[MAFIA] RMN: WHEN THEY CRY (TEA PARTY)
Posts
author=Muffle
Gourd is acting real suspicious cracking all those jokes and trying to suspect everyone. Trying to accuse Ozzy for roleplaying and LockeZ for saying not to accuse everyone on day one.
I vote to lynch Gourd as well.
Muffle, if you want to vote someone to be lynched you do it like so:
#lynch Gourd_Clae
Else your vote won't really count.
#cancel
author=LockeZ
yet you lack the conviction to actually type the words in bold, preferring only to egg others on
#cancel
#lynch Muffle
This is so scummy, the poorest excuse for wanting to lynch someone.
#lynch LockeZ
author=Muffleauthor=LockeZSo me pointing out my reasons for suspecting Gourd is considered egging people on? And just because I forgot to put it in bold that makes me suspicious? That's kind of strange.
yet you lack the conviction to actually type the words in bold, preferring only to egg others on
#cancel
#lynch Muffle
Yes, it makes you suspitious as it wasn't a valid vote. You can see the correct form in Locke's post.
author=LockeZ
Gourd, you're trying too hard.
#lynch Gourd_Clae
How is gourd trying too hard
author=LockeZ
yet you lack the conviction to actually type the words in bold, preferring only to egg others on
#cancel
#lynch Muffle
so uhhhh is gourd not trying too hard anymore
author=OzzyTheOne
Muffle, if you want to vote someone to be lynched you do it like so:
#lynch Gourd_Clae
Else your vote won't really count.
#cancel
Yea, I just forgot. By the time I realized it, it was when I came back and LockeZ had said something and I couldn't edit the post.
author=OzzyTheOneauthor=LockeZThis is so scummy, the poorest excuse for wanting to lynch someone.
yet you lack the conviction to actually type the words in bold, preferring only to egg others on
#cancel
#lynch Muffle
#lynch LockeZ
But I do agree with this.
#cancel
#lynch LockeZ
author=OzzyTheOneauthor=LockeZThis is so scummy, the poorest excuse for wanting to lynch someone.
yet you lack the conviction to actually type the words in bold, preferring only to egg others on
#cancel
#lynch Muffle
#lynch LockeZ
Which one? Locke's or your excuse to vote someone?
author=Cap_Hauthor=MuffleYes, it makes you suspitious as it wasn't a valid vote. You can see the correct form in Locke's post.author=LockeZSo me pointing out my reasons for suspecting Gourd is considered egging people on? And just because I forgot to put it in bold that makes me suspicious? That's kind of strange.
yet you lack the conviction to actually type the words in bold, preferring only to egg others on
#cancel
#lynch Muffle
why is it suspicious that the person who hasn't played here before didn't throw down a hard vote (you have also voiced suspicion of people without throwing down a vote)
It doesn't make her suspicious for me, but objectively, not throwing a real vote could be scummy. But its all reliant on strategy and the person, which is posting.
In this case, you're correct that muffle is a newcomer and she's only learning local habbits.
And yes, you can suspect me for that. I still suspect Gourd the most, but its not enough to vote him.
In this case, you're correct that muffle is a newcomer and she's only learning local habbits.
And yes, you can suspect me for that. I still suspect Gourd the most, but its not enough to vote him.
author=TungerManU
Somehow LockeZ's vote on Muffle is "so scummy", but the other ones in this game (none of which have good reasons behind them either) aren't. Your aggressive vote feels way more scummy to me than LockeZ's.
#lynch OzzyTheOne
Finding a valid reason to suspect LockeZ - which was lynching me for a very poor reason - isn't really scummy. I feel like people are starting to lynch others at random because they don't like them, don't agree with them, or are starting to figure out who's on what side and trying to lynch off their enemy.
As Cave and Cap_H had said, I am new at this game and not to mention have an actual memory disability. So it shouldn't come off as suspicious or strange for me to forget a simple thing such as bolding my vote. That was what Ozzy was getting at, not to mention even if it was a little suspicious for some reason or other it still seemed quite sudden to randomly vote to lynch me for one slight mistake on my part. Which could have happened to any new person.
