New account registration is temporarily disabled.

JOSEPHSERAPH'S PROFILE

expression

old avatar log


http://i.imgur.com/cZVMqmn.gif (1.29.2017 - 3.30.2017)
http://i.imgur.com/wBF9yy6.png (06.13.2016 - 01.29.2017)
http://i.imgur.com/MmQhwCA.gif (04.25.2016 - 06.13.2016)
https://36.media.tumblr.com/4348623c8c1e650f399dc5806b043951/tumblr_o5u4yp8q5f1qktz4xo1_250.png (04.18.2016 - 04.25.2016)
(blank) (03.31.2016 - 04.18.2016)
https://45.media.tumblr.com/eff2e25eb273ceac010856f5e84a466d/tumblr_o4loyzOGkV1qktz4xo1_250.gif (03.25.2016 - 03.31.2016)
http://i.imgur.com/qMBRqEl.png (03.11.2016 - 03.25.2016)
http://i.imgur.com/uMziTvv.png (02.02.2016 - 03.11.2016)
http://i.imgur.com/ZzSew04.png (12.13.2015 - 02.02.2016)
http://i.imgur.com/yJztZDt.png (12.12.2015 - 12.13.2015)
https://31.media.tumblr.com/525c96811b416d1fdeb9f274d6ccc97b/tumblr_nx4bvbwDzz1qktz4xo1_250.gif (10.23.2015 - 12.12.2015)
http://i.imgur.com/T0JPIkf.png (10.23.2015 - 11.01.2015)
https://33.media.tumblr.com/8b4988b601ecb1191d6b6c243b040a96/tumblr_nw92c9GBeV1qktz4xo2_r1_250.gif (10.15.2015 - 10.23.2015)
(empty) (09.23.2015 - 10.15.2015)
http://i.imgur.com/9e7U7IJ.gif (09.09.2015 - 09.23.2015)
http://i.imgur.com/jqIYVxe.gif (09.07.2015 - 09.09.2015)
http://i.imgur.com/lEMKIwQ.png (08.30.2015 - 09.07.2015)
http://i.imgur.com/8dWQClj.png (08.28.2015 - 08.30.2015)
http://i.imgur.com/H9rxf4D.gif (08.21.2015 - 08.28.2015)
http://i.imgur.com/BZHFfGM.png (08.16.2015 - 08.21.2015)
http://i.imgur.com/j7hRiNN.png (07.16.2015 - 08.16.2015)
??? (rikku) (image deaded) (06.18.2015 - 07.16.2015)
http://i.imgur.com/lEw3JEq.gif - (05.02.2015 - 06.18.2015)
http://i.imgur.com/x0Eun6m.gif - (04.30.2015 - 02.05.2015)
http://i.imgur.com/R9uhXdq.gif - (28.04.2015 - 30.04.2015)
https://33.media.tumblr.com/ff883554d0c0256b23b1fe133c6d2411/tumblr_nmi5v5QVR51qktz4xo1_250.gif ( 08.04.2015 - 28.04.2015)
http://i.imgur.com/bQxPg92.png (02.04.2015 - 08.04.2015)
http://i.imgur.com/iakfGdA.gif (31.03.2015 - 02.04.2015
http://i.imgur.com/er7LeT6.png (14.02.2015 - 31.03.2015)
http://i.imgur.com/er7LeT6.png (10.02.2015 - 14.02.2015)
http://i.imgur.com/kM9IXDf.png (08.02.2015 - 10.02.2015)
http://i.imgur.com/CKQVWpB.png (27.01.2015 - 08.02.2015)
http://i.imgur.com/fbUd5jU.png (12.08.2014 - 27.01.2015)
http://i.imgur.com/ne1AeVF.gif (11.07.2014 - 12.08.2014)
http://i.imgur.com/oXsxU6p.gif (10.14.2014 - 11.07.2014)
http://i.imgur.com/Q1Y70q3.gif (07.20.2014 - 10.14.2014)
http://i.imgur.com/hD3H0Ex.gif (03.12.2014 - 07.20.2014)
http://i.imgur.com/jYsnkAI.gif (??.??.???? - 03.12.2014)
http://i.imgur.com/w8MBFVK.gif
http://i.imgur.com/XhVdO2c.png
Resonate ~call out my an...
A girl and her newfound friends must grow a tree to return home.

Search

Filter

A.I. Generation and RMN

KrimsonKatt
1: But I'm broke and lazy.

Case closed.

Laziness is perfectly moral and correct. Absolutely nothing wrong with being lazy. Or with being depressed, anxious, having to grapple with a difficult daily life. But AI isn't your saviour, El*n M*sk and OpenAI won't fix your bank account or your lack of bandwidth to allocate to art.

KrimsonKatt
I had natural talent though?

