New account registration is temporarily disabled.

KOFF'S PROFILE

Cataphract OI
Experimental RPG about time management and protecting allies

Search

Filter

[MAFIA] The Salem Witch Trials of November

sigh

/lynch abstain

[MAFIA] The Salem Witch Trials of November

it should be fine if the brothers just come forward. if the witches do attempt a false claim (which i still think is unlikely), the real bros are almost guaranteed to counter-claim (that is to say, they would be very dumb not to) and that puts us in a favorable position. no need to wait around for every single player to claim. :/

[MAFIA] The Salem Witch Trials of November

its impact isn't purely statistical, however. if the brothers are out in the open, we have someone we can trust to give frank opinions and directions without a hidden agenda. the point isn't just to bolster the odds - it's to start getting the village organized, informed, and moving in the same direction (provided at least one of the brothers can provide adequate leadership)

[MAFIA] The Salem Witch Trials of November

are there any other thoughts on solitayre's plan?

[MAFIA] The Salem Witch Trials of November

what if we enact both proposed plans so as to confirm as many innocents as possible? on some level i think that we'd benefit more from the added organizational power than from trying to protect vitiated power roles.

also
if the witches false-claim, the real brothers can counter-claim and put the witches in a dangerous position. i really don't see them trying to pull that stunt.

[MAFIA] The Salem Witch Trials of November

post=Natook
The brothers would probably stay alive, since the mafia would then know who NOT to kill and aim for people who are more likely to be important. But hey, I suppose in the end it's up to the "brothers" to decide.

one would expect they'd go straight for the brothers. having a confirmed innocent so early in the game would strengthen the town's organizational power considerably, and the witches would be foolish to let us get away with that.

[MAFIA] The Salem Witch Trials of November

speaking in tongues does little to help your case

[MAFIA] The Salem Witch Trials of November

hey shinan next time you try to impersonate an honest, god-loving puritan, maybe you should take into account that protestants don't speak fucking latin you godless hag or possible catholic scum

post=Kitsune Inferno
Anyways, as I said, it's nothing but advantageous to the town if Ezekiel and Herrick come forth.

-It gives us two innos
-It allows the lynch more accuracy
-It allows the cop more accuracy
-It gives the angel two safe options tonight

But now this may sound a little harsh but...
-It buys the cop and angel two more days of time, as it gives the witches two confirmed townies to burn through instead.
this makes a lot of sense to me. at the very least i think it's a good starting point. does anyone see any reason why we shouldn't follow through on this?

[MAFIA] The Salem Witch Trials of November

pretty sure X_X means "dead".

[MAFIA] The Salem Witch Trials of November

regardless of shinan's motive for asking, it's an important question and i'd like to hear the answer as well.