It doesn't help LockeZ's case that right before he was speaking of Gourd trying too hard and once I post a little mistake he chooses to change his vote. Gourd has been posting a lot more than I, so given this fact if he was truly suspicious of Gourd why would he change it to me when I have shown little evidence that I could be the murderer? It just comes off as rash and suspicious on his part, especially since a couple other people are also suspicious of Gourd.
That would be the reason why Ozzy decided to lynch LockeZ, not because he was trying to burn him, get back at him or just being aggressive. May I ask how Ozzy's reason - now that I have given a clear indication on what I believe he was thinking about - is more scummy than LockeZ's reason for lynching me?
author=TungerManUauthor=Cap_HCan't tell if genuine misunderstanding or just a sick burn, but I like it.author=OzzyTheOneWhich one? Locke's or your excuse to vote someone?author=LockeZThis is so scummy, the poorest excuse for wanting to lynch someone.
yet you lack the conviction to actually type the words in bold, preferring only to egg others on
#cancel
#lynch Muffle
#lynch LockeZ
Somehow LockeZ's vote on Muffle is "so scummy", but the other ones in this game (none of which have good reasons behind them either) aren't. Your aggressive vote feels way more scummy to me than LockeZ's.
#lynch OzzyTheOne
I take it that this was a serious vote on LockeZ's site, so my vote on him stands.
This is going to be slightly meta (I apologise!! it literally cannot be helped!!) but I think LockeZ is a bit too smart to give himself away by voting for flimsy reasons.
If he were scum (I see CAVE_DOG fuming at me already), I don't see why he would switch his vote from Gourd to someone else, considering up to that point, Gourd had more than one vote on him already (Locke's own vote + mine).
Crackpot theory is that Gourd and LockeZ are both Mafia, but I think that's a stretch atm.
If he were scum (I see CAVE_DOG fuming at me already), I don't see why he would switch his vote from Gourd to someone else, considering up to that point, Gourd had more than one vote on him already (Locke's own vote + mine).
Crackpot theory is that Gourd and LockeZ are both Mafia, but I think that's a stretch atm.
https://rpgmaker.net/forums/topics/23154/?p=2#posts
six month old game but lockez was acting wildly different as scum.
six month old game but lockez was acting wildly different as scum.
i want to give esby some leeway since i dont think they've played here before but, i would like for them to say things.
author=Yellow Magic
This is going to be slightly meta (I apologise!! it literally cannot be helped!!) but I think LockeZ is a bit too smart to give himself away by voting for flimsy reasons.
If he were scum (I see CAVE_DOG fuming at me already), I don't see why he would switch his vote from Gourd to someone else, considering up to that point, Gourd had more than one vote on him already (Locke's own vote + mine).
Crackpot theory is that Gourd and LockeZ are both Mafia, but I think that's a stretch atm.
I don't know if I was clear, my apologies. I wasn't saying he completely gave himself away, I am quite aware how smart LockeZ is. I was just stating why he seemed so suspicious, and it still doesn't really make sense why he would randomly change his vote for some flimsy reason. Especially considering I had only posted once before that post, and unless he's just randomly trying to lynch people off it kind of comes off strange to me as LockeZ as I assume would usually wait to try and see if he could find more clues that I could be in the Mafia.
I wish I could say he was trying to joke around but it seemed like a pretty serious vote on his part. Of course, we can't be for sure if LockeZ or Gourd are in the Mafia. But may I ask LockeZ, is there any other reasoning that would make more sense than you gave me as to why you decided to lynch me? Perhaps if you give a more valid reason that would make sense to me, I'd be willing to change my vote.
It honestly confuses me because it almost seems as if he's trying to purposely make himself suspicious. But there's nothing he could gain from that. Because of this, I can't think of any valid and good reason to try and lynch me even if he did think I was suspicious because I messed up. Knowing LockeZ and how smart he is, I also would have figured he'd understand how it was a misunderstanding. Still wondering if he's just trying to spite me, but again this makes no sense since he seems like a serious vote.
