PUDDOR'S PROFILE

Puddor
if squallbutts was a misao category i'd win every damn year
5702
aren't you tired of being nice? don't you just want to go apeshit?

there's words for people who use AI instead of hiring artists and I'm not allowed to use them here, but i hope they know i'll see them in the northern territory
Nachtheulen
Two vampires. One plot to change all they know.

Search

Filter

Phoenix Mafia: Online Turnabout



I also move to have this witness declared an idiot.

Phoenix Mafia: Online Turnabout




Hang on just one second! If you are indeed claiming said role, there's no way you would also know for certain that Wes is town!

Phoenix Mafia: Online Turnabout

Phoenix Mafia: Online Turnabout



Why are you going back to the idea of lynching inactives when we've got two potential scum on our hands? There's no guarantee that my investigation will be accurate thanks to the possibility of a Mafia Framer and the fact that there's a Mastermind who can hide from my ability.

Phoenix Mafia: Online Turnabout



I thought you said you were the one who gave her the cookie...? Did I misread that?

I'm not entirely sure what it could mean if it wasn't actually you. We don't seem to have a mafia role that indicates there's someone who can poison other players (despite it being a typical method of killing people in the Ace Attorney universe *deep sigh*)



Maybe someone targeted her overnight, a non-malicious role, and the cookie was the indicator for herself that someone had targeted her in a way that didn't prompt interaction? That's my line of reasoning at the moment.

Phoenix Mafia: Online Turnabout

author=pianotm
You know, I tried to go back and read the posts from his point of view, but I don't see it. I'm not Cave. I can't read like Cave. I can't read like LockeZ. I can't read like Liberty. Only Cave can read like Cave. Only LockeZ can read like LockeZ. Only Liberty can read like Liberty. We can try the best we can to read like each other, but he won't even give us a point of reference. He's saying, "This post is scum." He's saying, "Liberty sounds different when she's town." He's saying, "She's only pretending to help." What he's not saying is that the vast majority of the people in this game have never played a mafia game with Liberty. Reading past threads and actually interacting are two different things. What is he pointing out; the lack of banana references?




The real problem with this line of thinking is that it implies Liberty is going to be a static person with only two modes of play-- mafia and town, which is simply not true, because she's not a robot. It's been a long time since we all played mafia together and Liberty's responsibilities and general position and life have changed-- moderating forums tends to make a person bitter (hell, the entirety of RMN tends to turn me into this guy:
)

I have played mafia with Liberty in the past, and while she has been a tad more aggressive than usual, it's reflective of her new duties, and besides that general quirk, she reads town to me.

Phoenix Mafia: Online Turnabout


AAAAAAAAAAAALRRIGHT WE NEED TO REVERSE OUR THINKING



yes I am here

I will admit that it was Cave who first pointed out wildwes. LockeZ has dramatically jumped down on my scumdar because he failed to take a roleclaim, however the roleclaim itself was a misread and taking it could have come across as scummy in the long run. There is a second reason as to why he's gotten lower on my radar. I will also say that I've skimmed the last 80 post and will be doing a more detailed read through after I've actually done some work for the day.



Anyway, I think we're heading in the wrong direction in terms of scumhunting, and I think there are a number of people who are doing nothing but waffle. MajoracanKing, for instance.

Phoenix Mafia: Online Turnabout

also im about to head to bed and NOW you guys get active? really?

Phoenix Mafia: Online Turnabout

I will have to double check that, but I know my (albeit mild) scum read wasn't unfounded.

Phoenix Mafia: Online Turnabout



Yeah, that struck me as weird and did considerably lessen my suspicions. LockeZ can be particularly aggressive even in normal forum standings, so this may just be his playstyle.