Subjective. What we call "natural talent" is merely interest, hyperfocus, etc. And improvement is not linear. But, as a person that has art teaching skills, I can objectively assess which areas are lacking in your art skills and could give you directions as to how to improve them.

Because art is mostly comprised of a set of objective tools used to birth subjective ideas. And I'm going to tell you -- if you're "lazy", you're not going to sketch and re-sketch to improve your composition. You're not going to bother spending countless hours drawing from reference to build a mental library, or following many of the amazing exercises very competent artists have crafted to help improve spatial awareness, for instance. And that's alright, art can be good without these fundamentals as well, since the subjective part is what it's all about. But...

KrimsonKatt

This level of anatomic concistency is that of a professional artist. Professional artists have invested not only countless hours into their careers, but also money in tutoring. You can't expect to shortcut your way into it if you're "lazy" -- especially if you don't have the money for proper tutoring, which is immensely helpful in actually telling you where it would be more efficient for you to spend your time improving in.

KrimsonKatt
Guess I have to work 10x as hard for inferior work done all by myself without help from AI then...
Or you can work 10x as easy for... Unsuperior work, all while NOT learning the anatomy you clearly are avoiding by tracing outlines, ultimately stagnating in your ability to express yourself. (Not to mention there are other better shortcuts to anatomy which can actually help you improve your art like posing dolls, even if you trace over them, ESPECIALLY if they're not anime)

Also, wanna get better at anime? Study art that's not anime.

I understand AI is a tempting alternative to practicing, but you're building on a foundation that you don't have, which means your house isn't as sturdy. There's obviously the moral side to it all but I really don't wanna get in there in this post.

Seriously, you remind me a little bit of how angry my sister gets whenever I tell her that "to be decent at something, you need to have 1000h of experience doing that thing" -- I don't mean her ill, but she's the kind to start drawing, hate the results then just quit for days. She's been getting better at it, though. But still got very, very low tolerance for frustration.



EDIT: The thing that I wanted to get to: Just like you're broke, most of us are. Art is expensive because it's time consuming. For example, $100 for a full body portrait is the type of pricing you can expect from me. But I will often spend DAYS, plural, on that portrait, while working from my home office (meaning consuming my own electricity, water, food, EQUIPMENT which is very expensive ESPECIALLY here in Brazil, etc.)

When you sum that all up, $100 a day's worth of work, considering all the related expenses as well as the years and dollars upon dollars artists like me have spent on art tutoring, supplies, drawing tablets, PCs, etc, isn't really expensive at all -- it's cheap.

But if you invest that in yourself, train and practice, you'll get better.


By the way, I totally recommend something like MakeHuman for you to practice drawing your characters -- DO NOT TRACE AT ALL not even outlines if you wanna improve, just try to copy the proportins, but these sorts of character creators can be a great starting point.

And my personal recommendation for you would be to practice copying without tracing WHILE changing the view. So do an exact copy of a character, then do it seen from the side, from a little up, from a little down. Do that enough and you'll develop that spatial and anatomic awareness to be able to craft your poses and characters with relative ease!

A.I. Generation and RMN

KrimsonKatt
Now people will have to do everything themselves or pay someone hundreds to do it for them, which many people don't have the time or skill to pull off. I'm lucky enough to know how to draw at least decently well and I'm learning how to compose as well, but not everyone has that sort of natural talent.


1. Yeah, people's work is worth money, including your own!
2. Skill is not a matter of "natural talent", I for example wasn't "born" an artist, I spent my entire life honing my craft which is why I can produce decent paintings relatively quickly. Very unlike pushing a button on Midjourney and producing an image that superficially resembles something a senior Riot Games artist (ew) would take 1 month and a very engorged salary to painstakingly craft :P

KrimsonKatt
Also, what about images that use AI as a base to work off of? That means I have to redraw EVERY character sprite for Chronicles Meteorfall because all of them use traced and edited AI images as bases.


To be fair I can confidently say it's generally harder to edit AI images into your own style than to just grasp an efficient workflow, and that all has the bonus that your art will look like your art, and not like Midjourney

A.I. Generation and RMN

I'm ambivalent as well, but I think it's cool RMN as a website has the ability to take a stance towards this

On one hand, I think situations like this:
Liberty
- Is it an edit of AI-generated art/etc that you're claiming? No.

Are a bit tricky because sometimes it's the other way around - it's an AI edit of your own created art - For instance I've played around with AI to "teach it" my art style, and I often like the result: Feels like looking at yourself in the strangest of mirrors.

On the other hand trying to draw a line too fine will inevitably lead to exploitation and headache for the staff

In the end, though, RMN's nature as a community with shared morals and values (a collective conscious, so to speak), and not just a generic hosting platform, means taking a stance when it comes to important and current topics like this an important thing to do.

