DEMONLORD5000'S PROFILE

I am simply a dangerous tester. Don't believe me? Then give me a game and I'll prove it.

Fear the lord of darkness!

Search

Filter

[MAFIA] Is this Werewolf?

I believe it. Odd has a tendency to hint whatever role he has, and the op sounds like it was guaranteed to be added. I don't think it's possible for scum to hide behind a non-existing lycan role because of that.

#cancel

In that case I'm going with fomar for that inconsistency. Emily, he specifically said unless he made a mistake, I don't understand why scum would want lycan dead. This implies that he thinks I'm town, unless his phrasing is just completely foreign to me.

#lynch fomar

[MAFIA] Is this Werewolf?

Also atiya: Day 1 is always tricky because there isn't really anything to go on. Part of lynching day 1 is to be able to go back and look at who voted for who since the dead have their alignments confirmed.

[MAFIA] Is this Werewolf?

I see a contradiction in fomars post. He said it makes no sense for scum to want to lynch the lycan (I wasn't even considering odd might be the lycan at the time). He said the only reason I might want to is if I were the lycan (in which case I'd be town with a bad role). He then said he wanted to lynch me.

See the contradiction? I could get behind a fomar vote today now too.

Also side note: I won't be around for eod tomorrow. Weekdays I work from 8 - 4:30 (central time). I posted not long after I got home from work, and it looks like muffles 24 hour post was about 4 hours before that.

[MAFIA] Is this Werewolf?

I swear I don't remember seeing that, or I've completely overlooked it this whole time. I can't say odd feels any better to me for suggesting that with with the rule in play, but knowing odd I can see the viewpoint of him subtly claiming lycan. I'm going to wait and see what odd has to say before I cancel, but I'm going to rethink things through if he is the lycan.

[MAFIA] Is this Werewolf?

Also I'm a little concerned on why psy tried to make us think there weren't confirmed roles at the time. It was late when he posted that so I didn't go back and read at the time and just took it at face value and assumed I missed something. As thorough as his posts usually are, it strikes me as a bit odd.

Psy: Where did you get your information that roles weren't confirmed to be in the game?

[MAFIA] Is this Werewolf?

Can confirm I'm not lycan. Everyone joke claims every game, so yeah I didn't take the sorceror claim seriously. I actually wasn't even thinking about the lycan existing when I made that post. I don't know why you would subtly hint at it though than just outright say it..but then this is odd were talking about.

What glared out to me the most was his telling the masons to reveal themselves because I was thinking about the value of having two townies who can confirm themselves late game, as well as the risk of lowering the amount of players the seer might be.

Odd, if you are the lycan you probably should just outright say it. There really is no reason to contest a lycan claim, and I'd rather who the lycan is be known than unknown.

[MAFIA] Is this Werewolf?

Yeah, I definitely wouldn't use a claim strat if the roles aren't confirmed to be in the game. I didn't realize that either.

[MAFIA] Is this Werewolf?

Psy also makes a good point, but that also narrows down the choices for who the seer might be. I'd say it's deciding what the better risk/reward is.

[MAFIA] Is this Werewolf?

There is also something to be said for staying hidden early on, as having two masons being able to confirm themselves later in the game would be very beneficial.

If we do lose a mason early, the other one can just reveal themselves. Scum can contest it if they want, but that also means that gives us a very small selection of people to vote for, and a fairly decent chance of hitting scum.

[MAFIA] Is this Werewolf?

Odd's more recent posts lowered my opinion a bit. Joke voting on day 1 is such a common thing at this point, and the fact I remembered he was going to claim that anyways it didn't really bother me.

His more recent post where he suggests that the masons should claim looks glaringly bad to me though. The whole seer shouldn't target me also bugs me. If he's town he's making the seer curious and potentially influencing their decision, and if he scum he's trying to avoid being detected. Looks bad both ways to me, and I feel his posts are not helping us.

I could vote for atiya or odd today, but for now I'm going to do this.

#cancel
#lynch odd