ALASKANEMILY'S PROFILE

The Pronoun Game
The means of pronoun generation belong in the hands of the people!

Search

Filter

[MAFIA] Prisoner's Dilemma. Game Over

Whoops, forgot the big part...
#cancel

[MAFIA] Prisoner's Dilemma. Game Over

That role seems awfully convenient.

I'm cancelling for right now, but like...we'll see.

Would it would make the most sense to not lynch Psy, and then find it extremely suspicious if he is not NK?

@Piano: Why wouldn't scum just kill Psy instead? Your reasoning seems pretty shaky to me.

[MAFIA] Prisoner's Dilemma. Game Over

author=PlatinumAshes
Looking at Demonlords post history, he posted more reads than I remembered just now, so I don't feel as sure.


I feel pretty good about him being town. He just comes across very much in the same way as he did in the other game I was in with him. It doesn't feel to me like he's scummy.

[MAFIA] Prisoner's Dilemma. Game Over

author=ivoryjones
I am expecting to give him 3 and a half hours max. Anytime after than that if he still doesn't reply you lot might forget to hammer him.


Where does this number come from?

I also don't think people will just up and forget to vote.

[MAFIA] Prisoner's Dilemma. Game Over

Well that blew up quick.

author=demonlord5000
We still have a good amount of time. I'm still willing to vote for him, but he should have a chance to claim/defend himself.


Yeah, I guess so. Unless he comes back with something really good, I'm voting to lynch psy.

[MAFIA] Prisoner's Dilemma. Game Over

To be clear, I am also very much willing to change my vote to Psy to get a lynch.

author=tale
There's something Liberty said earlier that seems off to me.

author=Liberty
Well, if we all picked vanilla at least we know we're all equal!

Source- https://rpgmaker.net/forums/topics/24686/?post=887129#post887129


Vanilla town and vanilla mafia can be the best of friends? Maybe in the beginning but for how long.


This post feels fine to me. It was very early, there wasn't much to really say yet.

I have hard time knowing what to think of Liberty, based on what people say (like her previously wanting to nolynch D1) I'm not really sure this is scum read to me? I could believe she is just being extremely tolerant, but I could see this also be the play if she is scum with two new players.

So I don't really know what to make of her.

[MAFIA] Prisoner's Dilemma. Game Over

@Piano: It's not that I think Psy is definitely town. It's that I feel more strongly that PA is scum.

[MAFIA] Prisoner's Dilemma. Game Over

author=pianotm
Am I actually the only one here that wasn't dumb enough to know that PA's vote on me was a freaking joke? Y'all need to grow a sense of humor!


That has nothing to do with my vote.

[MAFIA] Prisoner's Dilemma. Game Over

author=psy_wombats
re: Liberty, I don't remember her playstyle as being anything than "vote nokill D1, get really aggro the moment anyone votes against her." Her reasoning for voting PA is not good. Maybe I could see a Fomar/Liberty scumteam with that massive "how to play town" post and their in-thread interactions being performative.


You believe he is telling the truth? I just find that such a strange play. It feels so much more plausible to me that he is scum, he claimed a role known to exist in this game hoping to fish for more roles and banking on at least some negative roles existing, and then it didn't work.

How could he expect that false claiming wouldn't be suspicious? That seems like it could only be confusing for town, and I have such a hard time imagining it ever even working.

[MAFIA] Prisoner's Dilemma. Game Over

I kind of have a hard time believing PA about his 'plan'. That seems like SUCH a stretch, to expect multiple people to figure that, trust he isn't scum baiting them, and then know to play along.

I also don't feel like this would be the time to even come clean, that doesn't make a lot of sense to me except if he is trolling for more information.

#lynch PlatinumAshes

Maybe we just have extremely different playstyles, but that has a serious smell to me.

I also don't feel great about Fomar, posting very rarely and then coming back after being accused to talk about rules feels off to me.