Full Games List
Featured Games
New Games
Reviews
Media
Images
Blogs
Game Updates
Images Feedback Summary
Game Design Highlights
Tutorials
Articles
Scripts
Utilities / Plugins
Resources
Engines
Engine Bulletins
What is Makerscore?
Past Events
Achievements
Misaos
Forums
Chat
New to RMN?
Full Store List
RMN Music Pack (free)
Profile
Locker
Play ListsPSY_WOMBATS'S PROFILE
psy_wombats
13315
Close
Dememorize
a 2.5d explorer/horror game about NEURAL-9, a memory disease that spreads via eye contact
a 2.5d explorer/horror game about NEURAL-9, a memory disease that spreads via eye contact
Search
Filter
All
Game Pages
User Statuses
[MAFIA] Is this Werewolf?
We had an even number of players, were potentially set up for follow-the-cop, and Trihan doesn't look scummy. I think it was the right call given the info available.
[MAFIA] Is this Werewolf?
Yeah I'm not willing to kill Trihan, would rather nokill. One of the Trihan voters has to be around to make anything else work.
[MAFIA] Is this Werewolf?
Also no-kill wouldn't be bad today (would prefer it to Trihan dying). We have an even number of players, a seer in the open, and presumably a bodyguard, soo
[MAFIA] Is this Werewolf?
Well it wouldn't be RMN without a day 1 seer claim.
Anyway, of Demonlord/Trihan I prefer demonlord, although his recent posts have been pretty good, and the reasoning in this Trihan post is pretty bad https://rpgmaker.net/forums/topics/25302/?post=909522#post909522 -- but I have a hard time buying scum-Trihan, he'd have to be a pretty good actor and his thinking looks town-ish even if I think the logic's wonky.
This AE post I could totally buy being scum logic though: https://rpgmaker.net/forums/topics/25302/?post=909513#post909513 -- Odd looks really safe to me and votes on the Fomar bandwagon don't look great. I'd suggest last minute vote swap but I'd probably get punched.
Anyway, of Demonlord/Trihan I prefer demonlord, although his recent posts have been pretty good, and the reasoning in this Trihan post is pretty bad https://rpgmaker.net/forums/topics/25302/?post=909522#post909522 -- but I have a hard time buying scum-Trihan, he'd have to be a pretty good actor and his thinking looks town-ish even if I think the logic's wonky.
This AE post I could totally buy being scum logic though: https://rpgmaker.net/forums/topics/25302/?post=909513#post909513 -- Odd looks really safe to me and votes on the Fomar bandwagon don't look great. I'd suggest last minute vote swap but I'd probably get punched.
[MAFIA] Is this Werewolf?
I'd rather kill scum. Lycan isn't scum.
(also funnily enough lycan/miller/whatever is the one role where the /correct/ play is claiming it immediately haha)
My top lead's still Demon. AE could work just as well. Fomar would have to be sorceror for me to believe he's scum.
(also funnily enough lycan/miller/whatever is the one role where the /correct/ play is claiming it immediately haha)
My top lead's still Demon. AE could work just as well. Fomar would have to be sorceror for me to believe he's scum.
[MAFIA] Is this Werewolf?
@demonlord:
FWIW I also think leaving the masons secret for a day or two would've been the better play, but I don't think Odd suggesting they reveal themselves is scummy -- as Odd noted, he just read Raging Loop where town uses that strategy pretty effectively.
@Jero: Fomar's vote struck me as slightly opportunistic as well, but if he's acting in bad faith, scum-Fomar was taking a pretty big chance hitching his vote to the Odd-is-sorceror wagon right away.
author=psy_wombatsauthor=MuffleIf all of those roles were guaranteed to be in the game, with 10 players, I think it's mathematically solved from the beginning with a massclaim and the bodyguard protecting the seer.
4. There may be multiple roles of the roles mentioned above, or zero roles of the ones mentioned above. This will make the game harder to solve role-claim wise.
FWIW I also think leaving the masons secret for a day or two would've been the better play, but I don't think Odd suggesting they reveal themselves is scummy -- as Odd noted, he just read Raging Loop where town uses that strategy pretty effectively.
@Jero: Fomar's vote struck me as slightly opportunistic as well, but if he's acting in bad faith, scum-Fomar was taking a pretty big chance hitching his vote to the Odd-is-sorceror wagon right away.
[MAFIA] Is this Werewolf?
Demon didn't go after Odd for the lycan claim --
And it's not that scum wants a lycan dead, they just want a non-sorceror dead. Lycan is irrelevant except that it's not sorceror. I have no idea whether scum realized the lycan claim or not, but ignoring Odd while his sorc joke-claim stood and then going after him when he retracted it is a bad look.
author=demonlord5000
Odd's more recent posts lowered my opinion a bit. Joke voting on day 1 is such a common thing at this point, and the fact I remembered he was going to claim that anyways it didn't really bother me.
His more recent post where he suggests that the masons should claim looks glaringly bad to me though. The whole seer shouldn't target me also bugs me. If he's town he's making the seer curious and potentially influencing their decision, and if he scum he's trying to avoid being detected. Looks bad both ways to me, and I feel his posts are not helping us.
I could vote for atiya or odd today, but for now I'm going to do this.
#cancel
#lynch odd
And it's not that scum wants a lycan dead, they just want a non-sorceror dead. Lycan is irrelevant except that it's not sorceror. I have no idea whether scum realized the lycan claim or not, but ignoring Odd while his sorc joke-claim stood and then going after him when he retracted it is a bad look.
[MAFIA] Is this Werewolf?
@Dudesoft: Demonlord isn't lycan, Oddrabbit is. Demonlord's likely scum. And why Oddrabbit, you doubt him?
@Jero: Also, trying to fakeclaim lycan would be a pretty dumb scumplay seeing as how a real one would counterclaim him.
(also if a not-Oddrabbit person is lycan, do counterclaim him)
@Jero: Also, trying to fakeclaim lycan would be a pretty dumb scumplay seeing as how a real one would counterclaim him.
(also if a not-Oddrabbit person is lycan, do counterclaim him)
[MAFIA] Is this Werewolf?
The last thing scum would want to do is kill their sorceror buddy, so, daykilling someone claiming miller is pretty safe, especially given how easy is should be to get millers daykilled. Claimed miller is of no use to scum, not like anyone will investigate him now, and besides, seer still isn't 100% accurate given sorc.
And I dunno, that logic thing definitely not a sure thing, but Odd's joking -> participating had a reaction in Demon that was "no problem with a joke" -> "kill Odd", whereas mine was the total opposite of "joke my ass, kill him" -> "he's safe", to the point where I'm betting there's scum-logic motivating it.
And I dunno, that logic thing definitely not a sure thing, but Odd's joking -> participating had a reaction in Demon that was "no problem with a joke" -> "kill Odd", whereas mine was the total opposite of "joke my ass, kill him" -> "he's safe", to the point where I'm betting there's scum-logic motivating it.
Games - Tester
Games - Other