So unless LockeZ can describe a reasoning that makes more sense and isn't a poor excuse to lynch me, then my vote still stands to lynch him.
LockeZ
I'd really like to get rid of LockeZ. His play style is way too unpredictable. He's always like this too. If he ran a country, he'd just kill and imprison people at random until crime stopped.
5958
I mean I was just trying to get Muffle to actually vote and start some real discussion. I guess technically it worked. I'm satisfied.
#cancel
I don't like this post:
Followed immediately by this one, in which without even waiting for a response, he felt the need to give a third reason:
It's like, we're on day one, you don't need to rapid fire off three different reasons for a vote that you didn't even make but merely suggested to other people. That's definitely "methinks thou doth protest too much" level defensive.
I'm actually moving my vote back to Gourd because I think it's actually a good vote, unlike Muffle, whom I was just prodding (with very sharp knives).
#cancel
author=CAVE_DOG_IS_BACKauthor=LockeZHow is gourd trying too hard
Gourd, you're trying too hard.
#lynch Gourd_Clae
I don't like this post:
author=Gourd_Clae
I just wanted to declare someone's life forfeit tbh
Ozzy's life or another's? It makes no difference to me. Plus, yeah, getting the game going requires killing someone as unfortunate as that is.
Followed immediately by this one, in which without even waiting for a response, he felt the need to give a third reason:
author=Gourd_Clae
It would be a tragedy to kill another person with a Gourd Original(tm) though.
It's like, we're on day one, you don't need to rapid fire off three different reasons for a vote that you didn't even make but merely suggested to other people. That's definitely "methinks thou doth protest too much" level defensive.
I'm actually moving my vote back to Gourd because I think it's actually a good vote, unlike Muffle, whom I was just prodding (with very sharp knives).
LockeZ
I'd really like to get rid of LockeZ. His play style is way too unpredictable. He's always like this too. If he ran a country, he'd just kill and imprison people at random until crime stopped.
5958
#lynch Gourd_Clae
author=LockeZ
I'm actually moving my vote back to Gourd because I think it's actually a good vote, unlike Muffle, whom I was just prodding (with very sharp knives).
I wish I could say this is a trick to make me take my eyes off of you, but this actually makes much more sense than the flimsy reason you gave me as well as it's very LockeZ-esque. So, therefore, after feeling humiliated and tricked by this mastermind, I will change my vote xD Very good job LockeZ.
#cancel
#lynch Gourd_Clae
author=CAVE_DOG_IS_BACK
i want to give esby some leeway since i dont think they've played here before but, i would like for them to say things.
it's day one and so far it's just been shit flinging and revenge votes, what do you expect me to say?
Before I get into things, esby wasn't even the first one to make that butler joke. See post #2 in thread where I made it at the same time as signing up.
Now then...on to the game. Honestly, gourds over-eagerness seems normal for him. I don't think it's an indication that he's scum. I have nothing on lockez yet, but I don't think he'd be so aggressive this early if he were scum. I don't particularly like his vote, but i'm betting he only did it to see everyones reactions. Muffle seems new to the whole thing, and I'd rather not vote a new player day 1. It gives them time to learn, and we aren't going to get a read this early on someone we haven't seen play before.
This leaves basically everyone else. I'm thinking ozzy just hasn't seemed that serious this game, and his reasoning for voting lockez is a rather poor one. I'm not completely convinced yet but for now...
#lynch OzzyTheOne
Now then...on to the game. Honestly, gourds over-eagerness seems normal for him. I don't think it's an indication that he's scum. I have nothing on lockez yet, but I don't think he'd be so aggressive this early if he were scum. I don't particularly like his vote, but i'm betting he only did it to see everyones reactions. Muffle seems new to the whole thing, and I'd rather not vote a new player day 1. It gives them time to learn, and we aren't going to get a read this early on someone we haven't seen play before.
This leaves basically everyone else. I'm thinking ozzy just hasn't seemed that serious this game, and his reasoning for voting lockez is a rather poor one. I'm not completely convinced yet but for now...
#lynch OzzyTheOne




















