PSY_WOMBATS'S PROFILE

Search

Filter

[MAFIA] Star Trek (Limited Reveal) Mafia - Day 1

I think I voted like once this game but it was a town win so w/e. Going to take a mafia break for a decent chunk of time probably, hopefully next game's more involved. Sorry to newbies if this wasn't really representative of what a game should be.

[MAFIA] Star Trek (Limited Reveal) Mafia - Day 1

I would guess because it's the theoretically "correct" tactic.

[MAFIA] Star Trek (Limited Reveal) Mafia - Day 1

And sorry Odd, that came off meaner that I intended but I can't edit now - I'm know you're capable of being a competent town PR so don't kneecap yourself by claiming early every game

[MAFIA] Star Trek (Limited Reveal) Mafia - Day 1

@Odd: yes I understood that, because I am capable of hitting the "Posts" button on a person's profile and reviewing thread history with a fourth grader's level of understanding. Buuut like the last game, this doesn't imply /at all/ that the person doing this is town. If you have a town PR, what you should be aiming to do is avoid attention, foremost, and then if you want to get fancy, breadcrumbing what role you had. But the idea of a breadcrumb is to confirm what role you had in retrospect and not confirming it to scum ahead of time.

Luckily I have no idea if you intend to protect yourself or not tonight, so keep it that way.

@OldPat: It's a parity cop. So they can confirm as innocent 2 people a night (assuming they don't miraculously guess the whole scumteam) or mark as guilty a set of two people. If muffle got a result of "mixed" on n1 for CaveDog+Fomar then it confirms that CaveDog is guilty, because Fomar is innocent. If this is unclear, read the role description. I've never played in a game with a parity cop either before but it's not /that/ weird.

[MAFIA] Star Trek (Limited Reveal) Mafia - Day 1

For newbies or anyone else in doubt, if you're vanilla and not the parity cop, just post "I am not the parity cop" and that's good enough for me and then we can kill off that scumlord Cavedog~

[MAFIA] Star Trek (Limited Reveal) Mafia - Day 1

Nah, that's a job well done if you nailed Cave.

Anyone going to counterclaim Muffle?

[MAFIA] Star Trek (Limited Reveal) Mafia - Day 1

bbcode ate my message -- should read result are like "demon odd fomar emily" ie 100% worthless, but, even then

[MAFIA] Star Trek (Limited Reveal) Mafia - Day 1

I thought you'd be the cop because there's no real reason for any other role to claim. No one was even voting for you this time, c'monn

Still think the cop should claim unless their results are like

[MAFIA] Star Trek (Limited Reveal) Mafia - Day 1

The point of not talking during the first two days was to prevent scum from getting a bead on our PRs - discussion would only let them get info, because we weren't actually going to use the content of any discussion to scumhunt. But we're at the point now where we should be talking so as to allow us to actually find scum.

I don't know if like Cave or someone has another opinion but I think it's best bet for cop to come forward vs risk getting nk'd tonight and I imagine otherwise any scum is going to try to claim cop before getting daykilled.

@Odd: if you're implying you're cop and got a guilty read with me in it somewhere, I'm pretty damn interested in who that other person is. If it comes down to it I don't mind dying to prove they're scum, but for that to work you need to name them beforehand.

[MAFIA] Star Trek (Limited Reveal) Mafia - Day 1

although, I re-ran the sim without the cop claiming today but town starting the daykills -- it's only marginally smaller (64%) but it feels a lot riskier if the cop goes down.

@demon: I guess the upshot of this is that scum wouldn't know the identity of /any/ of the dead players right now, correct?