ALASKANEMILY'S PROFILE

Although he did immediately back off after the roleclaim. I do agree that the lead-up when we were first nearing hammer on Psy seemed, if not clean, at least not really scummy.

I still kind of feel like I haven't fully digested the interactions people had with Liberty, knowing now that she was scum.

The more I think about it, the more I wonder if Piano and Liberty weren't trying to turn up their argument specifically to take focus off of Psy, and then finally agreed that instead we should all vote for Shinan.

I still have this nagging feeling that the entire interaction was largely a show, on both sides. I would really prefer we lynch Piano this time.

Re:Tale, looking back I really don't like the post of nothing but a cancel. I think most of the time posts with nothing but a vote are very suspicious. But Tale also did take Psy up to one vote away from hammer, so...I'm not really sure what to think.

author=OzzyTheOne
In regards to the Fomar vote, he tried to hammer Psy. Neither Liberty nor Psy was around when the first Psy train was going. I don't think that a newbie scum would've hammered his comrades. I am now certain that Fomar is just a newbie town and not a coached scum.

That does makes sense to me. And pretty much any realistic prearranged plan for fomar to be the one to hammer probably wouldn't have played out the way it did, I think.

Sorry, I meant this game and PA's game.

Well, I am still onboard with either PA or Piano lynch for reasons I've said before.

Regarding fomar, considering a new player makes it more difficult. He has done a lot of rookie mistakes (including talking a LOT about mechanics). Psy did kind of stick up for him at one point in a tangential way (saying how he also would do stuff like running numbers and posting them). Although it was so minor I'm not sure it was really protecting scum buddy in an unobtrusive way.

He reads as very new player town or somewhat new scum, which isn't really helpful.

author=Fomar0153

author=pianotm
I thought Libby was just protecting him because she was scum chosing a townie to protect to make herself look town, which is something I often do as scum, but in retrospect I think it's entirely possible that she was actually just trying to mitigate the fact that we were on all three scum on day one.

Did you just confess?

That seems like a poor reading. I think this is just "we were on all three scum on day one".

Right now I am seriously suspicious of Piano, still.

For the lynch, when he was saying things like "you might as well vote for me", that kind of looks like a subtle way to try to get some people to switch their vote to him when town didn't just immediately think Psy was in the clear.

I also still don't feel like either side of the Liberty/Piano argument was all that...honest. I could absolutely believe they were both scum.

But like...maybe I'm just not that experienced in the ways of the mafia, but what is the deal with the scum kill? Is that just to make it...harder for town to not mislynch? Is it to sow some kind of confusion about whether our other other suspicions were correct, or were false?