A.I. Generation and RMN

author=Liberty
There is definitely a difference between a plugin that automatically implants AI-generated text for NPCs or using graphics that were created by an AI bot for your game and one that allows entities to draw from in-engine scripts to have them act in specific ways in response to player movement (basically a much more detailed version of IF player x, THEN event y).

And it's a huge huge difference, if you were to call if-then AI then, well, RPG Maker itself would be banned. It's the name "AI" that's misleading, and I think what we're referring to here really is specifically a type of machine learning that uses scraped data to generate more data similar to that which it scraped. Entirely different from FF6 monster behavior code

I think Liberty's answers were pretty good at clearing things up.

Edit: That being said, that's exactly the type of machine learning that powers tools from the classic healing tool to predictive text to SOME upscaling algorhithms, which is why it's good that we estabilish clear boundaries

Boulevard of Broken 2k3 Dreams

not only there's a point IT'S THE ENTIRE POINT OF THE EVENT do it >:-(
(lookin' rad!!!)

They Walk Among Us

o no 日本語はACCEPTEDではない puxa vida, my team name got all messed up

heyyyyyyyy girliessssssss let's slayyy this is gonna be THE event (imma make a fart-ass project1 game 'cause i blew all my steam in the last one)

SS5.png

Tysmmmmmmm <3 <3 <3 <3 i frigging love node-based maps <3

A.I. Generation and RMN

the day final fantasy fangames are banned (the only thing to ever beat pom gets wifi) is the day i cease experiencing any emotion whatsoever

but objectively rips/fangames are iconic, love letters, and historically are the basis of all art to be honest. like, that's how people become artists. making fanart of sailor moon or captain america or david's cock

while AI, well. Machine learning has been there for decades, but flat out models that can spit out "new" images mimicking other artists's styles? that's new. And that's not a good new.

So I was thinking, maybe the rule would be fairer if it were something like "using ai generated assets directly is strictly forbidden, even if edited or altered" -- a bit narrower.

Meaning, for the case of text:

"Bard, write John's dialogue boxes when you first meet him"
*pastes text into game" = forbidden

"Bard, write John's dialogue boxes when you first meet him"
*uses text as reference, writes text into game" = forbidden?

"Bard, give me some cool game ideas that I can finish in a weekend"
*takes one of the game ideas as a base, makes a game in a month bc it was harder than expected orz* = ok


Or in the case of images:

"Midjourney: A screenshot of a visual scene of a purple haired priestess gasping in horror"
*uses image as a game still* = forbidden

*redraws image and uses as a game still" = allowed? IDK... I mean how could you even tell.. Most artists will have a hell of an easier time just using movie stills for reference, though, since they have much better composition than AI generated blobbery

Aaaaaaa maybe it's easier to just ban and say "act in good faith" yeah ´A`


EDIT: Frogge made some good questions. And on that topic, I like asking Bard stuff like
*describes my characters* what zodiac signs fit them, and why?
What do you think is their favourite fruit?
If they were a type of car, what would it be (I LEGITIMATELY ASK THESE THINGS SOMETIMES OK.......... not with the intention of that actually being their zodiac or favourite fruit, but moreso exploring archetypes and what the text algorhithm expects me to write)

Ruins of Provolone

A.I. Generation and RMN

I don't feel as strongly as Sidewinder but I, as another artist's voice, also think this is a well-intentioned but "narrow-minded" decision.

The reason I don't feel as strongly is that just how this rule came to be shaped the way is is now, Im sure it will be inevitably changed or substituted by another one in the future, based on things that are happening _now_.

Like sidewinder mentioned, any artist learning Photoshop today has Adobe Firefly built right in. And just like the Healing tool when it was released (afaik it IS machine learning also, albeit an archaic algorhithm from a decade ago) people will use it to touch up a photo or a messed up texture. Scaling up images on clip studio paint is now powered by AI. The predictive text from the phone I'm typing this right now is AI -- machine learning -- and likewise it has been for a decade.

Sidewinder's example of "an AI generated planet texture trained off of public domain NASA satellite photos" is particularly interesting, and particularly contrasting with the Midjourney visual novels or the ChatGPT amazon e-books.

Personally, I have used google bard to help me find programming flaws (it is glaringly bad at that but sometimes it helps), it's different than writing "a novel in the style of Stephen King" or idk, npc dialogue. (In the style of Stephen King...)

I think this will all become clearer in the years to come. And us artists are absolutely not getting replaced, I think. Not anywhere we weren't, already.

For now, this may very well be a good measure and a good stance taken by RMN, but one that is either rather severe - moreso than Kentona and Liberty might be thinkig -- or actually really fair, but in a way that's kind of subjective
In any case, asking "good faith" from the developers is the kinda thing that's usually subjective yet morally easy to understand.