->...->doc1. It might work. I'll try and figure out the odds.

To be honest, if every doctor saved themselves, we'd weed out the "bad" doctors like CPR. Do we want CPR anyway? No. We want reliable doctors, and we'll fire everyone else.

Coz I'm House M.D.